"Hong Kong's return to China in 1997 was supposed to be governed by the principle of 'one country, two systems.' For fifty years, Hong Kong would retain its capitalist economy, its independent judiciary, its free press, and its civil liberties while acknowledging Chinese sovereignty. But the people of Hong Kong were never consulted. The agreement was negotiated between Beijing and London, and the six million residents of the territory had no voice in determining their own future. Democracy was promised but never delivered. The handover was a transaction between empires, past and present."
— Hong Kong political commentator, 2003
The situation described in this passage most directly reflects which of the following tensions in the post-Cold War world?
- AThe economic rivalry between capitalist and communist systems competing for dominance in the integrated global marketplace
- BThe conflict between national sovereignty claims and the democratic self-determination of local populationsCorrect
- CThe decline of British military power and its growing inability to hold colonial possessions through force
- DThe success of international organizations in mediating contested territorial disputes through multilateral diplomacy
Why B is right
The passage highlights the tension between China's sovereignty claim over Hong Kong and the lack of democratic consultation with Hong Kong's population about their political future. This reflects the broader post-Cold War tension between state sovereignty and peoples' right to democratic self-determination.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the 'one country, two systems' framework was designed to avoid direct economic system competition by allowing Hong Kong to retain capitalism; the passage focuses on political rights rather than economic rivalry.
- C
- Incorrect because while Britain's withdrawal from Hong Kong reflected its diminished global position, the passage's central concern is the lack of democratic input from Hong Kong's residents, not British military capability.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage describes a bilateral negotiation between Britain and China that excluded Hong Kong's population, not successful multilateral mediation by international organizations.