Skip to content
SAT · Information and Ideas

Command of evidence textual

Command of evidence textual appears in 44 reviewed SAT questions and sits in Information and Ideas. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Command of evidence textual is tested

Example 1Medium
The following text is original practice text. Researchers studying urban neighborhoods have long debated the causes of residential segregation. A team at Westfield University recently proposed that historical redlining policies—federal maps that designated minority neighborhoods as poor lending risks—continue to shape contemporary housing patterns even decades after the practice was officially banned. The team analyzed property records, demographic data, and mortgage approval rates across forty American cities. They found that areas once marked as high-risk by redlining maps had 37% lower homeownership rates and significantly fewer bank branches than surrounding neighborhoods—suggesting that the effects of mid-twentieth-century policy remain structurally embedded in urban geography. Which finding, if true, would most directly support the researchers' claim?
  1. ACities that implemented anti-discrimination housing laws in the 1970s show no measurable difference in homeownership rates across neighborhoods.
  2. BThe number of bank branches in a neighborhood is primarily determined by current population density rather than historical lending policies.
  3. CNeighborhoods redlined in the 1940s still receive fewer small-business loans and have lower median home values than non-redlined areas today.Correct
  4. DHomeownership rates across the United States have declined steadily since the 2008 financial crisis regardless of neighborhood history.

Why C is right

The researchers claim that redlining's effects are 'structurally embedded' in current urban geography. Evidence that redlined neighborhoods today still face reduced lending and lower home values directly supports the claim that historical policy continues to shape present-day outcomes.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because this finding would undermine the researchers' claim by suggesting that anti-discrimination laws successfully eliminated redlining's effects.
B
Incorrect because this finding would weaken the claim by attributing current bank branch distribution to present-day demographics rather than historical policy.
D
Incorrect because a universal national decline in homeownership does not specifically support the claim that redlined areas are disproportionately affected by historical policy.
Example 2Harder
The following text is original practice text. Archaeologists excavating a site in present-day southeastern Turkey unearthed what may be the earliest evidence of organized grain storage. The site, dated to approximately 10,500 BCE, contains large communal structures with thick clay walls and interior bins whose residue analysis revealed traces of emmer wheat and einkorn barley. The researchers argue that centralized grain storage of this scale implies not only surplus agricultural production but also some form of coordinated social management—suggesting that complex social organization may have preceded, rather than followed, the full development of agriculture. Which finding, if true, would most directly support the researchers' argument?
  1. AAnalysis of skeletal remains at the site indicates that the population was socially stratified, with some individuals receiving more nutritious diets than others.Correct
  2. BEmmer wheat and einkorn barley are among the most calorie-dense grains available to early humans in the region.
  3. CGrain storage bins from later periods in the same region are consistently smaller, suggesting a decline in agricultural production.
  4. DOther sites from the same period in the region show evidence of mobile hunter-gatherer lifestyles with no permanent storage structures.

Why A is right

The researchers argue that large communal storage implies coordinated social management—i.e., complex social organization. Evidence of social stratification at the same site and time period directly supports the idea that complex social structures existed at this early date.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because the calorie density of grains does not address the researchers' claim about social organization; it only speaks to nutritional value.
C
Incorrect because a later decline in storage size does not support the argument about early social complexity; it is irrelevant to the researchers' central claim.
D
Incorrect because evidence of hunter-gatherers elsewhere does not directly support the claim about complex social organization at this specific site.
Example 3Harder
The following text is original practice text. A team of primatologists studying chimpanzees in Uganda recorded over four hundred distinct gestural communications used by the animals in natural social contexts. The researchers found that many of these gestures were used flexibly—a single gesture could convey different meanings depending on the social situation, and the same meaning could be conveyed by multiple gestures. This flexibility, previously thought to be unique to human language, suggests that the foundations of intentional, context-dependent communication may have deep evolutionary roots predating the emergence of Homo sapiens. Which finding, if true, would most directly support the researchers' conclusion?
  1. AHuman infants begin using intentional gestures before they develop spoken language, suggesting that gesture precedes speech in development.
  2. BThe same gestural flexibility observed in the Ugandan chimpanzees is also found in gorillas and bonobos, other great apes closely related to humans.Correct
  3. CChimpanzees in captivity use fewer distinct gestures than wild chimpanzees, suggesting that social complexity drives gestural development.
  4. DSome chimpanzee gestures are learned from other group members rather than being entirely innate, implying a degree of cultural transmission.

Why B is right

The researchers conclude that context-dependent communication has 'deep evolutionary roots.' Finding the same flexibility across multiple great apes would indicate this trait is ancestral and predates human evolution, directly supporting the claim.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because human infant development patterns do not speak to the evolutionary origins of flexible communication in non-human primates.
C
Incorrect because the relationship between social complexity and gesture development does not directly address whether flexible communication predates humans evolutionarily.
D
Incorrect because cultural transmission in chimpanzees is an interesting finding but does not specifically support the claim about evolutionary roots of flexible communication.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Information and Ideas.