"The Indians are our brothers, and Christ died for them as well as for us. Why, then, do we hold them so bestially and treat them so cruelly and unjustly? How can we hold them in such cruel and horrible servitude? By what right and by what justice do we hold these Indians in such cruel and horrible servitude?"
— Bartolomé de las Casas, A Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies, 1542
The argument made by las Casas most directly challenged which of the following justifications for Spanish colonial practices?
- AThe mercantilist principle that colonies existed solely to enrich the mother country through extraction of precious metals and raw materials
- BThe Treaty of Tordesillas, the papally sanctioned agreement that divided the non-Christian world between the Spanish and Portuguese crowns
- CThe Reconquista tradition that armed conquest of non-Christians was a legitimate expression of Christian duty and royal authorityCorrect
- DThe demographic claim that intensive European settlement was needed to repopulate territories emptied by epidemic disease
Why C is right
Las Casas directly challenged the theological and legal justifications rooted in the Reconquista tradition, which framed the conquest of non-Christians as a holy duty legitimizing coercive control. By asserting the full humanity of indigenous peoples and their equal status as potential Christians, las Casas undermined the theological underpinning of the encomienda system and the doctrine of just war against infidels. His arguments contributed to the New Laws of 1542, which attempted (with limited success) to reform the most brutal aspects of the encomienda system.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because las Casas was making a moral and theological argument about the humanity of indigenous peoples, not a critique of mercantilist economic theory, which was a separate intellectual framework.
- B
- Incorrect because las Casas was not challenging the Treaty of Tordesillas, a diplomatic agreement between European powers; his critique targeted the treatment of indigenous peoples within already-established Spanish colonies.
- D
- Incorrect because the demographic argument about repopulating territories was not a primary justification offered for Spanish colonial practices in this period; the main justifications were religious, legal, and economic.
In 1542, Spain issued the New Laws, which attempted to end the encomienda system by prohibiting new grants of indigenous labor and stipulating that existing encomiendas would revert to the Crown upon the holder's death. Bartolomé de las Casas had lobbied intensively for the New Laws, presenting his treatise 'A Short Account of the Destruction of the Indies' to King Charles I. The New Laws provoked violent resistance from Spanish colonists in Peru, leading to the assassination of the viceroy and the practical suspension of the laws' most controversial provisions.
The fate of the New Laws of 1542 most directly demonstrates which of the following?
- AThe tension between metropolitan Spanish reform efforts and colonial settlers' practical power to resist and effectively nullify imperial regulation.Correct
- BThe Spanish Crown's outright refusal to entertain any reform of the encomienda system, despite Las Casas's sustained advocacy at court.
- CThe Catholic Church's decisive intervention in overriding the political power of Spanish colonial settlers in order to safeguard indigenous peoples from forced labor.
- DThe successful and permanent abolition of the encomienda system throughout Spanish America through the efforts of Las Casas and the Crown.
Why A is right
The New Laws illustrate the ongoing tension between Spanish imperial reformers who sought to protect indigenous peoples (partly for moral, partly for fiscal reasons) and colonial settlers whose economic interests depended on indigenous forced labor; the violent resistance and suspension of key provisions shows the limits of metropolitan control over colonial society.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because the Crown did issue the New Laws under Las Casas's influence; the problem was not unwillingness to consider reform but the inability to enforce reform against settler resistance.
- C
- Incorrect because the Church's role was limited and internal; it was colonial settlers, not the Church, who had the decisive power to resist implementation, and no ecclesiastical intervention overrode their opposition.
- D
- Incorrect because the encomienda system was not successfully abolished; colonists' violent resistance forced the suspension of the most controversial provisions, and encomienda continued in modified forms for decades.