Skip to content
ACT · Science

Conflicting viewpoints

Conflicting viewpoints appears in 58 reviewed ACT questions and sits in Science. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Conflicting viewpoints is tested

Example 1Harder
Scientists disagree about the primary driver of coral reef bleaching events. Scientist 1: Elevated ocean temperatures are the primary cause of coral bleaching. When sea surface temperatures exceed the historical maximum by just 1–2°C for several weeks, corals expel their symbiotic zooxanthellae algae. Without algae, corals turn white (bleach) and may die. Satellite thermal data show bleaching events correspond precisely with temperature anomaly events, and global bleaching frequency has increased 5-fold since the 1980s with rising ocean temperatures. Scientist 2: While temperature stress plays a role, ocean acidification from dissolved CO2 is equally if not more damaging. Lower pH reduces the availability of carbonate ions needed to build coral skeletons, making reefs structurally weaker and slower to recover from any stress. Reefs in high-CO2 upwelling zones show chronic low coral cover regardless of temperature. The combination of acidification and temperature is synergistic, and focusing only on temperature underestimates the acidification threat. Scientist 1 would most likely respond to Scientist 2's argument about acidification by:
  1. AAgreeing that acidification and temperature are equally important and both must be addressed.
  2. BDismissing all evidence of coral reef decline as exaggerated.
  3. CClaiming that ocean acidification actually helps corals by increasing carbonate availability.
  4. DArguing that the strong temporal correlation between temperature anomalies and acute bleaching events demonstrates temperature as the primary trigger, not background acidification.Correct

Why D is right

Scientist 1's evidence focuses on the direct temporal correlation between temperature anomalies and bleaching events. A response consistent with Scientist 1's position would defend temperature as the primary acute trigger by pointing to the precise correspondence with thermal events, while not necessarily dismissing acidification as a secondary factor.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because agreeing they are equally important contradicts Scientist 1's stated position that temperature is the primary cause.
B
Incorrect because Scientist 1 does not dismiss reef decline — the argument is about mechanism (temperature vs. acidification), and Scientist 1 presents substantial evidence for bleaching.
C
Incorrect because increasing CO2 lowers pH and reduces carbonate ions; this statement is factually wrong and not consistent with any credible scientific position.
Example 2Medium
Scientists disagree about whether nuclear power should play a central role in reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Scientist 1: Nuclear power must be central to decarbonization. It produces near-zero lifecycle CO2 emissions (~5-15 g CO2/kWh, comparable to wind), can generate power 24/7 regardless of weather, and has the smallest land use per unit of energy of any source. Modern reactor designs are passively safe and produce orders of magnitude less waste per unit of energy than coal plants produce in air pollution alone. France generates 70% of its electricity from nuclear with among the lowest per-capita electricity emissions in the world. Scientist 2: Nuclear power is too expensive and too slow to build to be part of the climate solution. New nuclear plants cost $8,000–12,000/kW to build versus $800–1,200/kW for utility-scale solar. Construction takes 10–20 years. Meanwhile, renewable costs have fallen 90% in the past decade and can be deployed in 1–2 years. Capital spent on nuclear delays the rapid renewable deployment needed in the 2020s and 2030s to meet climate targets. Which consideration is NOT directly addressed by either scientist?
  1. AThe land use required for nuclear versus other energy sources.
  2. BThe cost of constructing new nuclear plants compared to utility-scale solar.
  3. CThe risk of nuclear proliferation from civilian nuclear programs.Correct
  4. DThe lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions per unit of energy for each source.

Why C is right

Scientist 1 addresses CO2 emissions, safety, land use, and capacity. Scientist 2 addresses cost and construction time. Neither scientist mentions nuclear proliferation risk — the possibility that civilian nuclear programs could increase access to weapons-grade materials.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because Scientist 1 specifically mentions that nuclear has the smallest land use per unit of energy of any source.
B
Incorrect because Scientist 2 directly compares construction costs ($8,000–12,000/kW for nuclear vs. $800–1,200/kW for utility-scale solar).
D
Incorrect because Scientist 1 explicitly states nuclear produces near-zero lifecycle CO2 (~5-15 g CO2/kWh, comparable to wind).
Example 3Medium
Scientists disagree about the cause of the Younger Dryas cooling event (~12,800 years ago). Scientist 1: A comet impact caused it, evidenced by nanodiamonds, spherules, and platinum/iridium spikes at the 12,800-year horizon in sediment cores worldwide. Scientist 2: Glacial meltwater disrupted Atlantic ocean circulation (AMOC), supported by oceanographic models and salinity proxies. The supposed impact markers have non-impact explanations. Which evidence would most directly support Scientist 2's meltwater hypothesis over Scientist 1's impact hypothesis?
  1. ADiscovery of additional nanodiamonds at the 12,800-year horizon in Antarctica
  2. BIdentification of a large impact crater dated to approximately 12,800 years ago
  3. CSediment cores showing a sharp freshwater influx into the North Atlantic coinciding with AMOC slowdown at 12,800 years agoCorrect
  4. DEvidence that platinum concentrations at 12,800 years ago match a known comet composition

Why C is right

Scientist 2's hypothesis depends on a large influx of fresh glacial meltwater disrupting North Atlantic circulation at 12,800 years ago. Sediment cores documenting a sharp freshwater pulse (salinity drop) coinciding with AMOC slowdown at precisely this time would directly confirm the proposed mechanism.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because additional nanodiamonds at the same horizon would strengthen the impact hypothesis (Scientist 1's evidence), not support Scientist 2.
B
Incorrect because an impact crater dated to 12,800 years ago would be the most direct evidence for Scientist 1's impact hypothesis, not Scientist 2's.
D
Incorrect because platinum matching comet composition would also support the impact hypothesis, strengthening Scientist 1's position.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Science.