Skip to content

Unit 7 of 8

Problem Solving and Data Analysis

9% of the exam159 reviewed questions31 key terms16 min read

Problem Solving and Data Analysis is worth about 9% of the PSAT/NMSQT exam. Our bank tests it with 159 reviewed questions across 31 distinct ideas — 94 easier, 60 medium and 5 harder.

On this page · 11 sections

Every question in this unit hands you numbers from a real situation and asks you to compare them correctly. You might get a recipe, a survey result, a list of test scores, a frequency table, or a scatter plot, and then you find a rate, a percent, an average, a probability, or a prediction. The algebra is light, so what the test really measures is whether you set up the right comparison with the right total and the right group.

On the PSAT/NMSQT this domain is about one in five math questions, roughly 8 to 10 of the 44 questions across the two math modules. In our question bank, 94 of the 159 items in this unit are rated easy and only 5 are rated hard, so most of what you will practice here is one-step work. On test day the harder questions stack two steps, such as a percent of a percent or a new mean after some scores are removed.

One idea ties the unit together: almost every answer is a part compared to a whole. A ratio compares two parts, and a percent compares a part to 100. A mean is a total shared out equally, and a probability is favorable outcomes over all possible outcomes. If you can name the whole before you divide, most of this unit becomes routine.

The unit in a minute

One line per topic. Tap any line for the full notes.

  1. Ratios, unit rates, and proportionsFind the unit rate or set up a proportion, keep the units attached, and never round the multiplier.
  2. Percentages and percent changeMultiply by the decimal, check which group is asked for, and always measure percent change against the original.
  3. Mean, median, mode, and rangeSort before finding a median, read frequencies as counts not values, and turn every mean into a total.
  4. Outliers, spread, and standard deviationOutliers move the mean and range a lot and the median very little; compare standard deviations by how bunched the data is.
  5. Probability, counting, and two-way tablesTotal first, then match the numerator to the question; 'given' shrinks the denominator, and independent events multiply.
  6. Scatter plots, lines of best fit, and linear modelsSlope is the average rate of change, the intercept is the starting value, and every prediction comes from substituting into the line.
  7. Sampling and experimental designRandom sampling earns generalization to the sampled population; random assignment earns cause and effect.
Grind Problem Solving and Data Analysis questionsAlready know this? Skip the notes and prove it.

The big ideas

Name the whole before you divide

Percents, probabilities, and conditional questions all depend on the denominator. 'Of those in the band' means the band is the whole, not the school, and 'given that the student is a junior' means only juniors count. Most wrong answers in this unit come from dividing by the wrong total, so circle the group the question names and make that your denominator.

Averages travel through totals

You cannot add or subtract means directly, but you can always add or subtract totals. Mean times count gives the total, so convert every mean into a total, do the adding or removing, and divide by the new count. This one habit handles removed scores, combined classes, and questions that ask what the last score must be.

Center and spread answer different questions

Mean and median describe where the data sits, while range and standard deviation describe how spread out it is. An outlier drags the mean and stretches the range, but it barely moves the median. When a question changes the data, decide which kind of statistic it is asking about and where the changed value sits relative to the rest.

A model is a trend, not a promise

A line of best fit turns scattered points into a rate and a starting value. Its slope tells you the average change in y for each unit of x, and it gives predictions, not exact values. Predictions are safest inside the range of the data, because the trend may not hold far outside it.

A study only reaches as far as its design

Random sampling lets you generalize from the sample to the population it came from, and no further. Random assignment to treatment groups lets you claim cause and effect. Without random assignment, you can only say two variables are associated, however strong the pattern looks.

Study notes

7 topics. Each one opens with its key idea, then the detail you need to use it.

1. Ratios, unit rates, and proportions

Key idea: Find the unit rate or set up a proportion, keep the units attached, and never round the multiplier.

