Experiment 5: A student compared the transpiration rates of three plant species by measuring water loss through leaves over 4 hours under identical environmental conditions. The student sealed the roots and stems with petroleum jelly to ensure water loss occurred only through leaf surfaces.
Plant Species | Leaf Surface Area (cm²) | Water Lost (mL) | Transpiration Rate (mL/cm²/hr)
Cacti | 15 | 0.12 | 0.002
Oak | 240 | 62.4 | 0.065
Tobacco | 310 | 120.9 | 0.097
Why did the student seal the roots and stems with petroleum jelly?
- ATo prevent photosynthesis from consuming water during the measurement period.
- BTo increase the rate of water movement through the plant's vascular tissue.
- CTo prevent nutrients from entering the leaves during the experiment.
- DTo ensure any water loss measured could be attributed to transpiration through leaves only.Correct
Why D is right
By sealing all surfaces except the leaves, the student isolated transpiration as the only pathway for water loss. This is a control measure to ensure that the measured water loss reflects only leaf transpiration, not leakage or evaporation from stems or roots.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because photosynthesis uses water internally and would not be blocked by an external sealant; also, the scale of photosynthetic water use is far smaller than transpiration rates.
- B
- Incorrect because sealing external surfaces with petroleum jelly would not accelerate internal vascular flow; if anything, it would have minimal effect on xylem transport.
- C
- Incorrect because petroleum jelly on external surfaces would not block internal nutrient transport through the vascular system.
A biology class measured the rate of transpiration in bean plants using a potometer (bubble movement = 1 mm³ water loss). Experiments: Experiment 1 (Still air, 22°C, 60% humidity): rate = 2.1 mm³/min. Experiment 2 (Fan/moving air, 22°C, 60% humidity): rate = 4.8 mm³/min. Experiment 3 (Still air, 22°C, 30% humidity): rate = 5.6 mm³/min. Experiment 4 (Still air, 35°C, 60% humidity): rate = 4.3 mm³/min. Experiment 5 (Still air, 22°C, 90% humidity): rate = 0.8 mm³/min. Which experimental comparison best demonstrates the effect of humidity on transpiration rate?
- AExperiment 2 vs. Experiment 3
- BExperiments 1, 3, and 5Correct
- CExperiment 1 vs. Experiment 2
- DExperiment 1 vs. Experiment 4
Why B is right
To isolate the effect of humidity, all other variables must be identical. Experiments 1 (60% humidity), 3 (30% humidity), and 5 (90% humidity) all use still air at 22°C, varying only humidity. This comparison properly isolates humidity as the independent variable. Rates of 5.6, 2.1, and 0.8 mm³/min show that transpiration decreases as humidity increases.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Experiments 2 and 3 differ in both air movement (fan vs. still) and humidity (60% vs. 30%) simultaneously — two variables change, making it a confounded comparison.
- C
- Incorrect because Experiments 1 vs. 2 vary air movement (still vs. fan) while humidity is constant — this tests the effect of wind, not humidity.
- D
- Incorrect because Experiments 1 vs. 4 differ in temperature (22°C vs. 35°C) not humidity — this tests the effect of temperature.
A student investigated the rate of transpiration in bean plants by measuring mass loss (g) over 60 minutes under four conditions. Three plants per condition were tested and results averaged. Condition / Mass loss (g/hour) / Standard deviation (g): Control (still air, 25°C, 50% RH): 1.42 / 0.08. Fan (moving air, 25°C, 50% RH): 2.98 / 0.11. High humidity (still air, 25°C, 80% RH): 0.61 / 0.06. High temperature (still air, 35°C, 50% RH): 2.15 / 0.19. The student wants to know if the difference between the control (1.42 g/hr) and the high temperature condition (2.15 g/hr) is statistically meaningful. The standard deviations are 0.08 and 0.19, respectively. Which statement is best supported by the data?
- AWith only 3 plants per condition, the sample is too small for any conclusions about statistical significance to be made.
- BThe difference is not meaningful because the standard deviations of the two conditions overlap significantly with each other.
- CThe high temperature condition has greater variability, so no conclusions can be drawn.
- DThe difference is likely meaningful because the 0.73 g/hr gap between means far exceeds either standard deviation.Correct
Why D is right
The means differ by 0.73 g/hr (1.42 vs. 2.15), which is 0.73/0.08 = 9.1 standard deviations of the control, or 0.73/0.19 = 3.8 standard deviations of the high-temperature group. When the difference between means is many times larger than the standard deviation, the difference is almost certainly real and statistically meaningful. The larger SD in the high temperature condition reflects more variability but does not invalidate the comparison.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because n = 3 per condition is small, but paired with the large effect size (9.1 control SDs of separation), the difference is almost certainly real; this statement overstates the limitation.
- B
- Incorrect because the standard deviations (0.08 and 0.19) do not 'overlap significantly' with the difference between means (0.73); the difference is far larger than the variability.
- C
- Incorrect because greater variability in one condition increases the uncertainty but does not prevent conclusions; the effect size (difference / SD) is still large enough to support meaningful conclusions.