Text 1 is original practice text.
Text 1
Mixed-income housing developments—projects that integrate market-rate and subsidized units—have been championed as a tool for reducing concentrated poverty. By dispersing low-income residents among higher-income neighbors, planners hope to expose them to stronger social networks and higher-quality local institutions.
Text 2
The social network theory underlying mixed-income housing rests on an assumption rarely validated by data: that proximity produces meaningful interaction across class lines. Studies repeatedly show that residents of market-rate and subsidized units in the same building may share an address while inhabiting entirely separate social worlds.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the claim in Text 1 that mixed-income housing exposes low-income residents to "stronger social networks"?
- ABy arguing that the benefits of social networks are overstated compared to the material benefits of improved local institutions
- BBy contending that physical proximity alone does not reliably produce the cross-class social connections that the policy assumesCorrect
- CBy agreeing that social network access is valuable but arguing that subsidized housing units should be better distributed across cities
- DBy suggesting that mixed-income housing developments are too expensive to implement at the scale required to reduce poverty
Why B is right
The Text 2 author's entire argument is that proximity does not lead to meaningful interaction across class lines—residents 'inhabit entirely separate social worlds.' This directly challenges the assumption in Text 1 about social network exposure.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not compare social networks to material benefits; the critique is specifically about whether proximity creates networks at all.
- C
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not endorse the policy with modifications; the critique questions the foundational assumption about social integration.
- D
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 never raises cost as an issue; the critique is about the social mechanism, not the price of implementation.
The following text is original practice text.
The American suburb, often imagined as a natural product of the postwar family's desire for space and privacy, was in fact substantially engineered by federal policy. The Federal Housing Administration's mortgage guaranty program, created in 1934 and expanded after World War II, made suburban homeownership affordable for white working-class families while systematically denying loans to Black families and to neighborhoods with any significant minority population—a practice known as 'redlining.' The wealth gap between white and Black Americans traceable to homeownership and home equity has its roots in these deliberately exclusionary policies.
Which choice best states the main purpose of the text?
- ATo compare the mortgage lending practices of public agencies to those of private banks during the postwar era
- BTo trace the history of the Federal Housing Administration from its founding through the present
- CTo describe the architectural features of postwar suburban developments and their influence on American domestic life
- DTo argue that federal housing policy intentionally produced racial inequality whose effects persist in wealth disparitiesCorrect
Why D is right
The text argues that the suburb was 'engineered' by federal policy, that this policy deliberately excluded Black families, and that this exclusion produced lasting wealth disparities. The purpose is to attribute racial wealth inequality to intentional federal housing policy.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because private banks are never mentioned; the focus is exclusively on FHA policy.
- B
- Incorrect because the text covers only the 1934-postwar period specifically related to redlining, not a full institutional history.
- C
- Incorrect because no architectural features are described; the text is about policy and racial exclusion.
Text 1 is original practice text.
Text 1
Rent control—price ceilings on residential rents—reduces housing affordability in the long run by discouraging new construction and causing property owners to convert rental units to condominiums or allow deterioration. Cities with the most stringent rent controls consistently have the lowest vacancy rates and the most expensive market-rate units, as the controlled sector shrinks and demand concentrates.
Text 2
The economic model underlying anti-rent-control arguments treats housing as a commodity like any other, ignoring its social function. Long-term tenants in rent-controlled apartments develop deep community ties—relationships with neighbors, proximity to schools and jobs, access to social services—that are destroyed when displacement occurs. Even if rent control reduces housing supply marginally at the aggregate level, it preserves stability for the most vulnerable tenants who cannot easily absorb displacement.
Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the claim by the author of Text 1 that cities with rent control have the least affordable overall housing markets?
- ABy contending that housing should be evaluated by social stability metrics, not only aggregate market affordabilityCorrect
- BBy suggesting that the vacancy rate is an unreliable measure of a housing market's health
- CBy arguing that the Text 1 author's data come from cities where rent control began too recently to show benefits
- DBy agreeing that rent control reduces supply but arguing that additional housing subsidies can offset the supply shortfall
Why A is right
The author of Text 2 argues that treating housing as a pure commodity ignores its social function—stability, community ties, displacement prevention. The author of Text 2 would reject the Text 1 author's market affordability frame by offering a different evaluative standard.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not engage with vacancy rates as a metric; the argument is about what we should measure, not measurement validity.
- C
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not challenge the Text 1 author's data or its recency; the critique is about what metrics matter.
- D
- Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not accept the supply reduction framing as decisive or propose subsidy offsets; the critique challenges the entire framework.