The following text is original practice text.
Thomas Kuhn's concept of the 'paradigm shift' has become so ubiquitous in popular discourse that it risks losing all precision. In Kuhn's original 1962 formulation, a paradigm shift is not merely a significant new finding but a wholesale restructuring of the assumptions, methods, and problems that define normal science within a field. It is the replacement of one incommensurable worldview with another, not the addition of new knowledge within a stable framework. Used loosely to describe any surprising result, the term becomes meaningless.
Which choice best states the main purpose of the text?
- ATo argue that Kuhn's theory of scientific revolutions was fundamentally flawed from the beginning
- BTo restore the precise meaning of a specialized term that has been diluted through popular misuseCorrect
- CTo introduce Kuhn's concept of the paradigm shift to readers who may be unfamiliar with his work
- DTo compare Kuhn's theory to alternative accounts of scientific progress offered by other philosophers
Why B is right
The text explains Kuhn's original precise meaning, contrasts it with loose popular usage, and warns that imprecise use makes the term 'meaningless.' The purpose is to restore precision to a diluted concept.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the text defends Kuhn's precise meaning rather than challenging his theory.
- C
- Incorrect because the text assumes the reader knows the term; the purpose is correction of misuse, not introduction to an unfamiliar concept.
- D
- Incorrect because no alternative philosopher or theory is mentioned; the text focuses solely on Kuhn's concept and its misapplication.
Text 1 is original practice text.
Text 1
The concept of 'fitness' in evolutionary biology refers strictly to reproductive success—the ability of an organism to survive and leave offspring in a given environment. It has no normative content: a highly 'fit' organism is not better in any moral or aesthetic sense, merely more reproductively successful. The misapplication of evolutionary 'fitness' to social hierarchies and human worth produced the pseudoscience of social Darwinism.
Text 2
The is/ought problem in evolutionary biology persists even when biologists explicitly disclaim normative intent. Once 'fitness' is introduced as a technical term, readers and policymakers tend to import value judgments that the scientist did not intend. The very vocabulary of success and failure in evolutionary description subtly shapes how audiences interpret human variation, regardless of the author's disclaimers.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the Text 1 author's claim that 'fitness' "has no normative content"?
- ABy arguing that 'fitness' should be replaced by a less intuitive term to reduce the risk of misinterpretation
- BBy agreeing that 'fitness' is normatively neutral but arguing that social Darwinism arose from deliberate distortion
- CBy suggesting that scientific disclaimers are legally binding and prevent misuse of biological terminology
- DBy contending that the term's normative neutrality in intent does not prevent audiences from importing value judgmentsCorrect
Why D is right
The Text 2 author's argument is precisely that even when scientists disclaim normative intent, the vocabulary still shapes how audiences interpret meaning. The author of Text 1 says there's no normative content; the author of Text 2 says that disclaimer doesn't prevent audiences from importing values.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not propose replacing the term; the argument is about the persistent rhetorical effect of any such vocabulary.
- B
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not attribute social Darwinism to deliberate distortion; the argument is about unintended audience interpretations.
- C
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 explicitly challenges the effectiveness of disclaimers; the claim is that disclaimers don't stop value importation.
The following text is original practice text.
Karl Popper's criterion of falsifiability holds that a scientific theory must make predictions that are in principle capable of being proven false by empirical observation. A theory that can accommodate any possible evidence—explaining success and failure alike—is unfalsifiable and therefore, Popper argued, not genuinely scientific. He used psychoanalysis as an example: when Freudian theory predicts a patient will exhibit a symptom and the patient does not, the analyst can always attribute the absence to repression, making the theory immune to disconfirmation. This immunization strategy, Popper argued, is the hallmark of pseudoscience.
Which choice best states the main purpose of the text?
- ATo explain Popper's falsifiability criterion, illustrate the problem it addresses with a specific example, and identify the pseudoscientific strategy it is designed to detectCorrect
- BTo argue that psychoanalysis has been unfairly dismissed by philosophers of science and deserves rehabilitation
- CTo trace Popper's influence on how academic institutions evaluate and fund scientific research proposals
- DTo compare Popper's philosophy of science with that of Thomas Kuhn and determine which offers a better account of scientific practice
Why A is right
The text explains falsifiability as a criterion, uses psychoanalysis to illustrate the problem of unfalsifiability, and identifies 'immunization' as the pseudoscientific strategy Popper targeted. The purpose follows this explanatory arc.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the text presents psychoanalysis as Popper's example of pseudoscience; no rehabilitation argument is made.
- C
- Incorrect because institutional funding is never mentioned; the text is purely philosophical.
- D
- Incorrect because Kuhn is not mentioned; the text focuses exclusively on Popper.