Following passage of the Social Security Act in 1935, many Republican critics argued that federal old-age and unemployment insurance would erode individual initiative, foster dependency on government, discourage private saving, and strain federal finances, claiming that the American tradition of self-reliance was incompatible with an expanded role for government in providing economic security.
Which of the following best explains why these critics expressed this viewpoint?
- AThe Republican Party had drafted a competing social insurance plan with more generous old-age benefits and was publicly pressing Roosevelt to adopt it instead
- BRepublican opposition reflected the party's broader ideological commitment to limited government, private charity, and individual responsibility as alternatives to federal social insuranceCorrect
- CRepublicans were representing elderly Americans, who polls showed unanimously preferred building private savings to enrolling in any government social insurance program
- DRepublicans were raising actuarial concerns that the Social Security trust fund could not pay its promised benefits, a worry later decades of experience confirmed
Why B is right
The Republican critique of Social Security reflects the party's Gilded Age and 1920s ideological legacy of limited government and individual responsibility. Arguments that federal social insurance would destroy initiative, create dependency, and undermine private saving echoed the Social Darwinist and laissez-faire arguments used against earlier Progressive reforms. These concerns proved largely unfounded — Social Security became enormously popular and arguably encouraged rather than discouraged economic activity — but the ideological opposition reflected genuine political philosophy, not merely business-interest calculation.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the Republican Party did not develop a competing social insurance plan; opponents of Social Security generally argued that private charity and individual savings were sufficient, not that government insurance should be more generous.
- C
- Incorrect because elderly Americans overwhelmingly supported Social Security and polls showed strong public approval; the Republican Party's opposition was not responsive to elderly constituents' preferences but to ideological and business-class interests.
- D
- Incorrect because while actuarial concerns are legitimate policy questions, the Republican statement here makes broader ideological arguments about initiative and self-reliance, not actuarial calculations; moreover, Social Security has maintained solvency through multiple decades, so subsequent experience did not confirm the worry.