Skip to content
SAT · Craft and Structure

Literary criticism

Literary criticism appears in 3 reviewed SAT questions and sits in Craft and Structure. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Literary criticism is tested

Example 1Medium
The following text is original practice text. Hurston's prose style is inseparable from her training as an anthropologist. Her years collecting folklore in the American South and the Caribbean taught her to listen carefully to the rhythms of vernacular speech. When she transcribed dialogue in her fiction, she was not condescending to her characters but honoring a linguistic tradition as rich and rule-governed as any standardized form. Critics who called her dialect writing quaint misunderstood the precision it required. Which choice best describes the overall structure of the text?
  1. AA claim about an author's technique is supported, then a misreading of it is corrected.Correct
  2. BTwo competing theories about an author's style are presented, and one of them is ultimately endorsed.
  3. CA personal anecdote is introduced, followed by a broader historical context that explains its significance.
  4. DA historical event is described, and its lasting influence on a later literary movement is assessed.

Why A is right

The text first claims Hurston's dialect writing was precise and respectful (supporting her technique), then corrects critics who misunderstood it as quaint. This matches 'claim supported, then a misreading of it corrected.'
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because only one view (critics calling her work quaint) is presented as wrong; no two competing theories are weighed.
C
Incorrect because no personal anecdote appears; the text discusses Hurston's professional background and critical reception.
D
Incorrect because no historical event is the focus; the subject is Hurston's writing technique and its critical reception.
Example 2Medium
The following text is original practice text. The term 'unreliable narrator' was introduced by scholar Wayne Booth in 1961 to describe a narrator whose account of events diverges—sometimes subtly, sometimes dramatically—from the implied author's intended meaning. Readers must learn to read against the narrator's self-presentation, inferring what the narrator cannot or will not acknowledge. The technique creates dramatic irony, placing readers in a position of knowing more than the narrator knows about the narrator. Works from Poe's 'The Tell-Tale Heart' to Kazuo Ishiguro's 'The Remains of the Day' exploit this gap between what is said and what is meant. The author includes references to Poe and Ishiguro primarily to
  1. Ademonstrate that unreliable narration originated in nineteenth-century American fiction and later spread to British literature
  2. Bargue that Ishiguro's use of the unreliable narrator is more sophisticated than Poe's because of its psychological subtlety
  3. Cprovide biographical context that explains why both authors were drawn to narrators who conceal the truth
  4. Dshow that the technique of unreliable narration spans different literary traditions and historical periodsCorrect

Why D is right

The two examples are from different eras (19th vs. 20th century) and traditions (American vs. British/Japanese), illustrating that unreliable narration is a broad, enduring technique—not confined to one place or time.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the text does not trace a historical origin or a spread between national traditions; the examples show breadth, not origin.
B
Incorrect because no comparison of sophistication between the two authors is made.
C
Incorrect because no biographical information about either author is offered.
Example 3Easier
William Shakespeare's tragedies have fascinated audiences for over four centuries and have spawned an enormous body of literary criticism. Some scholars approach his plays through the lens of historical context, reading them as products of Elizabethan and Jacobean society. _______, others apply contemporary theoretical frameworks—such as feminist criticism, postcolonial theory, or psychoanalytic readings—to illuminate dimensions of the plays that historical approaches might overlook.
  1. ATherefore,
  2. BIn contrast,Correct
  3. CSpecifically,
  4. DAs a result,

Why B is right

'In contrast' correctly signals that the two scholarly approaches are being explicitly contrasted: historical/contextualist readings versus contemporary theoretical frameworks. The two represent different interpretive orientations, making contrast the appropriate logical relationship.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because 'therefore' signals a logical consequence, implying contemporary theory is derived from or caused by the historical approach, but the two are parallel and competing, not causally related.
C
Incorrect because 'specifically' narrows or elaborates on the preceding claim, but the second scholarly approach is being contrasted with the first, not specifying a detail about it.
D
Incorrect because 'as a result' signals that contemporary theory arose as a consequence of historical criticism, but the two represent parallel, independent scholarly traditions.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Craft and Structure.