"Our new government is founded upon exactly the opposite idea [of equality]; its foundations are laid, its cornerstone rests upon the great truth that the negro is not equal to the white man; that slavery — subordination to the superior race — is his natural and normal condition. This, our new government, is the first, in the history of the world, based upon this great physical, philosophical, and moral truth." — Alexander H. Stephens, Confederate Vice President, Cornerstone Speech, March 1861
A historian could best use this source to support which of the following arguments?
- AConfederate leaders privately regarded slavery as morally indefensible and intended to phase it out gradually once independence from the Union had been secured by force
- BStephens spoke for a small Confederate faction tying secession to slavery, while most Confederates seceded chiefly over tariff policy and constitutional disputes unrelated to slavery
- CConfederate leaders publicly named racial slavery and white supremacy as the Confederacy's founding principles, contradicting later 'Lost Cause' claims of states' rights or tariffsCorrect
- DThe Confederate constitution, as Stephens explained it, matched the U.S. Constitution in nearly all respects, differing only in a few minor adjustments to federal trade and tariff policy
Why C is right
Stephens's Cornerstone Speech is one of the most historically significant documents on the causes of secession precisely because it is an explicit, unambiguous statement by the Confederate Vice President that racial slavery and white supremacy were the Confederacy's foundational principles. Historians cite this speech against 'Lost Cause' narratives that attribute secession to abstract states' rights or economic causes unrelated to slavery: the Confederate leaders themselves stated clearly that slavery was their cornerstone.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Stephens's speech expresses pride and confidence in the Confederacy's proslavery foundation, not secret abolitionist planning; Confederate leadership consistently defended slavery as the proper and permanent condition of African Americans.
- B
- Incorrect because Stephens was the Confederate Vice President, not a minority faction leader; his speech was a public address, not a private communication; and his 'cornerstone' framing reflected Confederate leadership's public position, not a minority view.
- D
- Incorrect because Stephens explicitly contrasts the Confederate constitution's 'cornerstone' of racial inequality with the U.S. Constitution's founding principle of equality; he is not claiming the two constitutions were identical.
"The 'Lost Cause' mythology emerged in Southern memory after the Civil War to explain Confederate defeat without acknowledging slavery as the war's cause. Lost Cause advocates argued that the South had fought for states' rights and constitutional principle; that Confederate soldiers had been betrayed by Northern industrial advantages rather than outfought; that slavery had been benevolent; and that Reconstruction had been a period of corrupt 'negro rule' that required white 'redemption.' These myths dominated textbooks and popular culture for decades." — Lost Cause historiography, 2016
The argument made in this passage most closely reflects which of the following historical developments?
- AThe 'Lost Cause' was a narrowly academic phenomenon confined to a handful of Southern university history departments, leaving popular culture, public monuments, and general historical understanding of the war essentially untouched by its arguments
- BThe 'Lost Cause' mythology was promptly discredited by contemporary documentary evidence and thereafter exerted no lasting influence on how subsequent American generations understood either the Civil War or the Reconstruction era that followed it
- CThe 'Lost Cause' offers a fundamentally accurate account of the Civil War and Reconstruction that has been unfairly dismissed by partisan Northern historians intent on distorting the South's constitutional case for secession
- DThe 'Lost Cause' shows how defeated societies reconstruct historical memory to obscure uncomfortable truths, here misrepresenting the causes of the Civil War and the nature of Reconstruction to rehabilitate the ConfederacyCorrect
Why D is right
Historians analyze the 'Lost Cause' as a deliberate reconstruction of historical memory that served political purposes: it rehabilitated the Confederacy by reframing secession as a noble constitutional cause rather than a defense of slavery; it justified the violent overthrow of Reconstruction as 'redemption' from corrupt 'negro rule'; and it maintained the racial hierarchy of slavery under new institutional forms by legitimizing post-Reconstruction disenfranchisement and Jim Crow. The mythology's power lay precisely in its systematic misrepresentation of documented historical reality.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the 'Lost Cause' dominated popular culture through novels (Gone With the Wind), film (Birth of a Nation), Confederate monuments, and school textbooks for generations; it was far from an academic phenomenon with limited cultural reach.
- B
- Incorrect because 'Lost Cause' mythology shaped American popular understanding of the Civil War for a century, influencing monument placement, textbook content, and popular representations; its influence was extensive and persistent, not rapidly discredited.
- C
- Incorrect because the 'Lost Cause' mythology directly contradicts contemporary Confederate documents (Stephens's Cornerstone Speech, secession declarations) that explicitly state slavery was the Confederacy's cause; characterizing it as 'accurate history unfairly dismissed' endorses the mythology.