"The Revolution... opened a new era in politics... [Women] have begun to think themselves capable of the exercise of their own reason, of forming their own sentiments, of exercising their own judgment... I know I am writing to a man, who not only feels her powers of discrimination, but who believes in the capacity of woman for mental and moral improvement." — Judith Sargent Murray, On the Equality of the Sexes, 1790
A historian could best use this source to support which of the following arguments?
- AThe Revolution immediately secured formal legal and political equality for women, as 'all men are created equal' was widely read to extend voting rights to women across the new states
- BSome women of the Revolutionary era drew on the era's intellectual climate to assert women's rational capacity and intellectual equality, pushing past the limits of Republican Motherhood ideologyCorrect
- CMurray's essay reached no meaningful audience because male-controlled publishing in the Revolutionary period entirely suppressed women's writing and barred them from print
- DRepublican Motherhood ideology was embraced universally by Revolutionary-generation women as a wholly satisfactory definition of their proper public and domestic roles
Why B is right
Judith Sargent Murray's essay is evidence that some Revolutionary-era women went beyond the 'Republican Motherhood' framework — which valued women as nurturers of virtuous citizens — to argue for women's intrinsic intellectual equality and capacity for reason. Murray's challenge to the assumption that women's mental capacity was inferior to men's was a significant, if limited, feminist intervention in Revolutionary-era political culture that pointed toward later women's rights movements.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because the Revolution did not produce formal legal or political equality for women; women were excluded from voting (with brief exceptions like New Jersey until 1807), lost property rights in marriage, and held no formal political standing.
- C
- Incorrect because Murray did publish and circulate her work; she appeared in the Massachusetts Magazine and was known in her intellectual community, so women's intellectual production, though constrained, was not entirely suppressed.
- D
- Incorrect because the passage shows Murray arguing for women's equal rational capacity, which goes beyond Republican Motherhood; it gives no evidence of universal acceptance of that ideology, but rather a challenge to its limitations.