Skip to content
ACT · Reading

Evidence based

Evidence based appears in 7 reviewed ACT questions and sits in Reading. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Evidence based is tested

Example 1Easier
The following questions refer to the passage below. Passage 1 (Prose Fiction): The summer Grandma Eula came to live with us was the summer I learned that silence could be a form of speech. She arrived with one battered suitcase and a cardboard box sealed with masking tape, and she set up her world in our spare bedroom with the efficiency of a woman who had moved many times before. I was twelve and curious about everything, especially the box she never opened in my presence. Mama had warned me not to pry. "Your grandmother has her ways," she said, which told me nothing except that prying would be noted and punished. But the box exerted a gravitational pull I could not resist, and after a week of watching Grandma Eula move through our house like a polite ghost, I asked her directly: "What's in the box?" She looked at me over her reading glasses. She had been sitting at the kitchen table with a cup of coffee and a worn Bible, though I had not seen her actually read anything in it. She considered my question for a long time—long enough that I began to feel the question had been rude. "Letters," she finally said. "And a few photographs." I waited for more, but she returned to her coffee. I thought that was the end of it. But two days later, she called me into her room and the box was open on the bed. She sat beside it and patted the bedspread for me to sit next to her. For three hours, she showed me her life. A photograph of her as a young woman standing in front of a cotton field in Mississippi, her dress white and pressed, her expression closed against the camera. Letters from a brother who had moved north to Chicago and written back about a city I could not imagine from his descriptions. A folded newspaper clipping about a church fire in 1963. She described each item briefly, without drama, and I understood that this was not a performance of grief—it was an inventory. She was making sure I knew where she had been. When she closed the box, she said, "Now you know something." She did not say what I knew. But I felt the weight of it, the way you feel the weight of an object you didn't realize was heavy until you tried to set it down. I never asked about the box again. But from that afternoon on, when she sat at the kitchen table with her coffee and her closed Bible, I sat with her. We didn't always talk. We didn't need to. The silence between us had become something else—a kind of inheritance I hadn't known I was receiving until it was already mine. Question: Which detail from the passage best supports the claim that Grandma Eula had lived an unsettled life before arriving at the narrator's home?
  1. AShe waited two days after the narrator's question before opening the box
  2. BShe described the contents of the box briefly, without drama
  3. CShe set up her world in the spare bedroom with the efficiency of a woman who had moved many times beforeCorrect
  4. DShe sat at the kitchen table with a cup of coffee and a worn Bible that she was never seen actually reading

Why C is right

The phrase 'the efficiency of a woman who had moved many times before' directly implies that the grandmother had frequently relocated, indicating an unsettled life prior to arriving. This is the passage's most direct textual evidence of previous instability or frequent movement.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the two-day delay relates to the grandmother's reserve and decision-making style, not evidence of having moved frequently.
B
Incorrect because describing things without drama suggests emotional restraint or composure, not an unsettled life history.
D
Incorrect because sitting with coffee and an unread Bible suggests private spirituality or habit, not a history of frequent relocation.
Example 2Medium
The following questions refer to the passage below. Passage 3 (Natural Science): The concept of a keystone species—one whose presence has a disproportionately large effect on its ecosystem relative to its abundance—emerged from a famous series of experiments conducted along the rocky intertidal zones of the Pacific Northwest coast in the 1960s. Marine ecologist Robert Paine removed sea stars of the species Pisaster ochraceus from a stretch of shoreline and observed what happened next. The results were dramatic: without sea stars to prey on mussels, mussel populations exploded and crowded out nearly every other species from the habitat. Biodiversity collapsed. When Paine reintroduced the sea stars, the ecosystem gradually recovered. The experiment demonstrated that some species exert a regulatory influence far exceeding what their population size would suggest. The concept quickly gained traction across ecology and conservation biology. Wolves in Yellowstone National Park became the most famous case study. After wolves were reintroduced to Yellowstone in 1995 following a seventy-year absence, researchers documented a cascade of ecological changes. Wolf predation reduced elk populations and altered elk behavior—elk began avoiding riverbanks where wolves could ambush them. Freed from overgrazing, riverbank vegetation recovered. Tree roots stabilized eroding streambanks. Rivers began to change course. These second- and third-order effects were termed a "trophic cascade"—a chain of changes moving through multiple levels of the food web. Not every ecologist accepts the keystone species concept without reservation. Critics argue that it oversimplifies complex ecological relationships and risks creating a misleading narrative in which ecosystems are stable systems disrupted only by the removal of a single critical species. Real ecosystems are constantly changing, shaped by climate, disease, human activity, and chance. A species that behaves as a keystone in one context may be far less influential in another. Despite these qualifications, the concept has had significant practical influence on conservation policy. Efforts to protect and restore apex predators—wolves, sharks, sea otters, and large cats—are often justified in part by keystone arguments. The logic is appealing: if a single species can restructure an entire ecosystem, then targeted protection of that species may represent an efficient use of limited conservation resources. Question: Which detail from the passage best supports the argument that the keystone species concept has value beyond academic ecology?
  1. AThe wolves reintroduced to Yellowstone had been absent for seventy years
  2. BRobert Paine removed sea stars from a stretch of Pacific Northwest shoreline in the 1960s
  3. CEfforts to protect and restore apex predators are often justified using keystone arguments, making species protection an efficient use of conservation resourcesCorrect
  4. DCritics argue that ecosystems are shaped by climate, disease, human activity, and chance

