The concept of resonance is applied to the carbonate ion (CO3 2-). Which statement about the carbonate ion's resonance structures is most accurate?
- AThe carbonate ion is best represented as a resonance hybrid with all three C-O bonds equivalent, each with a bond order of 4/3 due to electron delocalization.Correct
- BThe actual structure of CO3 2- is a single resonance structure with one C=O double bond and two C-O single bonds, existing at any given moment.
- CResonance structures of CO3 2- indicate that the oxygen atoms take turns being doubly bonded, sharing this feature through quantum mechanical tunneling.
- DThe three resonance structures of CO3 2- are in rapid equilibrium with each other, with the double-bonded oxygen changing position.
Why A is right
The carbonate ion has three equivalent resonance structures, each showing one C=O and two C-O single bonds. However, the actual structure — the resonance hybrid — is not any one of these but a blend of all three. Electrons are delocalized across all three C-O bonds through a pi system, making all three bonds equivalent. The bond order for each C-O bond is 4/3 (1 double bond + 2 single bonds distributed over 3 bonds = (2+1+1)/3 = 4/3). This is confirmed experimentally by X-ray crystallography showing all three C-O bonds have the same length (~129 pm, between single ~143 pm and double ~120 pm).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- If CO3 2- had one true C=O and two true C-O bonds, they would have different lengths. Experimental data show all three bonds are identical in length, proving the single-resonance-structure model is incorrect.
- C
- Quantum mechanical tunneling involves particles passing through energy barriers and is not the mechanism for resonance. Resonance delocalization is explained by molecular orbital theory and pi electron delocalization, not tunneling.
- D
- Resonance structures do not interconvert or exist in equilibrium. The carbonate ion does not 'flip' between structures. The hybrid is a single stable quantum mechanical state, not a time-averaged mixture of different structures.