Skip to content
ACT · Science

Paleoclimatology

Paleoclimatology appears in 5 reviewed ACT questions and sits in Science. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Paleoclimatology is tested

Example 1Medium
Scientists disagree about the cause of the Younger Dryas cooling event (~12,800 years ago). Scientist 1: A comet impact caused it, evidenced by nanodiamonds, spherules, and platinum/iridium spikes at the 12,800-year horizon in sediment cores worldwide. Scientist 2: Glacial meltwater disrupted Atlantic ocean circulation (AMOC), supported by oceanographic models and salinity proxies. The supposed impact markers have non-impact explanations. Which evidence would most directly support Scientist 2's meltwater hypothesis over Scientist 1's impact hypothesis?
  1. ADiscovery of additional nanodiamonds at the 12,800-year horizon in Antarctica
  2. BIdentification of a large impact crater dated to approximately 12,800 years ago
  3. CSediment cores showing a sharp freshwater influx into the North Atlantic coinciding with AMOC slowdown at 12,800 years agoCorrect
  4. DEvidence that platinum concentrations at 12,800 years ago match a known comet composition

Why C is right

Scientist 2's hypothesis depends on a large influx of fresh glacial meltwater disrupting North Atlantic circulation at 12,800 years ago. Sediment cores documenting a sharp freshwater pulse (salinity drop) coinciding with AMOC slowdown at precisely this time would directly confirm the proposed mechanism.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because additional nanodiamonds at the same horizon would strengthen the impact hypothesis (Scientist 1's evidence), not support Scientist 2.
B
Incorrect because an impact crater dated to 12,800 years ago would be the most direct evidence for Scientist 1's impact hypothesis, not Scientist 2's.
D
Incorrect because platinum matching comet composition would also support the impact hypothesis, strengthening Scientist 1's position.
Example 2Easier
Experiment 5: A geologist analyzed core samples from a lake bed to reconstruct a 10,000-year history of the local climate. By measuring the ratio of oxygen-18 to oxygen-16 (δ¹⁸O) in fossilized shells — a proxy for past water temperature — the geologist created the following record: Time Period (years ago) | δ¹⁸O (‰) | Inferred Temperature 10,000 | -8.2 | Cool 8,000 | -6.1 | Warm 6,000 | -5.8 | Warmest 4,000 | -6.4 | Warm 2,000 | -7.1 | Moderately cool Present | -7.8 | Cool Note: More negative δ¹⁸O values indicate cooler conditions; less negative values indicate warmer conditions. During which time period was the lake environment warmest, based on the proxy data?
  1. A10,000 years ago
  2. B6,000 years agoCorrect
  3. CPresent
  4. D8,000 years ago

Why B is right

The δ¹⁸O value at 6,000 years ago is -5.8‰, the least negative value in the dataset. According to the note that less negative δ¹⁸O indicates warmer conditions, -5.8‰ corresponds to the warmest period, labeled 'Warmest' in the table.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because 10,000 years ago shows the most negative δ¹⁸O value (-8.2‰), indicating the coolest conditions in the dataset.
C
Incorrect because the present shows δ¹⁸O of -7.8‰, one of the cooler values in the record, not the warmest.
D
Incorrect because 8,000 years ago was warm (-6.1‰), but 6,000 years ago (-5.8‰) was even warmer based on the less-negative value.
Example 3Medium
Experiment 4: A geologist extracted ice core samples from a Greenland glacier and analyzed trapped air bubbles to reconstruct atmospheric CO2 concentrations and temperature proxies over the last 400,000 years. Data from key time periods: Time Period | CO2 (ppm) | Relative Temp Change (°C) 400,000 years ago | 180 | -7 300,000 years ago | 280 | +2 200,000 years ago | 195 | -6 130,000 years ago | 290 | +4 20,000 years ago (LGM) | 180 | -8 280 years ago (pre-industrial) | 280 | 0 Present day | 420 | +1.2 Note: Temperature change relative to pre-industrial average. Based on the ice core data, which CO2 concentration is associated with warmer periods?
  1. ACO2 concentrations above 300 ppm are associated with cooler glacial periods.
  2. BCO2 concentrations near 280–290 ppm are associated with warmer periods.Correct
  3. CCO2 concentration and temperature show no consistent relationship.
  4. DCO2 concentrations below 200 ppm are associated with warmer interglacial periods.

Why B is right

Comparing the data: periods with CO2 ~280–290 ppm (300k years ago, 130k years ago, pre-industrial) correspond to positive or near-zero temperature anomalies (+2, +4, 0°C). Periods with CO2 ~180–195 ppm (400k, 200k, 20k years ago) correspond to the coldest temperatures (-7, -6, -8°C). This consistent pattern shows higher CO2 correlated with warmer temperatures.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the data show the opposite: temperatures at 420 ppm are the warmest (+1.2°C), and cooler periods occur at lower CO2 (~180 ppm).
C
Incorrect because there is a clear and consistent positive relationship between CO2 and temperature across all data points.
D
Incorrect because below 200 ppm CO2 corresponds to the coldest glacial periods (-6 to -8°C), not warmer interglacial ones.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Science.