"In the space of three months, the Reverend George Whitefield preached to more than 30,000 people across New England. Men and women wept openly at his words; hardened farmers fell to their knees in the fields. Church membership surged. Traditional ministers complained that he stirred up emotions without sound doctrine."
— Modern historian describing the Great Awakening, c. 1740
The religious revivals described in this account most directly contributed to which of the following?
- AThe immediate political radicalization of colonists, producing organized demands for independence from Britain within a decade of the revivals' peak
- BA lasting decline in New England church attendance as established Congregationalist churches permanently lost their members to Whitefield's itinerant ministry
- CA broader cultural challenge to established hierarchies and deference to authority, as the emphasis on individual conversion democratized access to salvationCorrect
- DThe formal union of New England's Protestant denominations into a single established church capable of coordinating colonial missionary work more effectively
Why C is right
The Great Awakening (1730s-1740s) challenged established social hierarchies in multiple ways. By emphasizing that conversion was a personal, emotional experience available to all regardless of social status, education, or church membership, revivalists like Whitefield and Jonathan Edwards implicitly democratized spiritual authority. The itinerant preaching style itself was radical — bypassing parish boundaries and established ministerial credentials — and contributed to a broader cultural questioning of deference to traditional authorities that historians have connected to longer-term shifts toward Revolutionary-era egalitarianism.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while the Great Awakening's cultural effects may have contributed to longer-term changes in colonial attitudes toward authority, the direct causal link to political radicalization within a decade is overstated; the political effects were indirect and developed over decades.
- B
- Incorrect because the revivals actually increased church membership and religious participation overall; while some traditional churches did lose members to New Light congregations, the net effect was a surge in religious engagement, not decline.
- D
- Incorrect because the Great Awakening actually increased denominational diversity and religious competition rather than unifying denominations; the revivals created new denominations (Baptists and Methodists grew significantly) and caused splits within existing churches between New Lights and Old Lights.