The following questions refer to the passage below.
Passage 3 (Natural Science): The concept of a keystone species—one whose presence has a disproportionately large effect on its ecosystem relative to its abundance—emerged from a famous series of experiments conducted along the rocky intertidal zones of the Pacific Northwest coast in the 1960s. Marine ecologist Robert Paine removed sea stars of the species Pisaster ochraceus from a stretch of shoreline and observed what happened next. The results were dramatic: without sea stars to prey on mussels, mussel populations exploded and crowded out nearly every other species from the habitat. Biodiversity collapsed. When Paine reintroduced the sea stars, the ecosystem gradually recovered. The experiment demonstrated that some species exert a regulatory influence far exceeding what their population size would suggest.
The concept quickly gained traction across ecology and conservation biology. Wolves in Yellowstone National Park became the most famous case study. After wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone in 1995 following a seventy-year absence, researchers documented a cascade of ecological changes. Wolf predation reduced elk populations and altered elk behavior—elk began avoiding riverbanks where wolves could ambush them. Freed from overgrazing, riverbank vegetation recovered. Tree roots stabilized eroding streambanks. Rivers began to change course. These second- and third-order effects were termed a "trophic cascade"—a chain of changes moving through multiple levels of the food web.
Not every ecologist accepts the keystone species concept without reservation. Critics argue that it oversimplifies complex ecological relationships and risks creating a misleading narrative in which ecosystems are stable systems disrupted only by the removal of a single critical species. Real ecosystems are constantly changing, shaped by climate, disease, human activity, and chance. A species that behaves as a keystone in one context may be far less influential in another.
Despite these qualifications, the concept has had significant practical influence on conservation policy. Efforts to protect and restore apex predators—wolves, sharks, sea otters, and large cats—are often justified in part by keystone arguments. The logic is appealing: if a single species can restructure an entire ecosystem, then targeted protection of that species may represent an efficient use of limited conservation resources.
Question: The main purpose of the passage is to
- Acompare the effectiveness of marine conservation strategies with terrestrial conservation approaches
- Bargue that Robert Paine's original sea star experiment was methodologically flawed and should be replicated
- Cdemonstrate that apex predators are essential to every ecosystem and should be universally protected
- Dexplain the concept of a keystone species, provide examples of its application, and note both its support and limitationsCorrect
Why D is right
The passage introduces and explains the keystone species concept (paragraph 1), provides key examples (sea stars, Yellowstone wolves, paragraphs 1-2), then notes critical objections (paragraph 3), and concludes with practical implications (paragraph 4). This balanced structure of explanation plus evidence plus qualification matches choice D.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage does not compare marine and terrestrial strategies; it uses both contexts to illustrate the same concept.
- B
- Incorrect because the passage does not critique Paine's methodology; it presents his experiment as evidence for the keystone concept, not as flawed.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage explicitly acknowledges that 'a species that behaves as a keystone in one context may be far less influential in another,' which contradicts a universal claim.
The following questions refer to the passage below.
Passage 3 (Natural Science): The concept of a keystone species—one whose presence has a disproportionately large effect on its ecosystem relative to its abundance—emerged from a famous series of experiments conducted along the rocky intertidal zones of the Pacific Northwest coast in the 1960s. Marine ecologist Robert Paine removed sea stars of the species Pisaster ochraceus from a stretch of shoreline and observed what happened next. The results were dramatic: without sea stars to prey on mussels, mussel populations exploded and crowded out nearly every other species from the habitat. Biodiversity collapsed. When Paine reintroduced the sea stars, the ecosystem gradually recovered. The experiment demonstrated that some species exert a regulatory influence far exceeding what their population size would suggest.
The concept quickly gained traction across ecology and conservation biology. Wolves in Yellowstone National Park became the most famous case study. After wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone in 1995 following a seventy-year absence, researchers documented a cascade of ecological changes. Wolf predation reduced elk populations and altered elk behavior—elk began avoiding riverbanks where wolves could ambush them. Freed from overgrazing, riverbank vegetation recovered. Tree roots stabilized eroding streambanks. Rivers began to change course. These second- and third-order effects were termed a "trophic cascade"—a chain of changes moving through multiple levels of the food web.
Not every ecologist accepts the keystone species concept without reservation. Critics argue that it oversimplifies complex ecological relationships and risks creating a misleading narrative in which ecosystems are stable systems disrupted only by the removal of a single critical species. Real ecosystems are constantly changing, shaped by climate, disease, human activity, and chance. A species that behaves as a keystone in one context may be far less influential in another.
