Experiment 8: A physics student dropped steel balls of varying masses from a height of 2 meters onto a sand pit and measured the diameter of the crater formed.
Mass (g) | Crater Diameter (cm)
10 | 2.1
20 | 2.6
40 | 3.3
80 | 4.1
160 | 5.2
A classmate argues that doubling the mass should double the crater diameter. Based on the data, is the classmate's prediction correct?
- ANo, because the relationship between mass and crater diameter is random.
- BNo, because crater diameter increases when mass doubles but at less than a 2:1 ratio.Correct
- CYes, because crater diameter doubles each time mass doubles.
- DNo, because crater diameter decreases when mass doubles.
Why B is right
Each doubling of mass does increase crater diameter, but not by a factor of 2. For example, from 10 g to 20 g (doubled), diameter goes from 2.1 to 2.6 cm (a factor of ~1.24, not 2). The increase is real but sub-linear.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because there is a clear pattern: diameter increases with mass in a consistent, non-random way.
- C
- Incorrect because the diameter does not double when mass doubles; for example, from 80 g (4.1 cm) to 160 g (5.2 cm), diameter increases by only 27%, not 100%.
- D
- Incorrect because crater diameter consistently increases with mass — it does not decrease.
Experiment 2: Researchers measured the effect of nitrogen fertilizer on crop yield (tons per hectare) in corn fields. Each plot received identical amounts of water and sunlight.
Nitrogen Applied (kg/hectare) | Corn Yield (tons/hectare)
0 | 2.1
50 | 5.4
100 | 8.2
150 | 9.8
200 | 10.3
250 | 10.4
300 | 9.6
A farmer currently applies 200 kg/hectare of nitrogen. Based on the data, what is the most economically rational adjustment?
- ADecrease nitrogen to 100 kg/hectare to reduce costs while maintaining yield.
- BReduce nitrogen slightly toward 150–200 kg/hectare, as yields have plateaued and more adds little gain.Correct
- CEliminate nitrogen application entirely since yields at 300 kg/hectare are lower than at 200 kg/hectare.
- DIncrease nitrogen to 300 kg/hectare to maximize fertilizer investment.
Why B is right
Yield increases steeply from 0 to 150 kg/hectare but nearly plateaus at 200–250 kg/hectare (10.3–10.4 tons). The marginal gain from 150 to 200 kg is only 0.5 tons, and adding more beyond 200 kg actually decreases yield (300 kg → 9.6 tons). The farmer is already near the optimal zone.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because dropping to 100 kg/hectare would reduce yield from 10.3 to 8.2 tons/hectare — a significant loss — while the cost savings might not compensate for lost production.
- C
- Incorrect because eliminating nitrogen entirely reduces yield to just 2.1 tons/hectare, a drastic decline from the current 10.3 tons; this would be economically devastating.
- D
- Incorrect because 300 kg/hectare actually yields less (9.6 tons) than 200 kg/hectare (10.3 tons), so increasing nitrogen beyond current levels is counterproductive.
Experiment 7: A nutritionist studied how different dietary interventions affect fasting blood glucose levels in pre-diabetic adults over 12 weeks. Three groups of 30 adults each received different interventions:
Group | Intervention | Mean Glucose at Start (mg/dL) | Mean Glucose at 12 Weeks (mg/dL) | Change
Group 1 | No change (control) | 112 | 115 | +3
Group 2 | 30 min aerobic exercise/day | 113 | 98 | -15
Group 3 | Low-carbohydrate diet | 111 | 95 | -16
A participant in Group 2 starts at 118 mg/dL. Based on the study results, what glucose level would be predicted after 12 weeks of intervention?
- A115 mg/dL
- B121 mg/dL
- C98 mg/dL
- D103 mg/dLCorrect
Why D is right
Group 2 showed a mean decrease of 15 mg/dL. Applying this reduction to a starting level of 118 mg/dL: 118 - 15 = 103 mg/dL. The data and relationship in the passage point to this result more directly than the other choices.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because 115 mg/dL is the control group's final value and corresponds to a slight increase, not the 15 mg/dL decrease seen in Group 2.
- B
- Incorrect because 121 mg/dL represents an increase of 3 mg/dL, consistent with the control group's trend, not Group 2's exercise intervention.
- C
- Incorrect because 98 mg/dL is the group mean ending value, not what an individual starting at 118 mg/dL would reach; the prediction should apply the mean change (-15) to the individual's starting value.