The Radical Republicans in Congress, led by Thaddeus Stevens and Charles Sumner, argued for a thorough transformation of southern society during Reconstruction. Thaddeus Stevens declared in 1865: 'The foundations of their institutions, political, municipal and social must be broken up and relaid, or all our blood and treasure have been spent in vain. This can only be done by treating and holding them as a conquered province and subjecting them to military occupation... The whole fabric of southern society must be changed, and never can it be done if this opportunity is lost.' Stevens advocated distributing confiscated Confederate lands to freedpeople.
Stevens's call for land redistribution most directly reflected which of the following Radical Republican beliefs?
- AThe belief that legal equality without economic independence would leave freedpeople vulnerable to renewed coercion and exploitation by their former enslavers.Correct
- BThe belief that Reconstruction should follow Andrew Johnson's plan for rapid readmission, leaving power in the hands of former Confederate elites.
- CThe belief that freedpeople would be most secure by emigrating to northern industrial cities rather than remaining in the South as farm laborers.
- DThe belief in a command economy in which the federal government would permanently own and manage all southern agricultural production.
Why A is right
Stevens understood that without economic independence—land of their own—freedpeople would remain dependent on their former enslavers, who could use that dependence to recreate conditions approaching slavery through sharecropping and tenant farming; in his view, land redistribution was essential to meaningful freedom.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because Stevens explicitly opposed Johnson's lenient plan; his demand to treat the South as a 'conquered province' directly contradicts rapid readmission that preserved Confederate elites' power.
- C
- Incorrect because Stevens argued freedpeople needed land in the South, where their labor had been extracted; he advocated southern land redistribution, not northern migration.
- D
- Incorrect because Stevens sought to give confiscated land to freedpeople as independent owners, not to establish permanent federal ownership or central control of southern agriculture.