"I see one-third of a nation ill-housed, ill-clad, ill-nourished. It is not in despair that I paint you that picture. I paint it in hope — because the nation, seeing and understanding the injustice in it, proposes to paint it out." — Franklin D. Roosevelt, Second Inaugural Address, January 20, 1937
A historian could best use this source to support which of the following arguments?
- ARoosevelt's Second Inaugural Address represented a concession to New Deal critics that his programs had failed, since one-third of the nation remained in poverty four years after he took office
- BRoosevelt's statement responded to the success of the New Deal, noting that the remaining one-third in poverty consisted of those who had refused to participate in federal relief programs offered since 1933
- CThe 'one-third of a nation' statistic cited by Roosevelt referred exclusively to elderly Americans who had not yet begun receiving Social Security old-age benefits established in 1935
- DSignificant poverty persisted in 1937 despite four years of New Deal programs, and Roosevelt acknowledged this while voicing confidence that continued government action could address itCorrect
Why D is right
Roosevelt's famous 'one-third of a nation' phrase — one of the most quoted lines in Presidential inaugural history — acknowledged that despite the New Deal's achievements, mass poverty persisted in 1937. Unemployment was still over 14%, millions lacked adequate housing and nutrition, and the Social Security Act had not yet begun making payments. Rather than treating this as defeat, Roosevelt frames it as challenge — progress had been made but more was needed. The Second Inaugural reflects the reformist confidence of Roosevelt's 1936 landslide victory and his commitment to continuing New Deal expansion.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Roosevelt frames the statistic not as concession of failure but as a challenge to continue — 'I paint it in hope'; the tone is reform-minded optimism, not defeated admission of failure.
- B
- Incorrect because there is no suggestion in the passage or historical record that Roosevelt blamed poverty victims for not participating in programs; New Deal relief was reaching millions but was inadequate to fully address Depression-era poverty.
- C
- Incorrect because the 'one-third of a nation' referred to the overall population experiencing poverty across multiple dimensions — housing, clothing, nutrition — not specifically the elderly or any single demographic group.