Historical accounts of an incident on the Pine Ridge Reservation describe U.S. troops arriving at a Sioux encampment at dawn to disarm the band. Chief Big Foot, gravely ill with pneumonia, lay in a wagon during the standoff. A shot then rang out — its origin disputed to this day — and soldiers opened fire with Hotchkiss guns on the camp's tipis; of roughly four hundred seventy people present, nearly three hundred were killed or wounded.
Which of the following most directly led to the situation described above?
- AU.S. officials feared the Ghost Dance religious movement signaled an Indian uprising, prompting the troop buildup that ended in the killings at Wounded KneeCorrect
- BSitting Bull successfully united the Plains tribes into a sovereign confederation through diplomacy, which prompted the federal government to launch a preemptive military campaign to break it apart
- CSioux warriors launched a coordinated armed offensive against U.S. Army outposts to reclaim lands taken from them under the allotment provisions of the Dawes Act of 1887
- DThe Supreme Court's ruling in Lone Wolf v. Hitchcock authorized the Army to forcibly remove Sioux communities from their reservation to smaller assigned territories in Nebraska
Why A is right
The Ghost Dance religious movement, founded by Wovoka, spread among Plains tribes in 1889-1890, promising that special dances would bring back the buffalo, reunite the living with dead ancestors, and restore the pre-contact world. U.S. officials, already on edge after Sioux land reductions, interpreted the movement as prelude to warfare. The Army was mobilized, Sitting Bull was killed during his arrest on December 15, 1890, and the 7th Cavalry's attempt to disarm Big Foot's band on December 29 ended in the massacre of approximately 250-300 Sioux at Wounded Knee Creek.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because Sitting Bull was killed before Wounded Knee precisely because officials feared his influence over the Ghost Dance movement; there was no successful diplomatic confederation among Plains tribes — the movement was spiritual, not a military alliance.
- C
- Incorrect because the Sioux did not launch a coordinated military offensive; the Ghost Dance was a religious movement, not a military campaign; Big Foot's band was fleeing toward the Pine Ridge Reservation when surrounded, not attacking Army positions.
- D
- Incorrect because Lone Wolf v. Hitchcock was decided in 1903, thirteen years after Wounded Knee; the ruling that Congress had plenary power to break treaties without consent came long after the massacre and cannot be its cause.