- A
- Incorrect because the Republican Party was generally the party of the protective tariff, which benefited its manufacturer constituents; most Republicans remained hostile to the income tax as a threat to business and wealthy supporters, and Progressives like La Follette were a minority faction. The amendment was carried mainly by Democrats and Progressive Republicans against mainstream GOP resistance, not by an enthusiastic party consensus.
- B
- Incorrect because the redistributive rationale was central to the income tax's Progressive advocacy from the start, not added after ratification; Populist Party platforms in the 1890s had already demanded an income tax specifically to shift the tax burden from consumers to the wealthy, so La Follette's framing accurately represents the original reformist motivation rather than a later justification.
- C
- Incorrect because the Supreme Court ruling (Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust, 1895) declared income taxes on income from property to be unconstitutional direct taxes requiring apportionment — not all forms of taxation. The federal government still collected tariff revenue and other taxes, so the ruling was specific to income taxes and did not strip Congress of all revenue power.