"The American Anti-Imperialist League, founded 1898: Prominent members included Mark Twain, Andrew Carnegie, Jane Addams, and Samuel Gompers. The League opposed American annexation of the Philippines, arguing that governing a distant people without their consent violated American democratic principles and the Declaration of Independence."
— Modern description of the Anti-Imperialist League
The Anti-Imperialist League's argument most directly challenged which aspect of the case for American imperialism?
- AThe humanitarian argument that American rule would benefit Filipino peoples by ending Spanish misrule, since anti-imperialists believed American rule would be equally exploitative
- BThe economic argument that colonies would provide new markets for American manufactured goods, which anti-imperialists argued was economically incorrect because colonies were expensive to maintain
- CThe military argument that Pacific island possessions would strengthen American naval power, which anti-imperialists argued was strategically unnecessary since the United States had sufficient domestic security
- DThe claim that American democratic values were compatible with governing distant peoples without their consent, which anti-imperialists argued was a fundamental contradiction of American founding principlesCorrect
Why D is right
The Anti-Imperialist League's central argument was a principled one about self-governance and democratic consent: that the Declaration of Independence's principles — that governments derive their just powers from the consent of the governed — were fundamentally incompatible with governing Filipinos as colonial subjects without their agreement. Mark Twain's savage anti-imperialist essays (including 'The War Prayer') made this point most eloquently: America could not be both a democracy at home and an empire abroad without betraying its own founding values. This argument also often carried, unfortunately, a racist undercurrent arguing that non-white peoples were ungovernable and would corrupt American democracy.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while some anti-imperialists did raise humanitarian concerns about American colonial rule, the primary argument identified in the passage — and historically most characteristic of the League — was the democratic principles argument about governing without consent.
- B
- Incorrect because while anti-imperialists did make economic arguments, the primary and most distinctive argument of the Anti-Imperialist League was the democratic-principles argument about consent and self-governance, not primarily an economic one.
- C
- Incorrect because the anti-imperialists' challenge was primarily moral and principled rather than strategic; they were arguing against imperialism as a violation of American values, not primarily making strategic calculations about naval necessity.
"The wilderness masters the colonist. It finds him a European in dress, industries, tools, modes of travel, and thought... It strips off the garment of civilization and arrays him in the hunting shirt and the moccasin... The wilderness has been interpenetrated by lines of civilization... And now, four centuries from the discovery of America, at the end of a hundred years of life under the Constitution, the frontier has gone, and with its going has closed the first period of American history."
— Frederick Jackson Turner, 'The Significance of the Frontier in American History,' 1893
The argument made in this passage most closely reflects which of the following historical developments?
- AThe frontier thesis reflected broad agreement among historians that American democracy was fundamentally superior to European systems
- BTurner's thesis prompted immediate congressional legislation to preserve western wilderness and fund new national parks
- CTurner argued that sustained Native American resistance had permanently shaped the development of American democratic institutions
- DThe closing of the frontier helped redirect American expansionist energy toward overseas imperial ventures in the Pacific and the CaribbeanCorrect
Why D is right
Turner's frontier thesis, delivered at the 1893 Chicago World's Fair, argued that the frontier experience had shaped American democracy and character. With the Census Bureau declaring the frontier closed in 1890, Turner's thesis implied that America needed new frontiers to maintain its democratic vitality. This argument influenced American imperialists like Theodore Roosevelt and Alfred Thayer Mahan who argued for overseas expansion — the Spanish-American War of 1898 and acquisition of Hawaii, Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Philippines followed within a decade.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Turner's thesis was controversial among historians and not universally accepted; later scholars criticized it for ignoring race, class, gender, and the violence of westward expansion, and for its mythologized view of frontier democracy.
- B
- Incorrect because while the conservation movement did develop in this era, Turner's thesis itself focused on the historical significance of the frontier rather than calling for preservation legislation; the national park movement predated Turner's thesis and was driven by different intellectual currents.
- C
- Incorrect because Turner's thesis largely erased Native Americans from his narrative of frontier development, treating the 'wilderness' as empty space that shaped white settlers; the thesis reflected a Eurocentric perspective that minimized indigenous contributions and resistance.