Skip to content
SAT · Information and Ideas

Evolution

Evolution appears in 9 reviewed SAT questions and sits in Information and Ideas. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Evolution is tested

Example 1Medium
The following text is original practice text. Charles Darwin delayed publishing his theory of natural selection for over twenty years after developing its essential outlines in 1838. He spent this time collecting evidence across an enormous range of domains—barnacles, orchids, earthworms, domesticated breeds—and developing answers to anticipated objections. The letter from Alfred Russel Wallace in 1858 announcing an independent discovery of essentially the same theory precipitated Darwin's publication of On the Origin of Species in 1859. Historians debate whether Darwin's delay reflected genuine scientific caution or anxiety about the theory's religious implications. The author includes the detail about Wallace's letter primarily to
  1. Aexplain the immediate external cause that ended Darwin's long delay and prompted publicationCorrect
  2. Bsuggest that Darwin and Wallace should receive equal credit for the theory of natural selection
  3. Cargue that Darwin had plagiarized Wallace's ideas and published before Wallace could establish priority
  4. Ddemonstrate that independent discovery is common in the history of science when multiple researchers study the same phenomena

Why A is right

The Wallace letter is the event that 'precipitated' Darwin's publication—it is the immediate cause that ended his twenty-year delay. The detail explains why Darwin published when he did.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because the text does not advocate for equal credit; the Wallace letter is mentioned as a historical cause, not a credit argument.
C
Incorrect because no plagiarism claim is made; Darwin's delay preceded the letter, and the text is neutral about their relationship.
D
Incorrect because independent discovery as a general pattern is not the focus; the detail serves to explain Darwin's specific publication decision.
Example 2Harder
The following text is original practice text. The evolution of eusociality—a social system characterized by cooperative brood care, reproductive division of labor, and overlapping generations—has evolved independently multiple times among insects, including in ants, bees, wasps, and termites. Evolutionary biologists have long puzzled over why worker insects, which often do not reproduce themselves, would evolve to sacrifice personal reproductive success to support the queen. William Hamilton's theory of inclusive fitness proposes an explanation: workers share a significant proportion of their genes with siblings they help raise, meaning that by assisting the queen, workers indirectly pass on copies of their own genes. This concept, often summarized as kin selection, reframes altruistic behavior as a form of genetic self-interest. Which finding, if true, would most directly challenge Hamilton's kin selection theory as applied to eusocial insects?
  1. ASome eusocial wasp species show high worker relatedness to the queen's offspring but also have workers that regularly attempt to lay unfertilized eggs.Correct
  2. BThe evolution of eusociality has been documented in multiple mammalian species, including naked mole rats, which live in underground colonies with a single breeding female.
  3. CWorker honey bees and their sisters share approximately 75% of their genes due to the haplodiploidy of the bee reproductive system.
  4. DEusocial insect species with the highest queen reproductive rates also tend to have the largest worker populations.

Why A is right

Kin selection predicts that workers forgo reproduction because helping raise relatives (who share their genes) serves their genetic interests. If workers are highly related to siblings but still try to reproduce themselves, this suggests genetic relatedness alone does not predict altruistic behavior—challenging the theory.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because eusociality in mammals expands the range of the phenomenon but does not specifically challenge Hamilton's kin selection explanation for insect eusociality.
C
Incorrect because high genetic relatedness between workers and siblings (75%) would actually support kin selection theory, not challenge it.
D
Incorrect because a correlation between queen reproductive rates and worker population size is consistent with kin selection and does not challenge it.
Example 3Harder
The following text is original practice text. Flowering plants, or angiosperms, appeared relatively late in the fossil record—about 140 million years ago—but diversified explosively to become the dominant plant group on Earth, comprising roughly 90% of all plant species today. Charles Darwin famously called this rapid diversification an 'abominable mystery.' Modern research has proposed a compelling answer: the coevolution of angiosperms with insect pollinators. As flowers evolved structural features that attracted specific insects, and insects evolved sensory and behavioral traits suited to exploiting flowers, both groups diversified in tandem—a process called mutualistic coevolution. This feedback loop may account for both the speed and the diversity of angiosperm radiation. Which finding, if true, would most directly support the mutualistic coevolution hypothesis for angiosperm radiation?
  1. AAngiosperm species that reproduce through self-pollination rather than insect pollination show higher genetic diversity than those dependent on insect pollinators.
  2. BThe geographic distribution of modern angiosperms closely correlates with the distribution of warm, humid climates, suggesting that climate drove angiosperm diversification.
  3. CThe earliest angiosperm fossils show structural features adapted for wind pollination rather than insect attraction, suggesting the first flowers did not rely on insect pollinators.
  4. DThe fossil record shows that diversification of insect pollinator groups closely paralleled in timing the diversification of flowering plant families during the Cretaceous period.Correct

Why D is right

The mutualistic coevolution hypothesis predicts that angiosperms and their insect pollinators diversified together. Finding that pollinator diversification paralleled angiosperm diversification in the fossil record directly supports the claim that the two groups drove each other's radiation.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because self-pollinating species having higher diversity would suggest that insect pollination may not be necessary for diversification, weakening rather than supporting the coevolution hypothesis.
B
Incorrect because a correlation between angiosperms and warm climates would suggest climate, not coevolution with pollinators, drove diversification—this challenges the hypothesis.
C
Incorrect because early wind-pollinated ancestors would suggest insects were not the original driver—this challenges rather than supports the hypothesis.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Information and Ideas.