Skip to content
AP U.S. History · Period 2: 1607-1754

Taxation

Taxation appears in 4 reviewed AP U.S. History questions and sits in Period 2: 1607-1754. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

In this period, the developing colonial principle that a tax was legitimate only when an elected assembly voted it. Virginia's House of Burgesses, founded in 1619, set the precedent.

Why it matters

For over a century, colonial assemblies voted their own taxes. In Massachusetts and New York they also voted the governor's salary year by year, so a governor who fought them could lose his pay. Virginia was the exception. From 1680 its royal governors drew a permanent tobacco export duty, so the Burgesses could not squeeze them that way. That power of the purse turned an expectation of consent into real leverage. Colonists invoked it once Parliament taxed them after 1763.

How the exam tests it

Stems present the Burgesses and ask why it matters in American political history. The credited answer links the precedent of representative consent to the later case against taxation without representation — not democracy for all, since the governor kept a veto and the Virginia Company could overrule colonial law.

Don’t confuse it with

The imperial tax crisis of the Stamp Act and Townshend duties, which belongs to Period 3. Period 2 still had trade rules Parliament imposed with no colonial consent. The Navigation Acts from 1651 restricted colonial shipping. The Plantation Duty Act of 1673 charged the first real customs duty collected in the colonies, on enumerated goods shipped from one colony to another. The Molasses Act of 1733 added another. Loose enforcement, called salutary neglect, kept them from becoming a fight.

Taxation in real questions

Example 1Medium
"The House of Burgesses, established in Virginia in 1619, was the first representative assembly in colonial America. Delegates were elected from each jurisdiction and met annually to pass laws for the colony. While the governor retained veto power and the Virginia Company could override colonial legislation, the Burgesses established the precedent that colonial taxation required the consent of elected representatives." — Modern description of the House of Burgesses The House of Burgesses is most significant in American political history because it
  1. Aestablished universal suffrage as the governing principle of colonial Virginia by granting all adult residents regardless of property or gender the right to vote for representatives
  2. Bprovided a model of federalism in which local colonial assemblies and the central English government shared sovereignty, inspiring the later design of the Constitution
  3. Cdemonstrated that republican government was incompatible with slavery, since the existence of both institutions in Virginia created irreconcilable political contradictions
  4. Dcreated the precedent of representative self-governance in colonial America, which colonists later invoked to argue that taxation without representation was illegitimateCorrect

Why D is right

The House of Burgesses established the principle that colonial governance required the consent of elected representatives — a principle that colonists developed over more than a century of self-governance into the argument that Parliament could not legitimately tax them without colonial representation. When Britain began imposing new taxes after 1763, American colonists drew on this long tradition of representative self-governance to argue that 'taxation without representation is tyranny,' making the Burgesses an important precedent for Revolutionary-era political arguments.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because the House of Burgesses had significant property and gender restrictions on suffrage; women, enslaved people, indentured servants, and propertyless men were all excluded from voting, making it far from universal suffrage.
B
Incorrect because the House of Burgesses was not designed as a federalist system sharing sovereignty with Parliament; it was a colonial legislature that claimed local authority while acknowledging ultimate Parliamentary sovereignty, a claim that became contested only in the 1760s.
C
Incorrect because the House of Burgesses actually coexisted with and indeed supported slavery in Virginia; the legislature passed slave codes and protected planter interests, demonstrating that colonial representative government and slavery were not only compatible but mutually reinforcing.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Period 2: 1607-1754.