Why C is right

The fourth paragraph explicitly discusses conservation policy applications, stating that apex predator protection is 'often justified in part by keystone arguments' and framing it as potentially efficient use of limited resources. This directly supports the concept's practical, beyond-academic value.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the seventy-year absence is context for the Yellowstone reintroduction study, not evidence of real-world conservation applications.
B
Incorrect because Paine's experiment is the original scientific evidence for the concept, not evidence of its policy or practical application.
D
Incorrect because this detail supports critics' objections to the concept, not evidence of the concept's practical value.
Example 3Medium
The following questions refer to the passage below. Passage 3 (Prose Fiction): The hardware store had belonged to Gerald's father, and his father's father before that, and for as long as Gerald could remember it had smelled the same: machine oil, sawdust, and something sweet he could never identify, perhaps just the particular mixture of metal and old wood that accumulated over decades. He had never wanted the store. He had gone to college for electrical engineering, come back to help during his father's illness, and then simply never left. On a Tuesday in November, a woman he didn't recognize came in looking for a specific kind of hinge—a butterfly hinge for an antique writing desk. Gerald knew he had them in the back, in a box that hadn't been touched in years, because his father had bought a surplus lot in 1984. The woman was perhaps seventy, dressed for weather that hadn't arrived yet, in a wool coat with wooden buttons. "My husband's desk," she said, without being asked. "He passed in April. The hinge has been broken since before he died, and I keep meaning to fix it." Gerald found the box without difficulty—his father had organized everything and Gerald had never reorganized it, which sometimes felt like neglect and sometimes felt like preservation. The hinges were there, still in their original packaging. "I'll only need two," the woman said. She looked at the box. "You have quite a few." "We have quite a few of a lot of things," Gerald said. He wasn't sure why he said it. It felt like an admission. He charged her less than the marked price. She didn't notice, or she noticed and said nothing. He watched her leave and then stood for a while in the aisle without moving, listening to the particular quiet of a store with no customers, which was different from any other kind of quiet he knew. Question: Which detail from the passage best supports the inference that Gerald felt an unspoken connection with the woman's situation?
  1. AHe found the hinges easily because his father had organized the store meticulously
  2. BHe noted that the butterfly hinges were still in their original packaging from a 1984 purchase
  3. CHe had gone to college for electrical engineering but came back to help during his father's illness
  4. DHe charged her less than the marked price, then stood listening to the quiet after she leftCorrect

Why D is right

Charging less than the marked price is an unexplained act of generosity toward someone who just revealed she was recently widowed. Standing still and listening to the quiet afterward suggests the encounter affected Gerald in some way he does not fully articulate. Together these details support the inference of an unspoken emotional connection.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because finding the hinges easily is about the store's organization; it is operationally relevant but does not indicate emotional connection.
B
Incorrect because the packaging date is a factual detail supporting the store's unchanged character; it does not indicate anything about Gerald's response to the woman.
C
Incorrect because Gerald's educational background is backstory about his own life, not a response to the woman's situation or evidence of connection with her.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Reading.