Text 1 is original practice text.
Text 1
Urban highway removal—the demolition of elevated or depressed freeways that bisected American cities during the mid-twentieth century—has been associated with significant urban revitalization. Cities that have removed urban freeways, from Seoul to San Francisco, have typically seen increases in adjacent property values, improved air quality, and the reconnection of previously divided neighborhoods.
Text 2
The cities most frequently cited as success stories of urban freeway removal—Seoul, San Francisco's Embarcadero—all shared important preconditions: extensive alternative transit infrastructure was already in place, the removed highway was structurally obsolete, and vehicle traffic was able to redistribute to parallel routes. These conditions are not present in most American cities, where car dependency remains high and alternative transit is limited.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the Text 1 author's optimistic account of urban freeway removal?
- ABy contending that the success stories in Text 1 relied on specific conditions that may not be replicable in most citiesCorrect
- BBy agreeing that freeway removal is beneficial but arguing it should be paired with congestion pricing to manage traffic
- CBy suggesting that the air quality improvements following freeway removal are too modest to justify the cost of demolition
- DBy arguing that property value increases near removed highways benefit wealthy residents while displacing lower-income communities
Why A is right
The author of Text 2 explicitly argues that the cited successes had specific preconditions (transit alternatives, structural obsolescence, redistributable traffic) not present in most American cities. The author of Text 2 would challenge the generalizability of the cases cited by the author of Text 1.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not propose congestion pricing; the argument questions whether removal is advisable without the necessary preconditions.
- C
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not address air quality or cost-benefit calculations; the critique is about transferability.
- D
- Incorrect because displacement and property value distribution are not the Text 2 author's concerns; the argument is about preconditions for success.
The following text is original practice text.
A city planner is studying the relationship between neighborhood walkability scores and residents' reported levels of physical activity. She hypothesizes that residents in more walkable neighborhoods will report higher levels of daily physical activity.
The planner surveys residents in neighborhoods with varying walkability scores (measured on a 0-100 scale) and records average daily steps:
Table: Walkability score and average daily steps
| Walkability score range | Average daily steps |
|---|---|
| 0-25 (car-dependent) | 4,200 |
| 26-50 (some walkability) | 5,800 |
| 51-75 (very walkable) | 7,600 |
| 76-100 (walker's paradise) | 9,100 |
Which choice most accurately represents the data shown in the table?
- AThe increase in daily steps is identical between each consecutive walkability category, showing a perfectly linear relationship.
- BResidents in neighborhoods with walkability scores above 75 average 9,100 steps per day, exceeding health guidelines for daily step targets.
- CDaily step counts increase consistently with walkability score, with the highest walkability neighborhoods averaging more than twice the steps of the lowest.Correct
- DResidents of car-dependent neighborhoods take fewer than half as many daily steps as residents of the most walkable neighborhoods.
Why C is right
Choice C is correct: step counts increase consistently across all four categories (4,200; 5,800; 7,600; 9,100), and the highest walkability group (9,100) averages more than twice the lowest group (2 × 4,200 = 8,400 < 9,100).
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the increases between categories are 1,600; 1,800; and 1,500 steps—similar but not identical, so the relationship is not perfectly linear.
- B
- Incorrect because the table does not mention health guidelines for daily step targets; this information is not present in the data and cannot be confirmed from the table.
- D
- Incorrect because the data do not show direct proportionality: doubling the walkability range does not exactly double the steps (e.g., the steps do not scale by a fixed ratio with the score), so 'exactly twice the steps' is not supported.
The following text is original practice text.
A transportation planner is examining the relationship between urban density (residents per square mile) and per capita carbon emissions from transportation in twenty metropolitan areas. She hypothesizes that denser cities will have lower per capita transportation emissions because residents walk more, use transit more, and drive shorter distances.
The planner compiles the following data:
Table: Urban density and per capita transportation emissions
| Density category | Average residents per sq mile | Average annual CO₂ per capita from transport (metric tons) |
|---|---|---|
| Very low density | 800 | 7.4 |
| Low density | 2,500 | 5.8 |
| Medium density | 6,000 | 4.1 |
| High density | 15,000 | 2.9 |
| Very high density | 35,000 | 1.6 |
Which choice uses data from the table to most directly support the planner's hypothesis?
- APer capita transportation emissions decrease consistently as urban density increases, from 7.4 metric tons in very low-density areas to 1.6 in very high-density areas.Correct
- BHigh-density cities emit 2.9 metric tons per capita from transportation, which is below the global average of 3.5 metric tons per capita for all cities.
- CVery low-density cities average 7.4 metric tons of CO₂ per capita from transportation, while very high-density cities average only 1.6—less than a quarter of the very low-density figure.
- DThe difference in per capita emissions between very low-density and low-density cities is 1.6 metric tons, the largest single-category decrease in the table.
Why A is right
The hypothesis predicts that denser cities have lower per capita transportation emissions. Choice A directly supports this by citing the consistent decrease in emissions across all five density categories, from 7.4 metric tons in very low-density areas down to 1.6 metric tons in very high-density areas as density rises from 800 to 35,000 residents per square mile. Choice B is wrong because the table provides no global average to compare against. Choice C is true but uses only the two endpoints rather than the full trend, making it less comprehensive support. Choice D is wrong because the largest single-category decrease is 1.7 metric tons (low to medium density), not the 1.6 between very low and low density.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the table does not provide a global average, making this comparison impossible to verify from the data given.
- C
- Incorrect because 1.6/7.4 ≈ 0.216, meaning very high density cities emit about 22% of very low density cities—slightly less than 'a quarter' (25%). This comparison is approximately correct but less precise and comprehensive than choice B.
- D
- Incorrect because the single-category decreases are: 1.6 (very low to low), 1.7 (low to medium), 1.2 (medium to high), 1.3 (high to very high). The largest decrease is between low and medium density (1.7), not very low and low density (1.6).