A ratio compares two quantities, like 3 cups of flour to 2 cups of milk. A rate is a ratio with different units, like 240 miles per 4 hours, and the unit rate scales it down to one of the second unit: 240 ÷ 4 = 60 miles per hour. Once you have a unit rate, any other amount is one multiplication away, so 7 hours at that speed gives 420 miles.

A proportion sets two ratios equal. If 4 notebooks cost $10, then 4/10 = 14/x for 14 notebooks, and cross-multiplying gives 4x = 140, so x = 35 dollars. The unit-rate route gives the same answer, since $2.50 per notebook times 14 is $35, so use whichever route fits the numbers.

Fractions show up inside rates. If a recipe needs 3/4 cup of oil per batch and you make 2.5 batches, multiply (3/4) × (5/2) = 15/8, which is 1 7/8 cups. Rewrite the decimal as a fraction first so the arithmetic stays exact. Do not round 2.5 batches to 2 or 3, because that gives the oil for a different number of batches.

Unit conversions use the same idea. Multiply by a conversion factor arranged so the unit you want to cancel sits on the bottom, so 3 ft × 12 in/ft = 36 in. For two steps, chain the factors. A price of $4.80 per pound is 480 cents per pound, and since a pound is 16 ounces, 480 ÷ 16 = 30 cents per ounce.

Two checks catch most errors. Track units, so miles per hour times hours leaves miles, and then check direction, because more batches must need more oil. Also watch part-to-part versus part-to-whole. If the ratio of boys to girls is 2:3, the boys are 2/5 of the class, not 2/3.

2. Percentages and percent change

Key idea: Multiply by the decimal, check which group is asked for, and always measure percent change against the original.

Percent means per hundred, so 35% is 0.35. To find a percent of a total, convert it to a decimal and multiply: 35% of 260 is 0.35 × 260 = 91. For a mental check, find 10% first, which is 26, so 35% is 3.5 × 26 = 91.

Read which group the question wants. If 35% of 260 people own a bike, then 91 do and 169 do not, and test writers put both numbers in the choices. They also offer the bare percent, 35, which is what you get if you forget to apply it to the total.

Percent change compares the change to the starting value: (new − old) ÷ old × 100. A price that rises from $40 to $50 went up 10 ÷ 40 = 25%, but going back down from $50 to $40 is a 10 ÷ 50 = 20% drop. The base is always the starting value, which is why the two percents differ.

Chained percents multiply. A 20% increase multiplies by 1.20 and a 20% decrease multiplies by 0.80, so raising $100 by 20% and then cutting it by 20% leaves $96, not $100. For a percent of a percent, work in steps. If 70% of 500 students play a sport and 40% of those athletes play soccer, first find 0.70 × 500 = 350, then 0.40 × 350 = 140. The second percent applies to the 350 athletes, not to all 500 students.

3. Mean, median, mode, and range

Key idea: Sort before finding a median, read frequencies as counts not values, and turn every mean into a total.

These four descriptive statistics each summarize a data set with one number. The mean is the total divided by the count, and the median is the middle value once the data is in order. The mode is the value that appears most often, and the range is the largest value minus the smallest.

For the median, sort first, then count positions. With an odd number of values n, the median is value number (n + 1)/2, so with 9 values it is the 5th. With an even count, average the two middle values, so for 3, 5, 8, 10, 12, 15 the median is (8 + 10)/2 = 9.

Frequency tables pack data tighter. Say 4 students own 0 pets, 9 own 1, 5 own 2, and 2 own 3. The mode is 1 pet, because that value has the highest frequency. It is not 9, which is only how many students gave that answer. There are 20 students, so the median is the average of the 10th and 11th values, and since values 5 through 13 are all 1s, the median is 1. The mean is (0 + 9 + 10 + 6) ÷ 20 = 1.25.

The most tested move is the mean through totals. If 20 runners average 30 minutes, their total is 600. If 4 runners who each took 40 minutes drop out, the total falls by 160 to 440, and the new mean is 440 ÷ 16 = 27.5. Divide by the new count, not the old one.

