Skip to content

Free-response practice

The Document-Based Question (DBQ)

7 points2 original prompts4 scored examples

The Document-Based Question is one essay built from seven short sources. It is worth 7 points and counts for 25% of your total exam score — the single biggest item on the test. The written questions — the three SAQs plus the two essays — add up to 60% of your score. You get 60 minutes for it: College Board recommends 15 minutes reading the documents and 45 minutes writing. The prompt always asks you to "evaluate the extent" of some change, cause, or effect, and from May 2027 it covers a wider chronological range than the old Periods 3 through 8 (1754–1980) window, so evidence from across the course can be in play. The documents are a mix: speeches, letters, laws, newspaper editorials, sometimes a photograph or cartoon. A trained reader scores your essay against a fixed 7-point rubric. The points are independent — a weak thesis does not stop you from earning evidence points. That matters for strategy: you are collecting seven separate points, not impressing anyone with style. Readers spend a few minutes per essay and hunt for specific rubric behaviors. Do each behavior visibly and you get the point.

On this page · 6 sections

The rubric, in plain terms

7 points, earned line by line. Readers score what is on the page, nothing else.

Thesis / Claim1 pt

Make a historically defensible claim that answers the prompt and sets up a line of reasoning — not a restatement of the question. "Expansion caused conflict" fails; "expansion caused conflict because every new territory forced Congress to reopen the slavery question compromises had buried" earns it. One or two sentences, usually at the end of your intro.

Contextualization1 pt

Describe the broader situation before or around the prompt's time frame and connect it to your argument. This must be developed — three or four sentences with names and dates, not a single dropped phrase like "after the Market Revolution." Easiest done as your opening paragraph, before the thesis.

Evidence from the documents2 pts

One point for accurately using the content of at least three documents to address the topic. Both points require using at least four documents to SUPPORT your argument — each document has to do work for a claim you are making, not just get summarized. Cite them as (Doc 3); never quote long passages.

Evidence beyond the documents1 pt

Bring in at least one specific piece of historical evidence that appears in none of the documents, and use it to support your argument. It must be concrete (the Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854, not "other laws") and explained in a sentence or two, not name-dropped.

Sourcing / analysis1 pt

For at least two documents, explain how or why the author's point of view, purpose, historical situation, or audience matters for your argument. Saying "he is biased because he is a planter" earns nothing. Explaining that a planter writing privately to his senator could state the South's demands more bluntly than any public speech — that earns it.

Complex understanding1 pt

Show a nuanced grasp of the question throughout the essay. Common routes: weigh both sides of "to what extent" and land a qualified verdict, trace change across the whole period, corroborate documents against each other, or explain a counterargument and answer it. A one-sentence "however" tacked on the end does not earn it.

Practice prompts

Prompt 1

Slavery, Expansion, and Sectional Conflict, 1844–1861

Document 1 — Editorial in a New York Democratic newspaper, 1845: The American people are called to spread across this continent. Providence has set aside these lands for a free and multiplying people. Texas today, Oregon and California tomorrow — the farmer and mechanic of the East will find room and independence in the West, and the Union will grow stronger with every new state.

Document 2 — Speech by a Whig congressman from Illinois, 1847: The President tells us Mexico shed American blood upon American soil. I have asked him to name the spot. He cannot, because the spot lies in territory that was never ours. This war was manufactured. Its object is not defense but conquest — new land into which the slave power means to carry its institution.

Document 3 — Resolution adopted at a Free-Soil convention in Buffalo, New York, 1848: Resolved, that Congress possesses the power and the duty to keep slavery out of every territory of the United States. We seek no interference with slavery where it exists under state law. But the new lands won from Mexico must be reserved for free labor, free men, and free soil.

Document 4 — Letter from a South Carolina planter to his senator, 1850: The territories were purchased with common blood and common treasure, ours no less than the North's. If Congress may bar our property from them, we are made a lesser order of citizens in our own country. Accept that principle and the South's weight in the Senate will sink year by year until we are governed entirely by others.

Document 5 — Sermon by a Congregationalist minister in Ohio, 1851: This new fugitive law commands us to hunt men. It reaches into free states and makes every citizen a slave-catcher on pain of fine and prison. I say to you that a statute which orders Christians to violate the law of God is no law at all, and obedience to it is sin.

Document 6 — Speech by a Democratic senator from Illinois, 1854: Why should this question tear the Union apart? Let the people of each territory decide for themselves whether to have slavery, as free men managing their own affairs. That is the true principle of self-government. Take the question out of Congress and you take it out of national politics forever.

