Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Long Essay Question (LEQ)

6 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

The Long Essay Question (LEQ) is the last task on the AP U.S. History exam. You see three prompts and answer one. All three test the same reasoning skill: causation, comparison, or continuity and change over time. Each one covers a different stretch of history: 1491–1800, 1800–1898, or 1890–2001. You get no documents and no excerpts. Every fact in your essay comes from memory.

On this page · 6 sections

The LEQ is scored out of 6 points and counts for 15% of your exam score. The essay section runs 100 minutes. The DBQ is meant to take 60 of them, including a reading period, and the LEQ the other 40. The free-response tasks add up to 60% of your score: three short-answer questions (3 points each, 20%), the DBQ (7 points, 25%) and the LEQ (6 points, 15%). Multiple choice is the other 40%. Each LEQ point is worth about 2.5% of your whole exam, so one missed point here costs about as much as several multiple-choice questions.

Readers score six separate points, and each is yes or no. You can miss the thesis and still earn both evidence points. Readers reward what is there, not what is missing. A small slip, like a date off by a year, costs nothing unless it breaks your argument. Spelling and grammar are not scored.

Pick your prompt in the first two minutes. Choose the one where you can name six or more specific facts: laws, court cases, people, dates, numbers. Do not pick the topic you like most. Then spend about five minutes planning: thesis, context, and two body paragraphs with evidence under each. Write for about 30 minutes. Keep the last few minutes to check that your thesis actually answers the question asked. A prompt that says 'evaluate the relative importance' wants a ranking. A prompt that says 'evaluate the extent' wants a verdict on how much.

The rubric, in plain terms

6 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Thesis / claim1 pt

State a claim a historian could defend, and give the reasons that will organize your essay. Restating the prompt earns nothing. 'Many factors caused independence' fails. 'British military force in 1774–1775 mattered more than taxes, because it destroyed colonists' faith that the King would protect them' earns it. The thesis may run more than one sentence. It must sit in your introduction or your conclusion, not halfway down the page.

Contextualization1 pt

Describe the bigger situation around the prompt's topic: what came before it, what was happening at the same time, or what carried on after. Then tie it to the topic. This usually takes several sentences with real names and dates. A single opening clause like 'After the French and Indian War' does not count. Most students do this in the first paragraph, before the thesis.

Evidence2 pts

First point: name at least two specific, accurate examples that fit the topic. 'The Stamp Act of 1765' is specific. 'British taxes' is not. Second point: use your examples to prove the argument. Every example needs a sentence explaining what it shows about your claim. Describing events earns the first point only. Making them do work for your thesis earns both.

Historical reasoning1 pt

Use the skill the prompt names to organize your argument. For causation, explain how and why causes produced the result, not just that they came first. For comparison, explain why the cases were alike or different. For continuity and change, explain what changed, what stayed the same, and why. A run of events in order, with 'next' and 'then', does not earn it.

Complex understanding1 pt

Show that you understand the topic in depth. You can do this anywhere in the essay, but it must be part of the argument. Strong routes: weigh several causes against each other and explain how they interacted; explain both what changed and what continued; show how the story differed by region or group; or use evidence to qualify your own claim. A one-line 'however, some people disagreed' tacked on at the end earns nothing.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

From Protest to Independence, 1763–1776 (causation)

  1. (LEQ)Evaluate the relative importance of the causes that moved many British colonists in North America from seeking reconciliation with Great Britain to declaring independence in the period from 1763 to 1776.
Prompt 2

Federal Policy Toward American Indian Nations, 1830–1890 (continuity and change)

  1. (LEQ)Evaluate the extent to which United States policy toward American Indian nations changed in the period from 1830 to 1890.

