Skip to content
SAT · Craft and Structure

Decision making

Decision making appears in 3 reviewed SAT questions and sits in Craft and Structure. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

How Decision making is tested

Example 1Medium
The following text is original practice text. Researchers studying decision fatigue have found that judges render harsher sentences, doctors order fewer tests, and loan officers approve fewer applications as the day progresses. The mechanism appears to be cognitive depletion: making decisions consumes mental resources, and as those resources diminish, individuals default to conservative or punitive choices that require less deliberation. The implications extend well beyond individual wellbeing to questions of institutional fairness. As used in the text, what does "conservative" most nearly mean?
  1. ACautious and tending toward the status quo or denialCorrect
  2. BEnvironmentally mindful and focused on preservation
  3. CPolitically right-leaning and resistant to progressive change
  4. DFrugal with financial resources and opposed to excess

Why A is right

In context, 'conservative' describes choices made when mental resources are depleted—defaulting to denials (fewer tests, fewer approvals) rather than deliberating. This fits the meaning of cautious or status-quo-preserving.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because environmental conservation is entirely unrelated to the context of the passage.
C
Incorrect because the text is about cognitive psychology, not political ideology; the word has no partisan meaning here.
D
Incorrect because the passage is about decision-making, not financial frugality.
Example 2Medium
The following text is original practice text. Dual-process theory, most associated with the work of Daniel Kahneman, proposes that human thinking operates through two distinct systems. System 1 is fast, automatic, effortless, and intuitive—it operates largely below conscious awareness and generates rapid judgments based on pattern recognition and heuristics. System 2 is slow, deliberate, effortful, and analytical—it engages when tasks require conscious attention, logical reasoning, or the consideration of new information. The two systems interact continuously: System 1 generates intuitive responses that System 2 can either accept, ignore, or modify through deliberate analysis. Because System 2 requires cognitive effort and is easily depleted by fatigue or cognitive load, many decisions that people believe are rational deliberations are actually System 1 intuitions that System 2 has rationalized post-hoc. The text indicates that people often fail to reason as deliberately as they believe they are because
  1. ASystem 2 requires cognitive effort and can be depleted, causing many apparent deliberations to actually be rationalizations of intuitive System 1 judgments.Correct
  2. BSystem 1 was evolutionarily selected for accuracy in modern decision-making environments, making its intuitive outputs more reliable than slow deliberative reasoning.
  3. CSystem 1 processing is entirely unconscious and never subject to revision by conscious deliberation, making it impossible for humans to reflect on their own thinking.
  4. DThe interaction between System 1 and System 2 creates a feedback loop that progressively degrades the quality of deliberate reasoning over multiple decisions in the same domain.

Why A is right

The text states that because 'System 2 requires cognitive effort and is easily depleted,' 'many decisions that people believe are rational deliberations are actually System 1 intuitions that System 2 has rationalized post-hoc.' Choice A accurately restates this mechanism: depletion of effortful System 2 leaves intuitive System 1 judgments to be rationalized after the fact.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because the text does not make a claim about System 1 being evolutionarily optimized for accuracy in modern environments or compare its reliability to deliberative reasoning.
C
Incorrect because the text says System 2 'can either accept, ignore, or modify' System 1's responses—System 1 outputs are explicitly subject to System 2 revision.
D
Incorrect because the text does not describe a feedback loop degrading reasoning over multiple decisions; it describes the general depletion of System 2 capacity.
Example 3Medium
While researching the psychology of decision-making, a student has taken the following notes: • Daniel Kahneman, a Nobel Prize-winning psychologist, proposed that human thinking operates through two systems: System 1 (fast, intuitive, automatic) and System 2 (slow, deliberate, effortful). • System 1 thinking is highly efficient but prone to cognitive biases and heuristic errors. • The availability heuristic is a System 1 bias in which people overestimate the likelihood of events that come to mind easily, such as plane crashes. • The anchoring bias causes people to rely too heavily on the first piece of information they encounter when making a decision. • Organizations such as hospitals and airlines have used structured checklists and protocols to counteract System 1 errors and reduce accidents. The student wants to explain what System 1 thinking is and identify one specific cognitive bias it produces. Which choice most effectively uses relevant information from the notes to accomplish this goal?
  1. ADaniel Kahneman's dual-process theory proposes that human cognition operates through System 1, which is fast and intuitive, and System 2, which is slow and deliberate, with each system playing a distinct role in decision-making.
  2. BAnchoring bias, a well-documented cognitive error, causes people to rely too heavily on the first piece of information they receive, leading to skewed judgments even in professional and high-stakes contexts.
  3. CCognitive biases that arise from System 1 thinking can have serious real-world consequences, which is why hospitals and airlines have implemented structured checklists to reduce System 1 errors.
  4. DSystem 1 thinking—fast, automatic, and intuitive—is efficient but prone to biases such as the availability heuristic, in which people overestimate the likelihood of events that come readily to mind.Correct

Why D is right

Choice D both explains what System 1 thinking is (fast, automatic, intuitive, and efficient) and identifies one specific cognitive bias it produces (the availability heuristic), defining it as the tendency to overestimate the likelihood of events that come readily to mind. This directly accomplishes the student's goal.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because this choice describes both systems but does not identify any specific cognitive bias that System 1 produces.
B
Incorrect because this choice describes the anchoring bias but does not explain what System 1 thinking is or clearly connect the bias to System 1.
C
Incorrect because this choice discusses the real-world consequences and organizational responses to System 1 biases but does not define System 1 thinking or identify a specific bias.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Craft and Structure.