Document 7 — Editorial in a Georgia newspaper, December 1860: The election has shown that a purely sectional party can seize the presidency with no Southern votes at all. The government our fathers made jointly has passed into hands hostile to our institutions. Nothing remains to protect us within the Union; safety must now be sought outside it.

  1. (1)Using the seven documents and your knowledge of U.S. history, evaluate the extent to which debates over the expansion of slavery caused political conflict in the United States from 1844 to 1861.
Prompt 2

The New Deal and the Role of the Federal Government, 1932–1940

Document 1 — Letter from an unemployed machinist in Detroit to the White House, 1934: I worked nineteen years at the same plant and have been out since 1931. My savings are gone and the city relief office has nothing left. I never thought I would write to a president, but people here say Washington is finally listening to men like me. Any work at all — I am not asking for charity, only a chance.

Document 2 — President Franklin Roosevelt, national radio address, 1933: The banks in the larger cities will open their doors again tomorrow, and I assure you that your money is safer in one of those reopened banks than hidden at home. Your government does not intend to let the machinery of daily life stand still. With your confidence, this recovery cannot fail.

Document 3 — Speech by a Republican senator from Ohio, 1935: These new agencies tell the farmer what to plant and the shopkeeper what to charge. That is not relief; it is regimentation. The Constitution grants Congress no such power over the private business of citizens, and the Supreme Court has begun to say so.

Document 4 — Pamphlet published by the American Liberty League, 1936: The New Deal taxes the thrifty to subsidize the idle and concentrates in one man's hands powers the Founders deliberately divided. Business cannot plan, invest, or hire while Washington rewrites the rules each season. Recovery will come from enterprise, not from bureaus.

Document 5 — Photograph: a Works Progress Administration crew building a farm-to-market road in rural Tennessee, 1936. Two dozen men work with picks and a grader; a sign reads "USA Work Program WPA."

Document 6 — Letter from a Black sharecropper in Alabama to a federal farm official, 1935: The government checks for plowing under cotton go to the landowner, and he put three families off the place and kept the money. The county committee that runs the program is all landlords. If Washington means this program for the farmer, somebody besides the landlord ought to see that check.

Document 7 — Statement by a steelworkers' union organizer in Pittsburgh, 1937: Two years ago a man who signed a union card lost his job by Friday. Now the law says the company must bargain with us, and there is a federal board to hear our case. We signed up thirty thousand men in the valley this spring. The men say it plainly: the government is on our side for once.

  1. (1)Using the seven documents and your knowledge of U.S. history, evaluate the extent to which the New Deal transformed the relationship between the federal government and the American people from 1932 to 1940.

Scored examples

Two responses per prompt — one near the top of the rubric, one in the middle — with every point accounted for. The mid response earns its score through the mistakes students actually make.

Slavery, Expansion, and Sectional Conflict, 1844–1861 · high-scoring response7/7

Before 1844, the Union had managed the slavery question through careful balance. The Missouri Compromise of 1820 drew a line at 36°30′ and admitted states in pairs, keeping the Senate even. The Market Revolution had meanwhile pulled the sections apart economically: the North built factories and free-labor farms while the cotton South deepened its commitment to enslaved labor. Slavery was contained as a political issue only so long as no new land forced the question open. Between 1844 and 1861, debates over slavery's expansion were the primary cause of political conflict, because every acquisition of territory reopened the question, destroyed the old party system that had suppressed it, and convinced each section the other meant to control the federal government.

Expansion itself was popular before it was divisive. The New York editorial (Doc 1) sells the West as room for eastern farmers and mechanics, promising the Union will grow stronger. As a Democratic paper writing for northern workingmen, its purpose was to make expansion look like a class promise, not a sectional one — which explains why the slavery problem blindsided so many expansionists. The Whig congressman (Doc 2) shows the promise collapsing almost immediately: he calls the Mexican War manufactured conquest for the "slave power." The Wilmot Proviso, first proposed in August 1846, tried to bar slavery from any land that might be taken from Mexico. Its repeated defeats split Congress along sectional rather than party lines even before the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo delivered the Mexican Cession in 1848.

