A student observes that when sodium chloride dissolves in water, the solution temperature drops slightly. The student also observes that when concentrated sulfuric acid () is added to water, the solution temperature rises significantly. Which explanation correctly contrasts these two observations?
- A dissolution breaks only weak ionic bonds, which absorbs heat and cools the solution; dissolution breaks only strong covalent bonds, which releases heat and warms the solution.
- BBoth observations are incorrect; all dissolution processes must be isothermal according to the ideal solution laws.
- C dissolution forms fewer dissolved particles, producing less entropy and so cooling the solution; dissolution forms more dissolved particles, producing more entropy and so heating the solution.
- D dissolution is endothermic as its lattice energy exceeds its hydration energy; dissolution is exothermic as ionization and hydration release more energy than is absorbed.Correct
Why D is right
: . Lattice energy () is slightly larger than hydration energy of and combined (), making dissolution slightly endothermic. Energy flows from surroundings to system: solution cools. : (very exothermic). is strongly associated in pure liquid form, but when added to water, the extensive ionization (, then ) and powerful hydration of , , and ions release far more energy than the energy needed to break interactions. The large negative means energy flows from system to surroundings: solution heats up.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- 's ionic bonds are actually quite strong (lattice energy ), not weak. Breaking any bond absorbs energy, so breaking 's covalent bonds cannot by itself release heat; the process is exothermic because the enormous hydration energy of (aqueous proton) and the other ions more than compensates. The characterization 'weak ionic vs strong covalent' oversimplifies the energetics.
- B
- Ideal solutions (Raoult's Law) do have zero enthalpy of mixing by definition, but –water and –water are non-ideal solutions with significant enthalpic interactions. Temperature changes during dissolution are real and well-documented.
- C
- Entropy changes do affect Gibbs energy of dissolution, but entropy is not the primary explanation for temperature changes observed in calorimetry. The temperature change directly reflects the enthalpy change (). More particles (; up to 3 ions) doesn't directly equate to heating or cooling.