4. Outliers, spread, and standard deviation

Key idea: Outliers move the mean and range a lot and the median very little; compare standard deviations by how bunched the data is.

An outlier is a value far from the rest of the data, and it pulls on some statistics much harder than others. The mean uses the size of every value, so one huge value drags it. The range uses only the two extremes, so an outlier changes it directly, while the median depends only on position and barely moves.

Take five salaries: $40k, $42k, $45k, $47k, and $50k. The mean is $44.8k and the median is $45k. Now replace $50k with $250k. The median stays at $45k, but the mean jumps to $84.8k and the range grows from $10k to $210k. That is why the median is the better summary of a typical salary when a few values are extreme.

Standard deviation measures how far values typically sit from the mean. The PSAT rarely asks you to calculate it, but it does ask you to compare it. Data bunched near the mean has a small standard deviation, and data pushed toward the ends has a large one. The sets 10, 10, 10, 10 and 1, 5, 15, 19 both have a mean of 10, but the first has a standard deviation of 0 while the second is far more spread out.

When a value is added or removed, ask where it sits. Removing a value above the mean lowers the mean, and removing a value equal to the mean leaves it unchanged. Removing the most extreme value never increases the range. It shrinks the range unless another value ties it, and it usually lowers the standard deviation.

5. Probability, counting, and two-way tables

Key idea: Total first, then match the numerator to the question; 'given' shrinks the denominator, and independent events multiply.

Probability is favorable outcomes divided by total outcomes, when every outcome is equally likely. A jar with 5 lemon, 3 cherry, and 4 grape candies holds 12 candies, so P(cherry) = 3/12 = 1/4. Add up the total first. Wrong choices often give the probability of a different flavor, so check that your numerator matches the one the question names.

Counting matters when conditions stack. A spinner numbered 1 through 10 has 10 outcomes, and 'odd and greater than 5' means only 7 and 9, so the probability is 2/10 = 1/5. When the set is small, list the outcomes, because a list is faster than a formula and harder to get wrong.

A two-way table sorts one group by two categories. Picture 120 students sorted by grade and by whether they drive to school. Suppose 50 are juniors and 20 of those juniors drive. P(drives, given junior) = 20/50 = 2/5, because 'given' shrinks the whole to the junior row. P(junior and drives) = 20/120 = 1/6, because 'and' keeps the whole table as the denominator. The phrases 'given that', 'of those', and 'among' all signal a smaller whole.

Independent events do not affect each other, so you multiply their probabilities. Roll a die twice, and P(even both times) = (3/6) × (3/6) = 1/4. Drawing without replacement is not independent, because the first draw changes what is left. Two red cards from 4 red and 6 black gives (4/10) × (3/9) = 2/15.

6. Scatter plots, lines of best fit, and linear models

Key idea: Slope is the average rate of change, the intercept is the starting value, and every prediction comes from substituting into the line.

A scatter plot shows paired data, with one point for each person or object. The line of best fit is the straight line that runs closest to the points overall. Its slope is a rate, the average change in y for each one-unit increase in x. Its y-intercept is the predicted y when x is 0, which may or may not make sense in context.

Say a line of best fit for plant height is h = 1.5d + 4, where d is days and h is centimeters. The slope says the plants grow about 1.5 cm per day, and the intercept says a plant is predicted to be 4 cm tall on day 0. To predict, substitute: at d = 10, h = 19 cm. Stems use words like 'predicted', 'estimated', and 'on average' because the points scatter around the line rather than sitting on it.

When the data is a clean table, build the linear model yourself. If x goes 1, 3, 5, 7 and y goes 20, 26, 32, 38, then y rises 6 for every 2 units of x, so the slope is 3. Step back one unit from (1, 20) to get the intercept 17, which gives y = 3x + 17, and at x = 4 the model predicts y = 29.

