Text 1 is original practice text.
Text 1
Carbon taxes are the most economically efficient tool for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. By placing a direct price on carbon, governments create a market signal that incentivizes businesses to innovate and consumers to shift behavior. Revenue generated can fund clean energy transitions.
Text 2
The appeal of carbon taxes rests on idealized assumptions about market behavior. In practice, low-income households bear a disproportionate share of the burden, since they spend a higher percentage of income on energy and goods. Without robust redistribution mechanisms, carbon taxes can deepen inequality even as they reduce emissions.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the claim in Text 1 that carbon tax revenue "can fund clean energy transitions"?
- ABy arguing that revenue should prioritize compensating low-income households before funding energy transitionsCorrect
- BBy suggesting that carbon taxes cannot generate sufficient revenue to fund large-scale transitions
- CBy contending that clean energy investment is unnecessary if market signals are functioning properly
- DBy agreeing that revenue allocation is the central advantage of carbon taxes over other climate policies
Why A is right
The Text 2 author's argument centers on the disproportionate burden on low-income households and the need for 'robust redistribution mechanisms,' so the author of Text 2 would redirect revenue toward compensating those households first.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the Text 2 author's critique is about distributional inequality, not about revenue adequacy.
- C
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not claim market signals are sufficient; the author is skeptical of idealized market assumptions.
- D
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 is critical of carbon taxes, not enthusiastic about their revenue advantage.
Text 1 is original practice text.
Text 1
The Harlem Renaissance is best understood as a deliberate artistic project. Intellectuals like Alain Locke actively curated which voices and aesthetic styles would represent the 'New Negro' to white patrons and publishers. This curation, while enabling Black artists to reach mainstream audiences, also constrained which stories could be told.
Text 2
To call the Harlem Renaissance a 'deliberate project' risks underestimating the organic energy of its participants. Poets, painters, and musicians were not marionettes guided by elite intellectuals; they pursued individual visions that happened to converge in a moment of extraordinary cultural vitality.
Which choice best describes how the perspective of the author of Text 2 differs from that of the author of Text 1?
- AText 2 argues the Harlem Renaissance was primarily a literary movement, while Text 1 sees it as a visual arts phenomenon.
- BText 2 foregrounds the independence and agency of individual artists, while Text 1 stresses the role of intellectual curation.Correct
- CText 2 emphasizes the commercial motivations of Harlem Renaissance artists, while Text 1 focuses on their political goals.
- DText 2 credits white patrons for the Renaissance's success, while Text 1 credits Black intellectuals.
Why B is right
The author of Text 1 emphasizes Locke's role in curating and shaping the Renaissance (curation by intellectuals), while the author of Text 2 argues artists pursued individual visions independently. This maps directly to B.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because both authors refer to multiple art forms (poets, painters, musicians) without privileging one medium.
- C
- Incorrect because neither author focuses on commercial motivation versus political goals; the debate is about agency versus curation.
- D
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not credit white patrons; the Text 2 author credits the artists themselves with organic energy.
Text 1 is original practice text.
Text 1
Recent neuroimaging studies show that when humans make moral judgments, brain regions associated with emotion—particularly the amygdala and insula—activate before regions associated with deliberative reasoning. This suggests that moral decisions are primarily emotional, with reason serving mainly to rationalize choices already made.
Text 2
The sequence of neural activation does not settle questions about moral epistemology. Even if emotion precedes articulate reasoning in real time, it does not follow that emotion is the actual justificatory basis of moral judgment. The logical structure of a moral argument stands independent of its psychological genesis.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the claim in Text 1 that moral decisions are "primarily emotional"?
- ABy contending that the causal sequence of brain activity does not determine what actually justifies a moral judgmentCorrect
- BBy arguing that the neuroimaging data are methodologically flawed and should be replicated before drawing conclusions
- CBy suggesting that emotion and reason are so intertwined in the brain that distinguishing them is scientifically impossible
- DBy agreeing that emotional responses are indispensable to moral perception but contending they operate differently than neuroimaging reveals
Why A is right
Text 2 explicitly argues that the temporal sequence of neural activation does not reveal the 'justificatory basis' of moral judgment—the logical argument stands apart from its psychological origin. This matches choice A: the causal sequence of brain activity does not determine what actually justifies a moral judgment.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because Text 2 does not challenge the methodology of the study; it challenges the philosophical interpretation of the data.
- C
- Incorrect because Text 2 does not argue that emotion and reason are indistinguishable; it separates psychological process from logical justification.
- D
- Incorrect because Text 2 does not agree that emotion is indispensable; it challenges the inferential leap from timing to justification.