Scientists disagree about the cause of the Younger Dryas cooling event (~12,800 years ago).
Scientist 1: A comet impact caused it, evidenced by nanodiamonds, spherules, and platinum/iridium spikes at the 12,800-year horizon in sediment cores worldwide.
Scientist 2: Glacial meltwater disrupted Atlantic ocean circulation (AMOC), supported by oceanographic models and salinity proxies. The supposed impact markers have non-impact explanations.
Which evidence would most directly support Scientist 2's meltwater hypothesis over Scientist 1's impact hypothesis?
- ADiscovery of additional nanodiamonds at the 12,800-year horizon in Antarctica
- BIdentification of a large impact crater dated to approximately 12,800 years ago
- CSediment cores showing a sharp freshwater influx into the North Atlantic coinciding with AMOC slowdown at 12,800 years agoCorrect
- DEvidence that platinum concentrations at 12,800 years ago match a known comet composition
Why C is right
Scientist 2's hypothesis depends on a large influx of fresh glacial meltwater disrupting North Atlantic circulation at 12,800 years ago. Sediment cores documenting a sharp freshwater pulse (salinity drop) coinciding with AMOC slowdown at precisely this time would directly confirm the proposed mechanism.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because additional nanodiamonds at the same horizon would strengthen the impact hypothesis (Scientist 1's evidence), not support Scientist 2.
- B
- Incorrect because an impact crater dated to 12,800 years ago would be the most direct evidence for Scientist 1's impact hypothesis, not Scientist 2's.
- D
- Incorrect because platinum matching comet composition would also support the impact hypothesis, strengthening Scientist 1's position.
Experiment 5: A geologist analyzed core samples from a lake bed to reconstruct a 10,000-year history of the local climate. By measuring the ratio of oxygen-18 to oxygen-16 (δ¹⁸O) in fossilized shells — a proxy for past water temperature — the geologist created the following record:
Time Period (years ago) | δ¹⁸O (‰) | Inferred Temperature
10,000 | -8.2 | Cool
8,000 | -6.1 | Warm
6,000 | -5.8 | Warmest
4,000 | -6.4 | Warm
2,000 | -7.1 | Moderately cool
Present | -7.8 | Cool
Note: More negative δ¹⁸O values indicate cooler conditions; less negative values indicate warmer conditions.
During which time period was the lake environment warmest, based on the proxy data?
- A10,000 years ago
- B6,000 years agoCorrect
- CPresent
- D8,000 years ago
Why B is right
The δ¹⁸O value at 6,000 years ago is -5.8‰, the least negative value in the dataset. According to the note that less negative δ¹⁸O indicates warmer conditions, -5.8‰ corresponds to the warmest period, labeled 'Warmest' in the table.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because 10,000 years ago shows the most negative δ¹⁸O value (-8.2‰), indicating the coolest conditions in the dataset.
- C
- Incorrect because the present shows δ¹⁸O of -7.8‰, one of the cooler values in the record, not the warmest.
- D
- Incorrect because 8,000 years ago was warm (-6.1‰), but 6,000 years ago (-5.8‰) was even warmer based on the less-negative value.
Experiment 4: A geologist extracted ice core samples from a Greenland glacier and analyzed trapped air bubbles to reconstruct atmospheric CO2 concentrations and temperature proxies over the last 400,000 years. Data from key time periods:
Time Period | CO2 (ppm) | Relative Temp Change (°C)
400,000 years ago | 180 | -7
300,000 years ago | 280 | +2
200,000 years ago | 195 | -6
130,000 years ago | 290 | +4
20,000 years ago (LGM) | 180 | -8
280 years ago (pre-industrial) | 280 | 0
Present day | 420 | +1.2
Note: Temperature change relative to pre-industrial average.
Based on the ice core data, which CO2 concentration is associated with warmer periods?
- ACO2 concentrations above 300 ppm are associated with cooler glacial periods.
- BCO2 concentrations near 280–290 ppm are associated with warmer periods.Correct
- CCO2 concentration and temperature show no consistent relationship.
- DCO2 concentrations below 200 ppm are associated with warmer interglacial periods.
Why B is right
Comparing the data: periods with CO2 ~280–290 ppm (300k years ago, 130k years ago, pre-industrial) correspond to positive or near-zero temperature anomalies (+2, +4, 0°C). Periods with CO2 ~180–195 ppm (400k, 200k, 20k years ago) correspond to the coldest temperatures (-7, -6, -8°C). This consistent pattern shows higher CO2 correlated with warmer temperatures.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the data show the opposite: temperatures at 420 ppm are the warmest (+1.2°C), and cooler periods occur at lower CO2 (~180 ppm).
- C
- Incorrect because there is a clear and consistent positive relationship between CO2 and temperature across all data points.
- D
- Incorrect because below 200 ppm CO2 corresponds to the coldest glacial periods (-6 to -8°C), not warmer interglacial ones.