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

From Protest to Independence, 1763–1776 (causation) · high-scoring response5/6

Between 1763 and 1776, colonists went from asking Britain to restore their rights to declaring independence. After the Seven Years' War, Parliament started taxing the colonies to pay its debts, and this started the conflict. But taxation alone did not make most colonists want to leave the empire. The most important cause was Britain's turn to military force and the King's refusal to negotiate in 1774-1775, which convinced moderates that reconciliation was impossible. Thomas Paine's Common Sense then gave them a reason to reject monarchy itself.

The tax crises of the 1760s built the argument against Parliament but kept colonists inside the empire. When Parliament passed the Stamp Act in 1765, nine colonies sent delegates to the Stamp Act Congress. The delegates said only their own assemblies could tax them, but they also declared loyalty to the King and petitioned for repeal. Merchants boycotted British goods, and Parliament repealed the act in 1766. This taught colonists that protest inside the empire worked. Even after the Townshend Acts in 1767, John Dickinson's Letters from a Farmer in Pennsylvania said Parliament could regulate trade but could not tax for revenue. Dickinson wanted the old relationship back, not a new country. So the tax disputes spread the idea of no taxation without representation, but in 1770 very few colonists wanted independence.

The decisive shift came when Britain answered protest with force. After the Boston Tea Party in 1773, Parliament passed the Coercive Acts, which closed Boston's port and rewrote the Massachusetts charter. This mattered more than any tax because it showed Parliament could take away a colony's self-government completely. Even then, the First Continental Congress in 1774 still professed loyalty to George III and used a boycott instead of war. Then fighting broke out at Lexington and Concord in April 1775. In July the Second Continental Congress sent the Olive Branch Petition asking the King to step in. George III refused to receive it and declared the colonies in rebellion. Parliament then passed the Prohibitory Act cutting off colonial trade, and Britain hired German soldiers. In Virginia, Lord Dunmore offered freedom to enslaved people who joined the British, which turned many planters against the Crown. Every one of these steps showed moderates that the King would not protect them from Parliament, and that protection had been the whole basis of their loyalty.

Common Sense, published in January 1776, turned this anger into a case for independence. Before Paine, most colonists blamed Parliament and bad ministers while still respecting the King. Paine attacked monarchy and hereditary rule themselves and argued that it made no sense for an island to rule a continent. He wrote in plain language, so his pamphlet reached farmers and artisans and not only educated elites, and it sold tens of thousands of copies in a few months. But Paine's argument worked because of timing. The King had just rejected the Olive Branch Petition. In 1766, right after the Stamp Act was repealed, the same pamphlet would have convinced far fewer people.

The shift was also not complete or the same everywhere. New England, which felt the Coercive Acts directly, moved toward independence faster than the middle colonies, where delegates from Pennsylvania and New York held back into the summer of 1776. Perhaps a fifth of colonists stayed Loyalist through the war. Independence was declared by a majority that British force had pushed there in 1775, not by people who had wanted it since the Stamp Act.

Overall, taxes started the argument, but British force and the King's rejection of compromise ended the hope of reconciliation, and Paine told colonists what to do next.

How it scored

1/1thesis — The first paragraph ranks the causes (force first, taxes as background, Paine as the final push) and gives a reason for the ranking. That is a defensible claim with a clear line of reasoning.
0/1context — The only setting is one sentence about war debt and taxes. Nothing describes salutary neglect, colonial self-government, or the Proclamation of 1763. The essay jumps straight into the argument, so the point is lost even though everything after it is strong.
2/2evidence — Many specific examples (Stamp Act Congress, Dickinson, Coercive Acts, Olive Branch Petition, Prohibitory Act, Dunmore's Proclamation). Each is explained in terms of what it did to colonial loyalty, so the evidence proves the argument.
1/1reasoning — Causation organizes the whole essay. It explains how each cause worked (taxes created ideas, force destroyed trust in the King) instead of listing causes in order.
1/1complexity — Earned in several places: it explains how causes interacted (Paine worked only because the petition had just been rejected), notes regional differences, and qualifies the claim with Loyalist numbers.
From Protest to Independence, 1763–1776 (causation) · mid-scoring response2/6

After the French and Indian War, Britain was in debt and started taxing the colonies. Between 1763 and 1776 there were many causes of the colonists deciding to declare independence, such as taxes, the Boston Massacre, and Common Sense, but taxes were the most important cause because they affected every colonist.

