In the early 1800s the federal government dealt with Native nations by treaty, as if they were foreign powers, while pushing them to 'civilize' by taking up farming, Christianity and written law. The Cherokee in Georgia adapted these tools for their own purposes. Sequoyah created a syllabary in 1821, the nation wrote a constitution in 1827, and it began printing the Cherokee Phoenix newspaper in 1828. At the same time the cotton boom made Southeastern land extremely valuable, and the discovery of gold in Georgia in 1829 brought thousands of white miners onto Cherokee land. By 1830 the question was whether Native nations that did what the government asked would be allowed to stay.
From 1830 to 1890 the methods of U.S. Indian policy changed a great deal, from removing whole nations west, to confining them on reservations through treaties and war, to breaking up tribes themselves through allotment and boarding schools. But the goal stayed the same the whole time: moving Native land into the hands of white settlers whenever economic interests wanted it, no matter what treaties said or how much Native peoples had adapted.
In the 1830s the method was removal. The Indian Removal Act of 1830 let Andrew Jackson negotiate land exchanges that moved Southeastern nations west of the Mississippi. In Worcester v. Georgia (1832) the Supreme Court ruled that Georgia law had no force inside the Cherokee Nation, but Jackson refused to back it, and Georgia ignored the ruling. In 1835 a small faction signed the Treaty of New Echota without the approval of the Cherokee government. In 1838 the army forced about 16,000 Cherokee west on the Trail of Tears, and around 4,000 died. This shows the continuity in goal. The Cherokee had a constitution, a written language and a newspaper, and none of it protected them, because Georgia wanted their land.
After 1848 the method changed because the West itself was filling up. The Mexican Cession and the California Gold Rush sent settlers across the Plains, and the transcontinental railroad, finished in 1869, cut through the buffalo range. So the government switched to reservations. In the Fort Laramie treaties of 1851 and 1868, Plains nations accepted boundaries in exchange for promises to protect their land. When gold was confirmed in the Black Hills in 1874, the government let miners in anyway and went to war with the Lakota. Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn in 1876 only delayed this. Massacres like Sand Creek in 1864 and the destruction of the buffalo made the reservation system enforceable. The tools were new, but once again a treaty lasted only until white Americans wanted the land.
The biggest change came in the 1870s and 1880s, when policy moved from separating Native nations to dissolving them as nations. In 1871 Congress stopped making new treaties with tribes. It would no longer deal with them as independent nations, but it left existing treaties in force. The Dawes Act of 1887 divided reservation land into 160-acre allotments for heads of families and sold the 'surplus' to whites. Reformers honestly believed private property would turn Native people into farmers and citizens. Boarding schools like Carlisle, founded in 1879, cut children's hair, banned their languages and tried to erase tribal identity. This was a real change in method, since earlier policy at least accepted that tribes existed as groups. But the result matched the old goal. Native landholdings fell from about 138 million acres in 1887 to about 48 million by 1934. The Wounded Knee Massacre in 1890, after the army moved to suppress the Ghost Dance, ended armed resistance on the Plains.
Overall, U.S. policy changed its tools three times in sixty years, but every new tool served the same purpose of opening Native land to white settlement.
How it scored
1/1thesis — It answers 'to what extent' with a clear verdict: methods changed a lot, the goal did not. It also sets out the three stages the body follows.
1/1context — The opening paragraph explains the treaty and 'civilization' policy, Cherokee adaptation, the cotton boom and Georgia gold, then ties them to the question facing Native nations in 1830.
2/2evidence — Specific evidence throughout (Worcester, New Echota, Fort Laramie, the 1871 end of treaty-making, Dawes, Carlisle, acreage figures). Each paragraph closes by explaining what its evidence shows about change or continuity.
1/1reasoning — Continuity and change structures the whole essay. It explains why methods changed (settlement pressure, railroads, reformers' beliefs) and why the goal did not.
1/1complexity — It explains both continuity and change and connects them. It treats the Cherokee as active adapters, not passive victims, and shows the limits of that strategy. It also separates reformers' sincere intent from the land-loss outcome.