"The South...will never submit to be governed by a Black Republican President...elected by Northern votes alone, pledged to the restriction of slavery...We will secede from this Union the moment such a President is elected."
—Southern newspaper editorial, ca. 1860
Which of the following most directly explains why Southern states carried through with this threat after Lincoln's election?
- AHis election was read as the political fulfillment of John Brown's Harpers Ferry raid, which many Southerners believed had been secretly financed and sanctioned by the Republican Party
- BHis election proved a president could win without a single Southern electoral vote, signaling that the South had permanently lost the leverage needed to protect slaveryCorrect
- CThe states seceded chiefly over the protective tariff burdening cotton exports, invoking slavery only as rhetorical cover for a grievance that was fundamentally economic
- DHe had pledged during the 1860 campaign to use federal power to abolish slavery immediately in every Southern state upon taking office
Why B is right
Lincoln received no electoral votes from the Deep South and still won the presidency. This alarmed Southern leaders because it demonstrated that a president entirely opposed to slavery's expansion could be elected without any Southern support—a precedent that suggested the South would permanently lose political influence as the North's population and electoral votes grew. Secessionists concluded that the Union could no longer protect slavery's future.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while Southerners suspected Republican complicity in Brown's raid, Lincoln explicitly condemned Brown's methods; this was not the primary reason for carrying through the secession threat.
- C
- Incorrect because while tariffs were a secondary grievance, secession declarations and Confederate founding documents explicitly identified slavery's protection as the primary cause; the 'tariff caused secession' argument is a Lost Cause revision.
- D
- Incorrect because Lincoln did not campaign on immediate abolition; he pledged only to prevent slavery's extension into new territories while accepting its constitutional protection where it already existed.