"In the present condition of the country, I think the annexation of Texas and the war with Mexico are the greatest and most criminal blunders of our government."
—Daniel Webster, U.S. Senator from Massachusetts, ca. 1848
Which of the following most directly reflects the underlying concern expressed in Webster's opposition to the Mexican-American War?
- AWebster's belief that the United States lacked the military capability to defeat Mexico in a prolonged conflict far from its industrial base
- BWebster's commitment to the constitutional principle that only Congress, not the president acting alone, held the authority to declare war
- CWebster's financial ties to Massachusetts textile manufacturers who opposed any expansion of cotton cultivation into the newly acquired Southwest
- DWebster's fear that territory taken from Mexico would reopen the divisive debate over slavery's extension into the West and threaten the survival of the UnionCorrect
Why D is right
Webster's opposition to the Mexican-American War reflected his overriding concern for Union preservation. He feared—correctly, as events proved—that new territories acquired from Mexico would reignite the slavery extension debate, potentially splitting the nation along sectional lines. The Wilmot Proviso debate during the war demonstrated exactly this dynamic, previewing the sectional crises of the 1850s.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Mexico was significantly weaker militarily and the war resulted in a rapid American victory; this was not a serious concern for Webster.
- B
- Incorrect because while Whigs like Webster did question Polk's unilateral actions, Webster's primary opposition was substantive (the consequences of expansion), not merely procedural (separation of powers).
- C
- Incorrect because Massachusetts textile manufacturers actually benefited from Southern cotton and often had pro-Southern economic interests; this is an inaccurate characterization of Webster's constituency.