The first cause was taxes. The Sugar Act in 1764 and the Stamp Act in 1765 taxed the colonists without their consent. The colonists were angry because they had no representatives in Parliament, so they said no taxation without representation. The Stamp Act taxed newspapers, legal documents and playing cards, so almost every colonist had to pay it. Later the Townshend Acts taxed glass, paint, paper and tea. Taxes made colonists want independence because they felt Britain was treating them like servants and not like Englishmen. This is why the colonists started rebelling right after the Stamp Act.

Another cause was the Boston Massacre in 1770. British soldiers fired into a crowd and killed five colonists. Paul Revere made an engraving of it which made people angry at the British. This made the colonists hate having soldiers in Boston.

The last cause was Common Sense by Thomas Paine. Paine argued that Britain's trade laws were hurting colonial merchants and that the colonies would be richer if they could trade freely with the whole world. Lots of people read it and it convinced them to support independence.

So overall, taxes were the most important cause of independence because they affected everyone and started the whole conflict. The Boston Massacre and Common Sense also helped but they came after the taxes. Because of all these causes the colonies declared independence in 1776.

How it scored

1/1thesis — It names causes, ranks taxes first, and gives a reason ('they affected every colonist'). That is thin, but it is a defensible claim with a line of reasoning, so it earns the point.
0/1context — One opening clause about war debt is not developed context. It needs several sentences on the situation before 1763 and how it connects to the topic.
1/1evidence — For this line: the Stamp Act, Townshend Acts and Boston Massacre are specific and accurate. That clears the first evidence point.
0/1evidence — For this line: the examples are described but do not prove the claim. The essay never deals with the fact that the Stamp Act was repealed in 1766 and most colonists stayed loyal for nine more years. It reduces Common Sense to a trade complaint and misses its real target, monarchy, which is why the pamphlet mattered. 'Started rebelling right after the Stamp Act' flattens the timeline the prompt is about.
0/1reasoning — Not earned. The essay labels causes and ranks taxes first, but labeling and ranking causes is not explaining them. It never shows how taxes turned a protest movement into a wish for independence. Its 'first, another, last' structure is the same list the Indian-policy mid essay uses, and it fails for the same reason. A reason for the ranking earns the thesis point, not the reasoning point.
0/1complexity — 'They came after the taxes' is sequence, not weighing. Nothing shows how causes interacted, and nothing on Loyalists or regional differences.
Federal Policy Toward American Indian Nations, 1830–1890 (continuity and change) · high-scoring response6/6

In the early 1800s the federal government dealt with Native nations by treaty, as if they were foreign powers, while pushing them to 'civilize' by taking up farming, Christianity and written law. The Cherokee in Georgia adapted these tools for their own purposes. Sequoyah created a syllabary in 1821, the nation wrote a constitution in 1827, and it began printing the Cherokee Phoenix newspaper in 1828. At the same time the cotton boom made Southeastern land extremely valuable, and the discovery of gold in Georgia in 1829 brought thousands of white miners onto Cherokee land. By 1830 the question was whether Native nations that did what the government asked would be allowed to stay.

From 1830 to 1890 the methods of U.S. Indian policy changed a great deal, from removing whole nations west, to confining them on reservations through treaties and war, to breaking up tribes themselves through allotment and boarding schools. But the goal stayed the same the whole time: moving Native land into the hands of white settlers whenever economic interests wanted it, no matter what treaties said or how much Native peoples had adapted.

