Skip to content
SAT · Craft and Structure

Ethics

Ethics appears in 3 reviewed SAT questions and sits in Craft and Structure. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Ethics is tested

Example 1Harder
Text 1 is original practice text. Text 1 Genetic editing technologies like CRISPR-Cas9 offer the possibility of eliminating heritable diseases before birth. If used in embryos, germline editing could prevent not only the individual from suffering a genetic disease but all future descendants. The ethical argument for germline editing in disease prevention is therefore potentially very strong: one intervention prevents enormous cumulative suffering. Text 2 The consequentialist calculus that makes germline editing appear beneficial overlooks the moral status of the future people whose genetic code would be altered without consent. Unlike somatic gene therapy, which affects only the treated individual, germline editing imposes permanent genetic changes on an unlimited number of individuals who have no voice in the decision. The inability to consent is not a technical obstacle to be overcome but a fundamental moral barrier. Based on the texts, how would the author of Text 2 most likely respond to the Text 1 author's argument that preventing suffering across future generations is a strong justification for germline editing?
  1. ABy suggesting that somatic gene therapy can achieve the same benefits as germline editing without ethical complications
  2. BBy contending that the consequentialist calculus fails because it ignores the rights of unconsenting future individualsCorrect
  3. CBy agreeing that preventing suffering is a valid goal but arguing that social supports are a better tool than genetic editing
  4. DBy arguing that the suffering prevented by germline editing is too uncertain to weigh against its known costs

Why B is right

The author of Text 2 explicitly argues that the 'consequentialist calculus' (maximizing welfare reduction across generations) fails because it ignores the moral status and consent of future people. The inability to consent is the Text 2 author's core objection.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the author of Text 2 mentions somatic therapy only to distinguish it, not to argue it achieves the same benefits.
C
Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not propose social supports as an alternative; the argument is a principled objection to germline editing, not a policy substitution.
D
Incorrect because the author of Text 2 does not challenge the uncertainty of benefits; the objection is principled, not empirical.
Example 2Medium
The following text is original practice text. Utilitarianism holds that the morally right action is the one that produces the greatest good for the greatest number. The theory's appeal lies in its democratic impartiality: everyone's welfare counts equally. Critics have long pointed to the theory's willingness to endorse intuitively monstrous acts when they produce net utility—torturing one innocent person to prevent minor inconveniences for millions, for example. Defenders respond that a sophisticated utilitarian calculus, one that accounts for rule-following, preference satisfaction, and long-term social stability, would not in fact endorse such acts. Which choice best describes the overall structure of the text?
  1. AThe historical origins of utilitarianism are traced, and its reception by academic philosophers is assessed.
  2. BUtilitarianism is defined, a criticism of it is presented, and a utilitarian response to that criticism is offered.Correct
  3. CA moral dilemma is described, and utilitarianism is shown to provide the only satisfying resolution.
  4. DThree distinct versions of utilitarianism are described, and the most defensible is identified by the author.

Why B is right

The text defines utilitarianism, presents the 'monstrous acts' criticism, and then presents defenders' sophisticated response. This is definition, criticism, defense—matching B. This choice preserves the passage's meaning, tone, and rhetorical logic.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because no historical origins or reception history is presented; the text is purely philosophical argument.
C
Incorrect because the dilemma (torturing one for many) is used to criticize utilitarianism, not show it provides a satisfying resolution.
D
Incorrect because no three versions are described and compared; the text discusses one general form of utilitarianism and its defense.
Example 3Harder
The following text is original practice text. In the 1970s, philosopher Peter Singer applied utilitarian ethics to argue that the capacity for suffering—not species membership or intelligence—should determine which beings receive moral consideration. Singer argued that because non-human animals clearly experience pain and distress, causing them unnecessary suffering is morally indefensible regardless of their cognitive complexity. This 'sentience-based' view of moral consideration challenged the traditional view that humans' unique rational capacities justified treating animals as means rather than ends. Critics argued that cognitive complexity does matter morally—that there is a meaningful difference between the suffering of a human who anticipates death and the suffering of a chicken who does not. Which finding, if true, would most directly support Singer's argument that animal suffering warrants moral consideration?
  1. AA majority of people surveyed in multiple countries report feeling moral discomfort when watching videos of factory farming practices, suggesting widespread intuitive support for animal welfare.
  2. BNeurological research has shown that the pain-processing regions of fish brains are structurally analogous to those in mammals, and fish demonstrate behavioral and physiological responses to noxious stimuli consistent with pain experience.Correct
  3. CUtilitarian philosophers have developed mathematical models for calculating the total suffering produced by factory farming that, when applied, consistently show that the practice produces net negative utility.
  4. DLegal systems in several European countries have begun to recognize animals as 'sentient beings' with legal protections, demonstrating growing institutional acceptance of Singer's position.

Why B is right

Singer's argument rests on the claim that non-human animals can suffer. Finding that fish have pain-processing brain structures analogous to mammals and show behavioral/physiological responses consistent with pain directly supports the empirical premise that fish (and by extension other animals) genuinely experience suffering—Singer's key criterion for moral consideration.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because popular moral intuitions are sociologically interesting but do not constitute scientific evidence that animals are capable of suffering.
C
Incorrect because utilitarian mathematical models supporting Singer's conclusions are theoretical applications of his framework, not independent evidence for the empirical claim that animals suffer.
D
Incorrect because legal recognition reflects changing social norms but doesn't provide evidence for the biological capacity for suffering that Singer's argument requires.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Craft and Structure.