Despite these qualifications, the concept has had significant practical influence on conservation policy. Efforts to protect and restore apex predators—wolves, sharks, sea otters, and large cats—are often justified in part by keystone arguments. The logic is appealing: if a single species can restructure an entire ecosystem, then targeted protection of that species may represent an efficient use of limited conservation resources.
Question: According to the passage, what happened to the riverbank vegetation in Yellowstone after wolves were reintroduced?
- AIt was unaffected by the wolves and recovered only after direct conservation planting
- BIt recovered because elk, fearing wolf predation, avoided grazing along riverbanksCorrect
- CIt was damaged by increased wolf activity along the riverbanks
- DIt declined as flooding increased due to unstable streambanks
Why B is right
The passage explains that elk began avoiding riverbanks where wolves could ambush them, which freed the vegetation from overgrazing and allowed it to recover. This is a direct statement of the trophic cascade mechanism described in the second paragraph.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the passage attributes the recovery to the behavioral change in elk, not to any conservation planting effort.
- C
- Incorrect because the wolves affected vegetation indirectly by changing elk behavior, not by damaging it directly; wolves do not graze on vegetation.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage states that tree roots stabilized eroding streambanks and rivers changed course positively; flooding is not mentioned as a consequence.
The following questions refer to the passage below.
Passage 3 (Natural Science): The concept of a keystone species—one whose presence has a disproportionately large effect on its ecosystem relative to its abundance—emerged from a famous series of experiments conducted along the rocky intertidal zones of the Pacific Northwest coast in the 1960s. Marine ecologist Robert Paine removed sea stars of the species Pisaster ochraceus from a stretch of shoreline and observed what happened next. The results were dramatic: without sea stars to prey on mussels, mussel populations exploded and crowded out nearly every other species from the habitat. Biodiversity collapsed. When Paine reintroduced the sea stars, the ecosystem gradually recovered. The experiment demonstrated that some species exert a regulatory influence far exceeding what their population size would suggest.
The concept quickly gained traction across ecology and conservation biology. Wolves in Yellowstone National Park became the most famous case study. After wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone in 1995 following a seventy-year absence, researchers documented a cascade of ecological changes. Wolf predation reduced elk populations and altered elk behavior—elk began avoiding riverbanks where wolves could ambush them. Freed from overgrazing, riverbank vegetation recovered. Tree roots stabilized eroding streambanks. Rivers began to change course. These second- and third-order effects were termed a "trophic cascade"—a chain of changes moving through multiple levels of the food web.
Not every ecologist accepts the keystone species concept without reservation. Critics argue that it oversimplifies complex ecological relationships and risks creating a misleading narrative in which ecosystems are stable systems disrupted only by the removal of a single critical species. Real ecosystems are constantly changing, shaped by climate, disease, human activity, and chance. A species that behaves as a keystone in one context may be far less influential in another.
Despite these qualifications, the concept has had significant practical influence on conservation policy. Efforts to protect and restore apex predators—wolves, sharks, sea otters, and large cats—are often justified in part by keystone arguments. The logic is appealing: if a single species can restructure an entire ecosystem, then targeted protection of that species may represent an efficient use of limited conservation resources.
Question: The critics mentioned in the third paragraph would most likely agree with which of the following statements?
- AConservation efforts focused on apex predators are wasteful and should be redirected toward habitat preservation
- BThe keystone species concept may overstate the role of individual species in ecosystems that are shaped by many interacting forcesCorrect
- CEcosystem health depends entirely on the diversity of species present, not on the influence of any single species
- DPaine's sea star experiment was conducted improperly and should not be cited in scientific literature
Why B is right
The critics argue that the keystone concept 'oversimplifies complex ecological relationships' and risks a 'misleading narrative' in which ecosystems are stable systems disrupted only by one critical species. They also note that real ecosystems are shaped by climate, disease, human activity, and chance. Choice B captures this measured objection: the concept may overstate the role of individual species in ecosystems shaped by many interacting forces. Choice C overreaches with 'entirely' and 'not on the influence of any single species,' a stronger claim the critics do not make.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the critics' objection is theoretical and scientific, not about resource allocation for conservation; the passage does not attribute that position to them.
- C
- Incorrect because while critics emphasize ecological complexity, they do not endorse the specific claim that diversity alone (not any individual species) determines health; that would be a different argument.
- D
- Incorrect because the critics challenge the broader concept's applicability, not the methodology of Paine's specific experiment.