Figure 2 describes a scatter plot of air pollution (PM2.5 concentration, y-axis, 0–80 μg/m³) versus hospital admissions for respiratory disease per 100,000 residents (x-axis, 0–250 per 100,000) for 30 cities. The data points form a positive correlation with a moderately strong R² value of 0.68. Several outlier cities appear with high pollution but lower-than-expected admissions, and two cities with low pollution but high admissions.
A public health official uses these data to argue that reducing air pollution will directly reduce hospital admissions. A critic challenges this conclusion. Which criticism is most scientifically valid?
- ACorrelation does not prove causation; other factors (smoking rates, age demographics, access to care) may explain some of the relationship.Correct
- BThe R² value of 0.68 means the data are unreliable.
- CThirty cities is too small a sample to see any trend.
- DThe scatter plot uses the wrong units for pollution measurement.
Why A is right
The fundamental limitation of observational correlation data is that they cannot establish causation. The outliers noted (high pollution with low admissions, low pollution with high admissions) suggest other variables are at play. A valid scientific critique recognizes that correlation, while suggestive, does not prove the causal mechanism the official claims.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because R² = 0.68 means 68% of variance in admissions is associated with pollution levels — a moderately strong relationship, not evidence of unreliability.
- C
- Incorrect because 30 cities is a reasonable sample size for detecting ecological correlations, and the moderate R² (0.68) suggests a discernible trend, not an absence of one.
- D
- Incorrect because PM2.5 (particulate matter ≤2.5 μm) in μg/m³ is the standard epidemiological unit for air quality; the units are appropriate.
Scientists disagree about whether near work (screens/reading) or lack of outdoor time is the primary driver of rising childhood myopia rates.
Scientist 2 argues outdoor time protects against myopia via bright light stimulating retinal dopamine.
A new study finds that children who use tablets outdoors in bright sunlight show myopia rates comparable to children who do not use tablets at all. Which scientist's position does this finding most directly support?
- AScientist 2, because bright outdoor light protected against myopia even with near-work screen use.Correct
- BNeither scientist, because the finding is unrelated to either hypothesis.
- CBoth scientists equally, because the study included both screens and outdoor activity.
- DScientist 1, because tablets were involved in the study.
Why A is right
The finding that tablet use outdoors does not increase myopia risk compared to no tablet use directly supports Scientist 2's hypothesis: bright outdoor light (not the reduction of near work) is the protective factor. Screen use in the presence of bright outdoor light does not increase myopia, isolating outdoor light, not absence of screens, as the key variable.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the finding directly tests the central dispute between the scientists — outdoor light exposure vs. near work — and provides relevant evidence.
- C
- Incorrect because the finding clearly distinguishes the two hypotheses; bright outdoor light appears to eliminate the effect of screen use, isolating light exposure as the protective variable.
- D
- Incorrect because Scientist 1 argues near work (like tablets) causes myopia. This finding shows tablets outdoors don't cause myopia, which contradicts rather than supports Scientist 1.
Scientists disagree about whether pharmaceutical marketing (Scientist 1) or socioeconomic factors (Scientist 2) primarily drive opioid addiction rates.
A public health researcher finds that in states where Medicaid covers addiction treatment, opioid overdose death rates are 30% lower than in states without such coverage, regardless of prescription rates. Which scientist's position does this finding most support?
- AScientist 1, because Medicaid coverage relates to pharmaceutical policy.
- BNeither, because the finding concerns treatment outcomes, not what causes addiction in the first place.
- CBoth equally, because both scientists would agree that better treatment access reduces overdose deaths.
- DScientist 2, because treatment access, a social support factor, cut deaths regardless of prescribing.Correct
Why D is right
Scientist 2 argues that social support and economic conditions are primary drivers, and that outcomes vary independently of prescription rates. Treatment access (a social support structure) reducing deaths regardless of prescription rates is consistent with Scientist 2's framework emphasizing social/economic interventions over pharmaceutical supply reduction.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Medicaid is a government program providing social support (treatment access), not a pharmaceutical marketing or prescribing regulation — it relates more closely to Scientist 2's emphasis on social structures.
- B
- Incorrect because treatment efficacy is directly relevant to understanding what reduces overdose outcomes, which is part of the debate about which interventions (supply-side vs. social support) work.
- C
- Incorrect because while both scientists might broadly support better treatment, the finding that outcomes differ by treatment access independent of prescription rates specifically aligns with Scientist 2's emphasis on social factors over pharmaceutical supply.