The following questions refer to the passage below.
Passage 2 (Natural Science): The Return of the Wolf — Predators, Prey, and Trophic Cascades
In 1995, gray wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone National Park after a seventy-year absence. Wildlife biologists expected the wolves to control elk populations. What they documented over the following decades went considerably further, reshaping the scientific understanding of how predators interact with entire ecosystems.
The elk population declined after reintroduction, but the more striking changes were behavioral rather than numerical. Elk had previously grazed in river valleys and along stream banks throughout the year. After wolves arrived, elk began avoiding these areas — or visiting only briefly — during periods when wolves were active. The ungrazed riverbanks began to recover. Willows, aspens, and cottonwoods regrew in riparian zones that had been stripped bare for decades. As the vegetation recovered, songbirds and beavers returned. The beavers built dams, creating ponds and slowing the flow of streams. The streams themselves began to change course — meandering more, eroding less, developing deeper channels and more stable banks.
This sequence — wolf reintroduction leading ultimately to physical changes in river morphology — exemplifies what ecologists call a trophic cascade: a process in which changes at one level of the food web propagate through the entire system, altering organisms and environments at levels far removed from the original intervention. The wolves were not directly responsible for the changed river channels. They created the behavioral conditions — elk moving away from riparian areas — that allowed vegetation to recover, which allowed beavers to build dams, which changed the streams.
Not all ecologists accept the strong version of the trophic cascade story. Some researchers argue that the changes in Yellowstone were partly coincidental — that drought recovery, reduced cattle grazing, and the specific composition of the reintroduced wolf population were additional factors. The debate turns on a perennial question in ecology: how much of any ecosystem's structure is determined by its large predators versus by other physical and biological factors?
The Yellowstone case has become a touchstone for conservation arguments worldwide. In areas where large predators have been eliminated — much of Europe, parts of Asia, most of North America — ecosystems may be operating in altered states maintained by the absence of apex predators. Rewilding proposals — the reintroduction of wolves, lynx, bears, or other large predators to their former ranges — draw heavily on the Yellowstone experience as evidence that predator recovery can trigger broader ecological restoration.
According to the passage, what is a 'trophic cascade'?
- AThe periodic movement of large herds of prey animals along migratory river corridors
- BA process in which changes at one level of a food web propagate through the entire ecosystem, altering organisms far removed from the original interventionCorrect
- CA rapid decline in prey populations caused by the sudden reintroduction of a large predator
- DAn ecological technique for measuring the total caloric energy transferred between predator and prey species
Why B is right
The passage defines it directly: 'a process in which changes at one level of the food web propagate through the entire system, altering organisms and environments at levels far removed from the original intervention.'
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because migratory corridors are not part of the trophic cascade definition.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage notes that elk populations declined but emphasizes the behavioral changes were more striking than numerical ones.
- D
- Incorrect because caloric energy transfer measurement is not the definition given.
The following questions refer to the passage below.
Passage 2 (Natural Science): The Return of the Wolf — Predators, Prey, and Trophic Cascades
In 1995, gray wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone National Park after a seventy-year absence. Wildlife biologists expected the wolves to control elk populations. What they documented over the following decades went considerably further, reshaping the scientific understanding of how predators interact with entire ecosystems.
The elk population declined after reintroduction, but the more striking changes were behavioral rather than numerical. Elk had previously grazed in river valleys and along stream banks throughout the year. After wolves arrived, elk began avoiding these areas — or visiting only briefly — during periods when wolves were active. The ungrazed riverbanks began to recover. Willows, aspens, and cottonwoods regrew in riparian zones that had been stripped bare for decades. As the vegetation recovered, songbirds and beavers returned. The beavers built dams, creating ponds and slowing the flow of streams. The streams themselves began to change course — meandering more, eroding less, developing deeper channels and more stable banks.
This sequence — wolf reintroduction leading ultimately to physical changes in river morphology — exemplifies what ecologists call a trophic cascade: a process in which changes at one level of the food web propagate through the entire system, altering organisms and environments at levels far removed from the original intervention. The wolves were not directly responsible for the changed river channels. They created the behavioral conditions — elk moving away from riparian areas — that allowed vegetation to recover, which allowed beavers to build dams, which changed the streams.
Not all ecologists accept the strong version of the trophic cascade story. Some researchers argue that the changes in Yellowstone were partly coincidental — that drought recovery, reduced cattle grazing, and the specific composition of the reintroduced wolf population were additional factors. The debate turns on a perennial question in ecology: how much of any ecosystem's structure is determined by its large predators versus by other physical and biological factors?
The Yellowstone case has become a touchstone for conservation arguments worldwide. In areas where large predators have been eliminated — much of Europe, parts of Asia, most of North America — ecosystems may be operating in altered states maintained by the absence of apex predators. Rewilding proposals — the reintroduction of wolves, lynx, bears, or other large predators to their former ranges — draw heavily on the Yellowstone experience as evidence that predator recovery can trigger broader ecological restoration.
The passage states that the most significant changes after wolf reintroduction were behavioral rather than numerical. What does this mean?
- AThe behavioral flexibility of wolves made them far more effective hunters of elk than the size of their packs alone would predict
- BThe wolves changed elk behavior more than they reduced elk numbers, and this behavioral shift had the larger ecological effectCorrect
- CThe elk adapted to the wolves so quickly that no population decline was ever recorded in the park
- DThe wolves ate more than expected, making population counts difficult for researchers to track accurately
Why B is right
The passage says 'the more striking changes were behavioral rather than numerical' and then describes how elk changed where they grazed — avoiding stream banks — which cascaded into vegetation recovery, beaver activity, and stream changes. The behavior shift drove the ecosystem transformation more than the population reduction did.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the behavioral changes described are those of elk, not wolves.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage does state that the elk population declined — the behavioral changes were described as more striking, not as the only change.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage says the population declined — the tracking difficulty is not the point.
Figure 2 shows a food web diagram for a kelp forest ecosystem. Arrows indicate energy flow (from prey to predator). The described connections are: kelp → sea urchin, kelp → kelp crab, sea urchin → sunflower sea star, sea urchin → sea otter, kelp crab → sea otter, sea otter → killer whale.
Sea otters were removed from the ecosystem due to hunting. Based on the food web, what would be the most likely cascade effect on kelp?
- AKelp would be unaffected, because sea otters do not directly eat kelp.
- BKelp would decrease, because sea otters eat kelp directly.
- CKelp would increase, because without sea otters, sea urchins would decrease.
- DKelp would decrease, because without sea otters, sea urchins would increase and overgraze kelp.Correct
Why D is right
Sea otters eat sea urchins. Without sea otters, sea urchin populations would be released from predation pressure and increase. Sea urchins graze on kelp. An unchecked sea urchin population would overgraze and dramatically reduce kelp — a well-documented 'trophic cascade' effect observed in real kelp forests.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while sea otters do not directly eat kelp, their presence indirectly controls kelp through top-down regulation of sea urchin populations — indirect effects do matter in food webs.
- B
- Incorrect because the food web shows sea otters eat sea urchins and kelp crabs, not kelp; sea otters do not directly consume kelp.
- C
- Incorrect because removing sea otters would cause sea urchins to INCREASE (not decrease), since the predator is removed. The logic is backwards.