In the 1830s the method was removal. The Indian Removal Act of 1830 let Andrew Jackson negotiate land exchanges that moved Southeastern nations west of the Mississippi. In Worcester v. Georgia (1832) the Supreme Court ruled that Georgia law had no force inside the Cherokee Nation, but Jackson refused to back it, and Georgia ignored the ruling. In 1835 a small faction signed the Treaty of New Echota without the approval of the Cherokee government. In 1838 the army forced about 16,000 Cherokee west on the Trail of Tears, and around 4,000 died. This shows the continuity in goal. The Cherokee had a constitution, a written language and a newspaper, and none of it protected them, because Georgia wanted their land.

After 1848 the method changed because the West itself was filling up. The Mexican Cession and the California Gold Rush sent settlers across the Plains, and the transcontinental railroad, finished in 1869, cut through the buffalo range. So the government switched to reservations. In the Fort Laramie treaties of 1851 and 1868, Plains nations accepted boundaries in exchange for promises to protect their land. When gold was confirmed in the Black Hills in 1874, the government let miners in anyway and went to war with the Lakota. Custer's defeat at Little Bighorn in 1876 only delayed this. Massacres like Sand Creek in 1864 and the destruction of the buffalo made the reservation system enforceable. The tools were new, but once again a treaty lasted only until white Americans wanted the land.

The biggest change came in the 1870s and 1880s, when policy moved from separating Native nations to dissolving them as nations. In 1871 Congress stopped making new treaties with tribes. It would no longer deal with them as independent nations, but it left existing treaties in force. The Dawes Act of 1887 divided reservation land into 160-acre allotments for heads of families and sold the 'surplus' to whites. Reformers honestly believed private property would turn Native people into farmers and citizens. Boarding schools like Carlisle, founded in 1879, cut children's hair, banned their languages and tried to erase tribal identity. This was a real change in method, since earlier policy at least accepted that tribes existed as groups. But the result matched the old goal. Native landholdings fell from about 138 million acres in 1887 to about 48 million by 1934. The Wounded Knee Massacre in 1890, after the army moved to suppress the Ghost Dance, ended armed resistance on the Plains.

Overall, U.S. policy changed its tools three times in sixty years, but every new tool served the same purpose of opening Native land to white settlement.

How it scored

1/1thesis — It answers 'to what extent' with a clear verdict: methods changed a lot, the goal did not. It also sets out the three stages the body follows.
1/1context — The opening paragraph explains the treaty and 'civilization' policy, Cherokee adaptation, the cotton boom and Georgia gold, then ties them to the question facing Native nations in 1830.
2/2evidence — Specific evidence throughout (Worcester, New Echota, Fort Laramie, the 1871 end of treaty-making, Dawes, Carlisle, acreage figures). Each paragraph closes by explaining what its evidence shows about change or continuity.
1/1reasoning — Continuity and change structures the whole essay. It explains why methods changed (settlement pressure, railroads, reformers' beliefs) and why the goal did not.
1/1complexity — It explains both continuity and change and connects them. It treats the Cherokee as active adapters, not passive victims, and shows the limits of that strategy. It also separates reformers' sincere intent from the land-loss outcome.
Federal Policy Toward American Indian Nations, 1830–1890 (continuity and change) · mid-scoring response3/6

In the 1800s white Americans wanted more land for farming, especially for growing cotton in the South after the cotton gin was invented. Many Native American tribes like the Cherokee and Creek lived in Georgia, Alabama and Mississippi on land that settlers wanted. Presidents like Jefferson hoped Native Americans would become farmers and live like white Americans. This set up a conflict between settlers and tribes over land in the South.

From 1830 to 1890 U.S. policy toward Native Americans changed a lot, as the government went from removal to reservations to the Dawes Act.

First, in 1830 Andrew Jackson passed the Indian Removal Act. The Cherokee had already lost a lot of their culture by then because they were forced to adopt a written alphabet, a newspaper and a constitution like white Americans. Even so, Georgia still wanted their land. The Cherokee went to the Supreme Court and won but Jackson ignored the ruling. Then the army forced the Cherokee to walk to Oklahoma on the Trail of Tears and thousands of them died.