Once the land existed, positions hardened. The Free-Soilers (Doc 3) demanded Congress bar slavery from every territory, while insisting they would not touch it in the states — proof the fight was specifically about expansion. The South Carolina planter (Doc 4) makes the mirror argument: exclusion from common territory made Southerners second-class citizens and would sink the South's Senate power. Because this is a private letter to his own senator, it is likely a candid statement of planter fears rather than public posturing, which makes its focus on Senate arithmetic revealing — the South understood expansion as a struggle for federal power. Douglas's popular sovereignty (Doc 6) tried to defuse this by moving the decision to the territories. It did the opposite. His Kansas-Nebraska Act of 1854 repealed the Missouri Compromise line, and "Bleeding Kansas" turned the abstract debate into actual killing, with pro-slavery and free-soil settlers racing to stack the vote.

Conflict also spilled beyond the territories, though expansion still drove it. The Ohio minister (Doc 5) preaches disobedience to the Fugitive Slave Act, part of the Compromise of 1850 — a law about the North, not the West, showing the crisis was widening. The Dred Scott decision of 1857 went further, holding Congress could not ban slavery in any territory, which destroyed both the Free-Soil program and popular sovereignty at once. By December 1860 the Georgia editorial (Doc 7) treats Lincoln's purely sectional victory as proof the South had lost the federal government itself; its purpose was to push wavering readers toward secession by making the Union look already lost.

Slavery's morality, tariffs, and cultural difference all fed sectional anger, and Doc 5 shows moral conflict operating outside the territories. But those tensions had existed for decades without breaking the party system. It was expansion that repeatedly forced Congress to choose, killed the Whigs, birthed the Republicans, and turned a contained question into secession. To a very great extent, expansion was the engine of the conflict.

How it scored

1/1thesis — The thesis answers the prompt with a three-part line of reasoning: expansion reopened the question, destroyed the party system, and convinced each section the other sought federal control.
1/1context — The opening develops the pre-1844 situation — Missouri Compromise, paired admissions, Market Revolution divergence — across several sentences and ties it to why expansion detonated the balance.
2/2doc-evidence — All seven documents are used, and at least four (Docs 2, 3, 4, 6, 7) actively support claims in the argument rather than being summarized.
1/1outside-evidence — Wilmot Proviso, Kansas-Nebraska Act, Bleeding Kansas, and Dred Scott are all specific, outside the documents, and explained in service of the argument.
1/1sourcing — Three documents are sourced with relevance explained: Doc 1 (audience and purpose), Doc 4 (private letter as candid evidence), Doc 7 (purpose of pushing secession). Only two were needed.
1/1complexity — The essay weighs the counterargument that moral and economic tensions mattered, uses Doc 5 to concede conflict beyond the territories, and still lands a qualified "very great extent" verdict.
Slavery, Expansion, and Sectional Conflict, 1844–1861 · mid-scoring response4/7

In the early 1800s America was growing fast. The Missouri Compromise of 1820 had settled the slavery question by drawing a line across the Louisiana Purchase, and for a while the country stayed calm. Debates over the expansion of slavery caused political conflict between 1844 and 1861 because the North and South could not agree on whether new territories should have slavery.

Document 1 says that America was destined to spread across the continent and that expansion would make the Union stronger. This shows Manifest Destiny. Document 2 is a congressman saying the Mexican War was manufactured to get land for slavery. He is biased because he is a Whig, so he was against the war. Document 3 shows the Free-Soil party wanted Congress to keep slavery out of the territories. Document 4 is a planter saying the South paid for the territories too and should be allowed to bring slavery there. This shows the two sides disagreed.

Document 5 is a minister saying the Fugitive Slave Act is against God's law. Document 6 says the people of each territory should vote on slavery for themselves, which was called popular sovereignty. Document 7 shows that after Lincoln was elected, the South felt the government was against them and started to secede.

There was also the Kansas-Nebraska Act, which let Kansas and Nebraska vote on slavery and led to violence in Kansas. This made the conflict worse. In conclusion, the North and South fought over slavery in the territories for the whole period, and this conflict eventually caused the Civil War. The documents show that both sides felt strongly and would not back down, so the debates over expansion caused a lot of political conflict.

How it scored

1/1thesis — Minimal but defensible: the final sentence of the intro makes a claim with a stated reason (the sections could not agree on slavery in new territories). It sets up a thin line of reasoning.
1/1context — The Missouri Compromise setup describes the situation before 1844 and connects it to the period, just clearing the bar for developed context. Readers accept less than the guide's safe three-to-four-sentence target — but do not plan on cutting it this close.
1/2doc-evidence — All seven documents are described accurately, earning the first point. But the essay marches through them in order — "Document 1 says... Document 2 is..." — and none is deployed to support a specific claim, so the second point is lost.
1/1outside-evidence — The Kansas-Nebraska Act and the violence in Kansas are specific, beyond the documents, and briefly tied to the argument.
0/1sourcing — "He is biased because he is a Whig" merely labels the author. It never explains how the Whig position affects what the document can prove, and no second document is sourced at all.
0/1complexity — The essay never weighs extent, considers other causes of conflict, or qualifies its verdict. It asserts one side throughout.
The New Deal and the Role of the Federal Government, 1932–1940 · high-scoring response7/7