A residual is the actual value minus the predicted value. A point above the line has a positive residual, which means the model underestimated it. Be cautious about predictions far beyond the plotted data, because the trend may not continue there.

7. Sampling and experimental design

Key idea: Random sampling earns generalization to the sampled population; random assignment earns cause and effect.

These questions ask what a study lets you conclude, and two features decide it. Random sampling lets you generalize from the sample to the population it was drawn from. Random assignment to treatment groups lets you conclude cause and effect.

A survey of 300 randomly chosen students at one high school supports claims about that school's students. It does not support claims about every teenager in the state, because they were never in the pool. A survey answered only by people who chose to respond online is biased, because volunteers tend to feel more strongly than everyone else.

A sample estimate often comes with a margin of error. If 62% of a random sample prefers a later start time, with a margin of error of 4 percentage points, the plausible range for the whole school is 58% to 66%. A larger random sample shrinks the margin of error, but it cannot fix a biased sampling method.

In an experiment, the researcher assigns the treatment at random. If 80 volunteers are randomly split into a group that uses a study app and a group that does not, a difference in scores can be credited to the app. If students chose for themselves, the study is observational. Motivated students might be the ones who pick the app, so you can only say app use and scores are associated.

To scale up a sample result, use a proportion. If 18 of 60 sampled apples are bruised, that is 30%, so about 600 of a 2,000-apple shipment would be expected to be bruised.

Common mistakes

Drawn from the wrong answers students actually pick on these questions.

Leaving the mean unchanged, or raising it, after high scores are removed.

If the removed values sit above the old mean, the new mean must be lower. Rebuild it from totals: mean times count gives the old total, then subtract the removed values and divide by the new, smaller count.

Rounding an exact answer to the nearest whole number.

A mean of 68.4 is not 68, and test writers put the rounded value in the choices on purpose. Keep the decimal unless the question tells you to round, and enter it in full on a student-produced response.

Answering with the wrong group in a percent question.

If 45% of 200 students like a show, 90 like it and 110 do not, and both numbers appear as choices along with the bare 45. Reread what the question counts before you pick, and remember the percent must be applied to the total.

Putting the wrong category in the numerator of a probability.

Distractors are often the probability of a different color or category from the same problem. After you add up the total, find the count for exactly the outcome the question names, then simplify.

Taking a value next to the middle as the median, or skipping the sort.

Sort the data, then count positions. With 7 values the median is the 4th value, not the 5th or 6th, and with an even count you average the two middle values.

Rounding the multiplier, or using the wrong unit rate, in a scaling problem.

If a serving needs 2/3 cup and you make 4.5 servings, multiply by 4.5 exactly, which gives 3 cups. Using 3 or 6 servings gives the amount for the wrong batch. Find the unit rate carefully too, since $1.20 for 3 items means $0.40 each, not $0.30.

How this unit shows up on the exam

The digital PSAT/NMSQT gives you two math modules of 22 questions each, with 35 minutes per module, and the second module adapts to how you did on the first. Problem Solving and Data Analysis questions are mixed in with algebra and geometry rather than grouped together. Every question has four choices except the student-produced responses, which make up about a quarter of the math section, so expect a few of this unit's questions to require typing your own number. A calculator is allowed on every math question, and the built-in Desmos tool handles messy percent and mean arithmetic quickly.

The stems are short and concrete. Typical setups are a class's quiz scores, a bag of marbles, a recipe, a survey result, a table of study hours and test scores, or a scatter plot with a line of best fit. The question then asks for one number, such as a new mean, a probability, a cost, or a predicted value, or it asks which conclusion a study supports. Frequency tables and two-way tables appear often, and the trap is usually reading the wrong row or treating a count as a value.