Next, the government put the Plains Indians on reservations. There were many wars on the Plains, like the Battle of Little Bighorn where Custer was killed. The government also let hunters kill the buffalo, which the Plains Indians needed for food.

Finally, in 1887 the Dawes Act split up the reservations into farms for individual families. The government wanted Native Americans to become farmers. There were also boarding schools that tried to make Native children act like white Americans.

So overall, policy changed a lot from 1830 to 1890 because it went from removal to reservations and then to the Dawes Act.

How it scored

1/1thesis — 'Changed a lot' answers the extent question, and the three stages give a line of reasoning. It is the bare minimum: it says nothing about what stayed the same.
1/1context — The first paragraph is short but real. It covers cotton expansion, settler demand for Southern land and Jefferson's assimilation hopes, and ties them to the conflict the prompt is about.
1/1evidence — For this line: the Removal Act, Trail of Tears, Little Bighorn and the Dawes Act are specific and relevant, which earns the first point. Small errors (Congress passed the Removal Act, and the case was brought by a missionary, Worcester) do not cost the point on their own.
0/1evidence — For this line: the examples are narrated, not used. The essay never says what any of them shows about how much policy changed. It also misreads the Cherokee evidence. The syllabary, newspaper and constitution were tools the Cherokee chose and adapted to defend their sovereignty, not a culture forced on them. Read correctly, that evidence was the strongest proof that adapting did not protect a nation from removal.
0/1reasoning — 'First, next, finally' is chronology, not continuity-and-change analysis. The essay never explains why policy changed, or what the three stages had in common.
0/1complexity — No continuity, no Native agency, and no tension between reformers' aims and the results. With nothing weighed, there is nothing complex to reward.

Where points die

Writing a thesis that restates the prompt: 'There were many causes of independence, and some were more important than others.' Commit to a ranking or a verdict and give your reasons in the same breath. If the prompt says 'relative importance', name the top cause and say why it beats the others. If it says 'extent', say how much, and what changed versus what stayed.

Narrating events in order ('First... Next... Finally...') and assuming the prompt's skill is obvious. Every body paragraph needs a sentence that says what its evidence proves. For causation, explain how the cause produced the result. For continuity and change, say what changed, what stayed the same, and why. A timeline alone gets you the first evidence point and nothing more.

Treating every cause as if it acted immediately. For example, writing that colonists rebelled 'right after the Stamp Act', or that the war ended after Saratoga. Keep the timeline straight, because the gaps are often the argument. The Stamp Act was repealed in 1766 and most colonists stayed loyal for nine more years. After Saratoga in 1777, Britain kept fighting for four years and shifted to a Southern strategy. Explain what happened in between.

Reading Native adaptation as loss. For example, calling the Cherokee syllabary, newspaper and constitution evidence that the Cherokee were forced to give up their culture. The Cherokee chose those tools and used them to defend their sovereignty, including in the Supreme Court. The point an essay can make is sharper: adapting did not protect them, because Georgia and Jackson wanted the land. Give historical actors agency, then explain the limits they hit.

Blending similar events into one: the Great Compromise with the Three-Fifths Compromise, or Shays' Rebellion with the Whiskey Rebellion. Keep paired events separate. The Great Compromise settled representation in Congress, and the Three-Fifths Compromise separately settled how enslaved people were counted. Shays' Rebellion (1786–87) exposed how weak the Articles were. The Whiskey Rebellion (1794) showed the new federal government's strength, when Washington led troops to enforce the tax. A swapped example can turn your evidence against your own thesis.

Reducing a source or movement to its most familiar label. For example, calling Common Sense an attack on trade laws, or saying Manifest Destiny unified the nation. Name what actually drove the argument. Paine's core attack was on monarchy and hereditary rule, and that is why it moved colonists who still trusted the King. Manifest Destiny did the opposite of unifying: the Mexican Cession reopened the fight over slavery in the territories almost immediately.

Score your own response

0 / 6

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.