Before 1932, most Americans expected almost nothing from Washington in daily life. The federal government of the 1920s under Coolidge kept taxes low and left relief to private charity and local government. When the Depression hit, Hoover extended credit to banks through the Reconstruction Finance Corporation but refused direct federal relief to individuals, believing it would corrupt character. By 1932, with unemployment near 25 percent, local relief systems had collapsed. The New Deal transformed the federal government's relationship with the people to a great extent — it made Washington directly responsible for individual economic security and a permanent referee between labor and capital — though the transformation was limited by constitutional resistance and by local administration that excluded Black Americans from many benefits.

The most basic change was psychological and direct. The Detroit machinist (Doc 1) writes to the president himself, saying he never imagined doing so but that "Washington is finally listening." Ordinary citizens now addressed the federal government as the answer of first resort, something unthinkable under the old charity model. Roosevelt built that relationship deliberately: his radio address (Doc 2) speaks to families about their own bank accounts in plain language. The purpose of the fireside format was exactly this — to create a personal bond between citizen and president that bypassed newspapers, and it worked, making federal action feel intimate rather than distant. The WPA photograph (Doc 5) shows the change in concrete form: the federal government directly employing men on a rural Tennessee road, with a sign advertising the program. Beyond the documents, the Social Security Act of 1935 made the change permanent, creating federal old-age pensions and unemployment insurance that still define the government's role today. The Wagner Act produced the same permanence for workers: the organizer (Doc 7) reports that federal law now forced companies to bargain, and thirty thousand men signed union cards. As an organizer recruiting members, he has reason to credit the government — his statement is partly a pitch — but the CIO's real growth to millions of members by 1938 corroborates him.

The transformation, however, met real limits. The Ohio senator (Doc 3) and the Liberty League (Doc 4) called the New Deal unconstitutional regimentation, and courts partly agreed: the Supreme Court struck down the NRA in 1935 and the first AAA in 1936. Roosevelt's 1937 court-packing plan to overcome this failed badly in Congress, showing that older constitutional expectations still constrained federal power. The Liberty League pamphlet should be read carefully: funded largely by business conservatives during the 1936 campaign, its purpose was electoral, and Roosevelt's landslide that year showed how few voters it persuaded. A deeper limit appears in the Alabama sharecropper's letter (Doc 6): AAA checks went to landlords, who evicted tenant families and kept the money, because all-landlord county committees ran the program locally. Federal money flowed through local white power structures, so the new relationship reached Black southerners weakly or not at all.

The New Deal did not end the Depression — full employment returned only with wartime mobilization after 1939 — and it left administration in local hands that preserved old hierarchies. But ending the Depression is the wrong measure of transformation. In 1928 an unemployed machinist had no reason to write to Washington; in 1934 he did, and after 1935 the law guaranteed his pension and his union. That expectation never reversed, which is the mark of a transformation that was great, if uneven.

How it scored

1/1thesis — A defensible, qualified claim: great transformation via direct responsibility for economic security, limited by constitutional resistance and discriminatory local administration. Clear line of reasoning.
1/1context — Developed pre-1932 context — Coolidge-era minimal government, Hoover's RFC and refusal of direct relief, collapsed local systems — explicitly set up as the baseline the New Deal changed.
2/2doc-evidence — All seven documents support the argument: Docs 1, 2, 5, 7 build the transformation case; Docs 3, 4, 6 build the limits case. Well over four documents do argumentative work.
1/1outside-evidence — Social Security Act, Schechter and Butler decisions striking down the NRA and AAA, the court-packing fight, and CIO growth are all specific outside evidence tied to claims.
1/1sourcing — Doc 2 (purpose of the fireside format), Doc 7 (organizer's motive, then corroborated), and Doc 4 (Liberty League's electoral purpose and funding) are each sourced with the relevance explained.
1/1complexity — The essay sustains a both-sides evaluation, corroborates Doc 7 with outside evidence, addresses the "didn't end the Depression" counterargument, and closes with a measured verdict.
The New Deal and the Role of the Federal Government, 1932–1940 · mid-scoring response3/7

The Great Depression started with the stock market crash in 1929 and put millions of people out of work. The New Deal transformed the relationship between the federal government and the American people to a large extent because it created many new programs that helped people directly.