The wrong choices are built from predictable slips: the rounded answer, the complement, the bare percent, the value next to the median, and the probability of the wrong color. The exam rewards exact arithmetic and careful reading of the denominator. On a student-produced response, a fraction such as 9/25 and its decimal form 0.36 are both accepted, so you rarely need to convert.

How the exam actually asks it

Real items from the PSAT/NMSQT bank, easier first. The answer is marked, and every wrong choice is explained — because knowing why a distractor is tempting is most of the work.

Worked example 1Easier
A bag contains 4 red marbles, 6 blue marbles, and 2 green marbles. If one marble is chosen at random, what is the probability that it is blue?
  1. A2/3
  2. B1/6
  3. C1/2Correct
  4. D1/3

Why C is right

Total marbles: 4 + 6 + 2 = 12. Probability of blue = 6/12 = 1/2. The data or units point to this result when the values are interpreted correctly.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because 2/3 = 8/12; this likely comes from subtracting red from total or another arithmetic error.
B
Incorrect because 1/6 would be the probability of green (2/12 = 1/6), not blue.
D
Incorrect because 1/3 = 4/12, which matches the probability of red, not blue.
Worked example 2Easier
A survey of 200 students found that 45% prefer math over English. How many students prefer math?
  1. A90Correct
  2. B80
  3. C110
  4. D45

Why A is right

To find a percent of a total, change the percent to a decimal and multiply it by the total. Here, 45% = 0.45, and 0.45 × 200 = 90, so 90 of the 200 students prefer math. As a check, 10% of 200 is 20, so 45% is 4.5 × 20 = 90.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
80 is 40% of 200 (0.40 × 200), so this choice uses the wrong percent instead of 45%.
C
110 is 55% of 200, which is the number of students who do NOT prefer math (200 − 90), not the number who do.
D
45 is the percent itself, not the number of students; it ignores that the percent has to be applied to the total of 200.
Worked example 3Easier
The following data set shows the scores of 7 students: 62, 75, 80, 80, 85, 90, 95. What is the median score?
  1. A80Correct
  2. B90
  3. C75
  4. D85

Why A is right

The data is already in order. With 7 values, the median is the 4th value: 80. The data or units point to this result when the values are interpreted correctly.
Why the other 3 choices miss
B
Incorrect because 90 is the 6th value, not the median.
C
Incorrect because 75 is the 2nd value, not the middle one.
D
Incorrect because 85 is the 5th value; the median of 7 values is the 4th, which is 80.
Worked example 4Easier
A store sells apples at a ratio of 3 apples for $1.20. At this rate, how much would 15 apples cost?
  1. A$6.50
  2. B$4.50
  3. C$5.00
  4. D$6.00Correct

Why D is right

Cost per apple = $1.20 / 3 = $0.40. Cost for 15 apples = 15 × $0.40 = $6.00. The data or units point to this result when the values are interpreted correctly.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because $6.50 adds extra; the correct multiplication gives exactly $6.00.
B
Incorrect because $4.50 = 15 × $0.30, using $0.30 per apple instead of $0.40.
C
Incorrect because $5.00 assumes some other unit rate, not the given ratio.

Can you do all of these?

Tick what you can do without looking. Anything left unticked is where to go back to.

0 of 10 ticked

Ready to test yourself?

Open practice pulls from all 159 questions in this unit. No account, no card — you get the reasoning the moment you answer.

Key terms in Problem Solving and Data Analysis

Ordered by how often our reviewed questions test them. Open any term to see the questions that use it.

The rest of PSAT/NMSQT

Every unit with its share of the exam. You are on Unit 7.

  1. 1Craft and Structure14% of exam
  2. 2Information and Ideas14% of exam
  3. 3Expression of Ideas13.5% of exam
  4. 4Standard English Conventions13.5% of exam
  5. 5Algebra13.5% of exam
  6. 6Advanced Math13.5% of exam
  7. 7Problem Solving and Data Analysis9% of exam
  8. 8Geometry and Trigonometry9% of exam