Interpreting the Articles of Confederation (secondary source, Period 3)
The following passage was written for practice and is not by a real historian.
"It has become a habit to treat the Articles of Confederation as a failed first draft. That habit misreads the men who wrote them. Americans of 1777 had just broken with a Parliament that taxed them without consent and a king who sent soldiers into their towns. They built a Congress that could not tax and could not coerce on purpose. Holding power in the states was not an oversight; it was the point. Under this weak Congress the new nation won its independence, secured a generous peace, and created an orderly system for settling and governing western land. The Confederation's real limits came from the same fear of distant power that had driven the Revolution itself."
— Practice passage modeled on a historian's interpretation
- (a)Briefly describe the author's argument about the Articles of Confederation. [1 pt]
- (b)Briefly explain how ONE specific historical development from the period 1781 to 1789 supports the author's argument. [1 pt]
- (c)Briefly explain how ONE specific historical development from the period 1781 to 1789 challenges the author's argument. [1 pt]