"The Mexican Revolution, which began in 1910, was driven by widespread resentment of the Porfirio Diaz regime's policies that concentrated land ownership in the hands of a small elite while dispossessing peasant communities of their traditional communal holdings. Emiliano Zapata's Plan de Ayala demanded the restoration of ejido lands to indigenous villages, while Pancho Villa mobilized landless workers and cowboys in the north. The 1917 Constitution, one of the revolution's most significant products, established labor rights, land reform provisions, and limits on foreign ownership of Mexican resources." -- Modern Latin American historian's account.
The demands described in the Plan de Ayala most directly reflected which of the following grievances?
- AThe demand of Mexican military officers for higher salaries, professional advancement, and improved conditions of service
- BThe opposition of the Catholic Church to the spread of secular, state-controlled education in public schools
- CThe desire of Mexican industrialists to attract greater foreign investment into domestic manufacturing enterprises
- DThe dispossession of rural communities of their ancestral communal lands under liberal modernization policiesCorrect
Why D is right
The passage describes Zapata's Plan de Ayala demanding restoration of ejido (communal) lands to indigenous villages, directly addressing the dispossession of rural communities. Under Diaz's liberal modernization policies, communal lands had been privatized and consolidated into large estates, leaving peasant communities landless -- a core grievance driving Zapata's movement.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Zapata's movement rested on agrarian peasant demands for the return of communal land, not on the professional or pay concerns of military officers.
- B
- Incorrect because, although Church-state tensions existed in revolutionary Mexico, the Plan de Ayala specifically addressed land distribution rather than religious or educational disputes.
- C
- Incorrect because Zapata represented rural peasants seeking land reform, not industrialists seeking foreign investment; the 1917 Constitution in fact limited foreign ownership of resources.