Skip to content
ACT · Science

Mass extinction

Mass extinction appears in 3 reviewed ACT questions and sits in Science. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Mass extinction is tested

Example 1Harder
Scientists disagree about the mechanism of mass extinctions in Earth's history. Scientist 1: The primary cause of major mass extinctions, including the end-Cretaceous event 66 million years ago, was bolide (asteroid or comet) impacts. The Chicxulub impact released energy equivalent to billions of nuclear bombs, ignited global wildfires, ejected debris that blocked sunlight for years, causing photosynthesis collapse and food chain disruption. The global iridium layer and shocked quartz at the K-Pg boundary are direct physical evidence of this impact. Scientist 2: Massive volcanic eruptions — specifically flood basalt provinces like the Deccan Traps — were the dominant driver of major extinctions. These eruptions released enormous volumes of CO2, SO2, and other gases over tens of thousands of years, causing long-term climate warming, ocean acidification, and ecological stress before and after any impact event. Evidence shows that extinction rates began rising before the Chicxulub impact, suggesting pre-impact volcanic activity was already stressing ecosystems. Scientist 1 would most likely respond to the evidence about rising extinction rates before the Chicxulub impact by arguing:
  1. ABackground extinction rates fluctuate naturally, and the pre-impact increases were within normal variation.Correct
  2. BThe Deccan Traps actually began erupting because of the Chicxulub impact, making volcanoes a consequence, not a cause.
  3. CThe iridium layer at the K-Pg boundary was deposited over thousands of years, not instantaneously.
  4. DNo fossil evidence of ecosystem stress exists before the K-Pg boundary.

Why A is right

Scientist 1 would defend the impact hypothesis by arguing that the observed pre-impact extinctions don't exceed normal variation, preserving the asteroid impact as the primary causal agent for the mass extinction event itself.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because while some scientists do argue that the Chicxulub impact may have intensified Deccan volcanism, this is a nuanced position not directly implied by Scientist 1's stated reasoning in the passage.
C
Incorrect because arguing the iridium layer was deposited gradually would actually weaken Scientist 1's case for a sudden impact event, since iridium enrichment is the key evidence for a single impact.
D
Incorrect because Scientist 2 explicitly mentions fossil evidence of rising extinction rates before the impact, so flatly denying this evidence would be unreasonable for Scientist 1 to assert without data.
Example 2Easier
Scientist 1: Human activities are the primary cause of the ongoing sixth mass extinction. The current rate of species loss is estimated at 100–1,000 times the background extinction rate, driven by habitat destruction, pollution, invasive species, overhunting, and climate change. Fossil records show that natural background extinction rates are approximately 0.1 extinctions per million species per year; current rates far exceed this. Scientist 2: Extinction rate estimates are highly uncertain and likely overstated. Many 'extinct' species are later rediscovered, and estimates based on species-area relationships assume equilibrium conditions that may not apply on short timescales. The true extinction rate may be 10–100 times lower than claimed. Natural climate fluctuations have caused comparable extinction pulses in the past without human involvement, suggesting current losses may be within natural variation.
  1. AScientist 1 argues that current extinction rates are dramatically higher than background rates; Scientist 2 questions the reliability of these estimates and notes natural historical precedents.Correct
  2. BBoth scientists agree that current extinction rates are 100 to 1,000 times the background rate.
  3. CScientist 2 denies that any species are going extinct in the current era.
  4. DBoth scientists agree that habitat destruction is the dominant cause of modern extinctions.

Why A is right

Scientist 1 claims rates are 100–1,000 times above background, driven by human activities. Scientist 2 argues estimates are uncertain, rates may be overstated, and natural fluctuations have produced comparable events. Answer A accurately summarizes the position of each scientist. Neither denies extinction entirely, and Scientist 2 does not identify habitat destruction as the main cause.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because Scientist 2 disputes these rate estimates, arguing the true rate may be 10–100 times lower than claimed.
C
Incorrect because Scientist 2 does not deny current extinctions; they question the magnitude of the rate estimates.
D
Incorrect because only Scientist 1 identifies human-driven causes; Scientist 2 emphasizes natural climate fluctuations as a comparator.
Example 3Medium
Two scientists discuss the primary cause of the mass extinction event at the end of the Cretaceous period, approximately 66 million years ago. Scientist 1: The mass extinction was caused primarily by a massive asteroid impact near what is now the Yucatan Peninsula in Mexico. The impact created the Chicxulub crater and ejected enormous quantities of dust and sulfur aerosols into the atmosphere, blocking sunlight for months to years and collapsing photosynthesis-based food chains. The iridium-rich layer found worldwide at the Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary is consistent with an extraterrestrial source. Scientist 2: While the asteroid impact certainly occurred, the mass extinction was already underway due to massive volcanic eruptions known as the Deccan Traps. These eruptions lasted over 500,000 years and released vast quantities of carbon dioxide and sulfur dioxide, causing severe climate disruption and ocean acidification long before the asteroid arrived. Fossil evidence shows that many species were already declining before the impact. Both scientists would most likely agree with which of the following statements?
  1. AVolcanic eruptions were the primary driver of the mass extinction.
  2. BThe iridium layer at the Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary was produced by volcanic activity.
  3. CDinosaur populations were thriving immediately before the asteroid impact.
  4. DThe asteroid impact occurred at about the end of the Cretaceous period.Correct

Why D is right

Both scientists acknowledge that the asteroid impact occurred. Scientist 1 presents it as the primary cause, while Scientist 2 acknowledges it occurred ('the asteroid impact certainly occurred') but argues it was a contributing factor. Both agree the impact happened at the end of the Cretaceous.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because only Scientist 2 emphasizes volcanic eruptions as a major driver. Scientist 1 attributes the extinction primarily to the asteroid impact.
B
Incorrect because Scientist 1 explicitly states the iridium layer is 'consistent with an extraterrestrial source,' attributing it to the asteroid, not volcanism.
C
Incorrect because Scientist 2 explicitly states that 'many species were already declining before the impact.' Scientist 1 does not claim dinosaurs were thriving.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Science.