"The establishment of the Weimar Republic in Germany after World War I represented an experiment in liberal democracy in a country with limited democratic traditions. The Weimar Constitution included progressive provisions such as universal suffrage, proportional representation, and extensive civil liberties. However, the republic was burdened from the start by the stigma of the Versailles Treaty, hyperinflation in 1923, and the Great Depression after 1929. Political extremists on both the left (communists) and right (Nazis) exploited these crises, and the republic collapsed when Hitler was appointed chancellor in 1933." -- Political historian's summary.
The collapse of the Weimar Republic, as described in the passage, best supports which of the following arguments?
- ADemocratic institutions can be undermined by a combination of economic crisis, national humiliation, and political extremismCorrect
- BLiberal democratic constitutions, once enacted with progressive provisions, reliably guarantee the long-term survival of democratic governance regardless of external pressures
- CEconomic prosperity inevitably strengthens democratic institutions and, on its own, reliably prevents the rise of authoritarian movements during periods of crisis
- DThe collapse of the Weimar Republic resulted solely from the inadequacy of its constitutional provisions rather than from any broader economic or political pressures
Why A is right
The passage describes a progressive democratic constitution undermined by economic crises (hyperinflation, the Depression), national humiliation (Versailles Treaty stigma), and exploitation by political extremists. This supports the argument that democratic institutions, even when constitutionally well-designed, can be undermined by the combination of these destabilizing factors.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the Weimar example demonstrates the opposite: a progressive constitution with universal suffrage and civil liberties could not prevent democratic collapse when confronted with economic crisis, national humiliation, and political extremism.
- C
- Incorrect because the passage describes economic crises (hyperinflation, the Great Depression) as contributing to the republic's collapse, indicating that prosperity alone does not guarantee a barrier against authoritarianism.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage attributes the collapse primarily to external factors (economic crises, treaty stigma, political extremism) rather than to constitutional inadequacy alone.