Which of the following correctly ranks the lattice energies of MgO, NaF, and CaO in order from lowest to highest?
- ACaO < NaF < MgO
- BNaF < CaO < MgOCorrect
- CNaF < MgO < CaO
- DMgO < NaF < CaO
Why B is right
Lattice energy is proportional to (charge1 x charge2) / (r+ + r-). NaF has +1/-1 charges (small charges, larger ions) — lowest lattice energy (~923 kJ/mol). CaO has +2/-2 charges with Ca2+ (100 pm) and O2- (140 pm) — intermediate (~3401 kJ/mol). MgO has +2/-2 charges with smaller Mg2+ (72 pm) — highest (~3795 kJ/mol). Order: NaF < CaO < MgO.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect. CaO and MgO both have 2+ and 2- charges, but MgO has a smaller cation (Mg2+ vs Ca2+), giving MgO a shorter interionic distance and higher lattice energy than CaO.
- C
- Incorrect. While NaF is correctly placed lowest, MgO should be highest (not middle) because Mg2+ is smaller than Ca2+ despite both having +2 charge.
- D
- Incorrect. MgO has a higher lattice energy than NaF due to its 2+/2- charges compared to NaF's 1+/1- charges; MgO should be highest, not lowest.