Document 1 shows an unemployed machinist writing to the president asking for work. This shows that people now looked to the federal government for help. Document 2 is Roosevelt telling people the banks are safe. Roosevelt used the radio to talk to people, which presidents had not really done before. Document 5 is a photo of men working for the WPA building a road, which shows the government gave people jobs. Document 7 shows a union organizer saying the government was on the workers' side now because of the new labor law.

Some people did not like the New Deal. Document 3 is a senator saying the programs were unconstitutional, and Document 4 says the New Deal taxed the thrifty to subsidize the idle. But most people supported Roosevelt because the New Deal ended the Depression and got the economy going again. Document 6 is a sharecropper saying the landlord kept the government check, which shows the programs helped farmers.

The New Deal also created Social Security, which gave old people pensions and still exists today. This shows how much the government changed. Before the New Deal the government did not do much for regular people, but after it the government helped them with jobs, pensions, and unions. That is why the New Deal transformed the relationship between the government and the people to a large extent.

How it scored

1/1thesis — The intro's last sentence makes a defensible claim with a reason — new programs helped people directly — which is a minimal but sufficient line of reasoning.
0/1context — "The Great Depression started with the stock market crash" is a single background sentence, not developed context. There is no description of what government's role was before 1932, so the transformation has no baseline.
1/2doc-evidence — The content of at least three documents is used accurately, earning the first point. But Doc 6 is misread — the sharecropper is complaining that the landlord stole the benefit, not evidence the program "helped farmers" — and most documents are introduced with "Document X shows" summaries rather than supporting distinct claims. Second point lost.
1/1outside-evidence — Social Security is specific, outside the documents, and connected to the argument about lasting change.
0/1sourcing — The essay never explains why any author's point of view, purpose, situation, or audience matters. The radio observation about Doc 2 comes close but never says why the format mattered for the argument.
0/1complexity — Opposition documents are mentioned then waved away with the false claim that "the New Deal ended the Depression" — wartime mobilization did that. There is no real weighing of extent or limits.

Where points die

Walking through the documents in order — "Document 1 says..., Document 2 says..." — and calling that an essay. Group documents by the claim they prove, not by their number. The second evidence point requires at least four documents supporting YOUR argument. A summary shows you read the document; only using it to back a specific claim shows you can argue with it. Plan your groupings during the 15-minute reading period.

Reading a document by its author's label instead of its actual content — assuming a Northern writer opposes slavery everywhere, or that a complaint about a program is praise of it. Read what the document actually argues. The Free-Soil position opposed slavery in the territories while explicitly leaving it alone in the states — those are different claims, and mixing them up misuses the document. Same trap in reverse: a sharecropper describing how landlords pocketed AAA checks is evidence of a program's limits, not its success. Misread documents cost you evidence points.

Sourcing by labeling: "this document is biased because the author is a planter." Every author has a perspective; naming it earns nothing. Explain why it matters for your argument. A planter's private letter to his senator is candid where a campaign speech performs; a pamphlet published by business donors during an election campaign is persuasion aimed at voters. Say what the source can and cannot prove because of who wrote it, for whom, and why.

Treating one event as instantly deciding everything — Saratoga ending the Revolution, or the New Deal ending the Depression. Big turning points changed trajectories; they rarely ended anything. Britain fought for four more years after Saratoga, and unemployment stayed high until wartime mobilization after 1939. Readers reward precise causation. Sloppy overclaims like these are exactly what kills the complexity point, because they show you are not weighing extent.

Contextualization as a drive-by phrase: "After the Market Revolution, conflict grew." The context point requires a developed description of the broader situation, connected to the prompt. Spend three or four sentences with names and dates on what the world looked like before your period starts — then pivot to your thesis. Write it as your opening paragraph so you cannot forget it under time pressure.

Confusing which compromise or law settled which dispute — crediting the Great Compromise with the three-fifths ratio, or the Compromise of 1850 with the 36°30′ line. Outside evidence only earns its point if it is accurate and specific. The Great Compromise set congressional representation; the Three-Fifths Compromise handled counting enslaved people; the Missouri Compromise (1820) drew the 36°30′ line; Kansas-Nebraska (1854) repealed it. If you are not sure which law did what, use the one you are sure of — one correct piece of evidence beats three shaky ones.

Score your own response

0 / 7

Be the harshest reader in the room: award a point only when your response does what the line says, on the page — not what you meant to write.