A student draws a Lewis structure for the sulfate ion () and finds that it has four equivalent S–O bonds. Which of the following best explains the observation that all four S–O bonds in sulfate have the same bond length?
- AAll four bonds are pure single bonds with no double bond character
- BSulfur uses sp hybridization, resulting in four equivalent bonds arranged linearly
- CThe true structure is a resonance hybrid, so the bond order is delocalized equally across all four bondsCorrect
- DEach oxygen atom donates a lone pair into an empty orbital on sulfur, creating four equivalent dative bonds
Why C is right
The sulfate ion has multiple resonance structures in which double bonds can be placed between sulfur and different oxygen atoms. The actual structure is a resonance hybrid where the bond order is distributed equally across all four S-O bonds, giving them identical bond lengths intermediate between single and double bonds.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because if all bonds were pure single bonds, the bond lengths would be longer than observed; the actual bond length is shorter than a typical S-O single bond due to resonance.
- B
- Incorrect because sulfur in sulfate uses approximately sp^3 hybridization (tetrahedral geometry), not sp hybridization (which would be linear with only two bonds).
- D
- Incorrect because while coordinate bonds exist in some contexts, the equivalence of sulfate bonds is best explained by resonance delocalization, not dative bonding from each oxygen into sulfur.