Skip to content
AP U.S. History · Period 1: 1491-1607

Valladolid debate

Valladolid debate appears in 3 reviewed AP U.S. History questions and sits in Period 1: 1491-1607. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

A formal argument held at Valladolid, Spain, in 1550 and 1551 before a royal panel called by Charles V. It asked whether Spain could lawfully conquer Native Americans and force them to work. Juan Gines de Sepulveda called them natural slaves; Bartolome de las Casas called them rational people who could be won only by preaching.

Why it matters

It is the clearest proof that Spanish colonialism was fought over inside Spain rather than settled. The same reform push produced the Laws of Burgos in 1512 and the New Laws in 1542. Limiting Native forced labor also pushed the colonies harder toward enslaved Africans.

How the exam tests it

A Valladolid question asks you to tell the two sides apart. Sepulveda used Aristotle's idea of natural slavery: some people are born to be ruled. Las Casas answered that Native people were rational beings with souls, so war on them could not be just. Las Casas is the likelier stimulus author, since he is the named figure for this fight. One question instead starts earlier, with Antonio de Montesinos's 1511 sermon in Hispaniola. He demanded to know by what right colonists held Native people in servitude. The credited answer there is that such protests fed Spain's long dispute over whether conquest was moral and legal.

Don’t confuse it with

Do not confuse it with the Laws of Burgos or the New Laws, which were real royal legislation. Valladolid was only a debate: it ended without a ruling, and encomienda labor went on afterward.

Valladolid debate in real questions

Example 1Harder
In 1511, a Dominican friar named Antonio de Montesinos delivered a sermon to Spanish colonists in Hispaniola that scandalized his audience: 'I am the voice of Christ crying in the wilderness of this island, and therefore you ought to listen to me with attention, not with indifference, with all your heart and senses. For this voice will be the strangest you ever heard, the harshest and hardest and most terrible... Tell me, by what right do you keep these poor Indians in such cruel and horrible servitude? By what authority do you wage such detestable wars against these people?' Montesinos's sermon most directly contributed to which of the following?
  1. AThe immediate abolition of all indigenous slavery and forced labor throughout the Spanish Caribbean by royal decree.
  2. BThe universal adoption of Las Casas's anti-slavery arguments as official doctrine by the Spanish Catholic Church.
  3. CThe expulsion of all Dominican friars from Spanish colonial territories for challenging royal and imperial authority.
  4. DOngoing Spanish debates over the moral and legal justification for conquest and the treatment of indigenous peoples.Correct

Why D is right

Montesinos's sermon sparked a broader controversy that led to the Laws of Burgos (1512) and contributed to ongoing debates about the legality and morality of conquest, culminating in the Valladolid debate and Las Casas's advocacy—demonstrating that Spanish colonialism was not monolithic but contested from within.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the Laws of Burgos (1512) that followed Montesinos's sermon attempted to regulate rather than abolish indigenous labor; slavery and forced labor continued despite the controversy.
B
Incorrect because while Las Casas was influenced by Montesinos, the Spanish Catholic Church never universally adopted abolitionist arguments; pro-conquest and pro-encomienda positions remained powerful within the Church.
C
Incorrect because while Spanish colonists complained, the Dominicans were not expelled; the sermon led to legal and theological debate rather than suppression of the friars.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Period 1: 1491-1607.