Which of the following correctly distinguishes between ionic bonding and polar covalent bonding?
- APolar covalent bonds are always stronger than ionic bonds because shared electrons create more stability.
- BIonic bonds only form between metals and nonmetals, while polar covalent bonds only form between identical nonmetal atoms.
- CIonic bonds result from complete electron transfer, giving full +/- charges on ions; polar covalent bonds involve unequal sharing of electrons with partial charges.Correct
- DIonic bonds involve partial charge separation (delta+ and delta-), while polar covalent bonds involve complete transfer of electrons.
Why C is right
In ionic bonding, electronegativity differences are large (typically > 1.7 on the Pauling scale) and electrons transfer completely from one atom to another, forming ions with full +1, +2, -1, etc. charges. In polar covalent bonding, electronegativity differences are intermediate (0.5–1.7), and electrons are shared unequally, producing partial charges (delta+ and delta-).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. Bond strength comparisons between ionic and covalent bonds depend on specific species; ionic compounds can have very high lattice energies that make them highly stable, and no universal statement that polar covalent is always stronger is valid.
- B
- Incorrect. While ionic bonds most commonly form between metals and nonmetals, polar covalent bonds form between different nonmetal atoms (like H-F, O-H), not between identical atoms (which would be nonpolar covalent).
- D
- Incorrect. This reverses the definitions; ionic bonds involve COMPLETE electron transfer (full charges), while polar covalent bonds involve partial charge separation.