Allotropes are different structural forms of the same element. Diamond and graphite are both pure carbon, but they have dramatically different properties. Which comparison is most accurate?
- ADiamond is a network covalent solid with sp3 carbon forming a 3D tetrahedral lattice; graphite is a layered structure with sp2 carbon and delocalized pi electrons that conduct electricity.Correct
- BDiamond has sp2 hybridized carbon forming a planar 2D sheet; graphite has sp3 hybridized carbon with all sigma bonds in a 3D structure.
- CBoth diamond and graphite have sp3 carbon; graphite's slippery property comes from weak metallic bonds between layers.
- DDiamond is a molecular solid with sp3 carbon; graphite is an ionic solid with sp2 carbon and delocalized pi electrons.
Why A is right
Diamond: each carbon is sp3 hybridized with 4 sigma bonds in a tetrahedral arrangement, forming a continuous 3D covalent network. This structure gives diamond extreme hardness (hardest natural mineral) and high melting point. It is a nonconductor because all electrons are in localized sigma bonds. Graphite: each carbon is sp2 hybridized with 3 sigma bonds in a hexagonal planar sheet. The remaining unhybridized 2p orbital on each carbon contributes to a delocalized pi system across the layer, giving graphite good electrical conductivity. The layers are held together by weak van der Waals forces, making graphite slippery and soft.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- This option reverses the hybridizations. Diamond has sp3 carbon (tetrahedral) and graphite has sp2 carbon (planar hexagonal sheets). The swap makes both descriptions incorrect.
- C
- Graphite has sp2 (not sp3) carbon. The slippery property comes from weak van der Waals forces between the graphite layers (not metallic bonds), allowing layers to slide over each other.
- D
- Graphite is not an ionic solid — it is a molecular/covalent solid with metallic-like properties due to delocalized pi electrons. No ions are formed in graphite; all C-C interactions are covalent or van der Waals.