"The present assault upon capital is but the beginning. It will be but a stepping-stone to others, larger and more sweeping, till our political contests will become a war of the poor against the rich; a war constantly growing in intensity and bitterness. If the court sanctions the power of vexatious and unequal taxation, it will mark the hour when the sure decrement of our government will commence."
-- Joseph Choate, attorney arguing against the federal income tax, Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co., 1895
Choate's argument most directly reflects which of the following perspectives common during the Gilded Age?
- AProgressive reformers' insistence that an activist government should regulate trusts and monopolies to protect ordinary consumers
- BPopulist farmers' demands for an inflationary monetary policy, such as free silver, to ease their crushing debt burdens
- CSocial Gospel advocates' conviction that Christian ethics obligated reformers to confront urban poverty
- DConservative elites' defense of private property rights and laissez-faire economics against government efforts to redistribute wealthCorrect
Why D is right
Choate frames the income tax as an assault on capital and a step toward class warfare. This reflects Gilded Age conservative elites who opposed government redistribution of wealth and defended private property rights, consistent with laissez-faire ideology.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Choate argues against government intervention, the opposite of the Progressive reformers' call for an activist regulatory state.
- B
- Incorrect because Populist farmers wanted government action to help debtors, while Choate speaks for the wealthy opponents of such intervention.
- C
- Incorrect because Social Gospel advocates urged action to address inequality and urban poverty, which Choate's defense of capital opposes.