"The doctrine of nullification holds that a state has the right to declare null and void any federal law that it deems unconstitutional. If a state nullifies a federal law, then the federal government cannot enforce that law within the state. If the federal government attempts to use force to compel the state to comply, the state has the right to secede from the Union. This doctrine, first articulated in 1798, has been revived in South Carolina in 1832 with respect to the tariff." — Nullification crisis summary, 2004
Which of the following most directly led to the situation described in this passage?
- AJohn C. Calhoun developed nullification theory as a constitutional mechanism to shield Southern interests — especially slavery — from federal legislationCorrect
- BAndrew Jackson, who had personally endorsed nullification before his presidency, signaled to South Carolina that federal enforcement of the tariff was unlikely to occur
- CA constitutional amendment ratified in 1830 expressly granted states authority to nullify federal revenue laws, which South Carolina then invoked against the tariff of 1828
- DThe Supreme Court's recognition of state nullification rights in McCulloch v. Maryland, a precedent Calhoun cited to justify South Carolina's resistance to the tariff
Why A is right
Calhoun developed nullification theory in response to the 'Tariff of Abominations' (1828), which hurt Southern states that were export-dependent agricultural economies. But nullification was also motivated by the deeper fear that if Congress could regulate tariffs, it might eventually regulate or abolish slavery. Calhoun constructed the compact theory of the Constitution (states created the federal government and could judge its acts) as a constitutional barrier protecting Southern states' right to maintain slavery from federal interference.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because Jackson was a fierce opponent of nullification; he issued a Proclamation to the People of South Carolina (1832) declaring nullification unconstitutional and treasonous, and threatened military force to compel South Carolina's compliance.
- C
- Incorrect because no such constitutional amendment was passed; the nullification doctrine had no formal constitutional basis and was rejected by Jackson, Clay, and Webster as unconstitutional; South Carolina acted without any legal authorization beyond Calhoun's theoretical argument.
- D
- Incorrect because McCulloch v. Maryland (1819) upheld federal power over state power and explicitly rejected state interference with federal authority; it was the opposite of a precedent for nullification.
"We, the people of the State of South Carolina, in convention assembled, do declare and ordain that the several acts and parts of acts of the Congress of the United States, purporting to be laws for the imposing of duties and imposts on the importation of foreign commodities... are unauthorized by the Constitution of the United States, and violate the true meaning and intent thereof, and are null, void, and no law."
-- South Carolina Ordinance of Nullification, November 24, 1832
The constitutional theory underlying this document is most similar to which of the following?
- AAlexander Hamilton's argument for a broad interpretation of the Necessary and Proper Clause to expand the powers of the national government
- BJohn Marshall's ruling in McCulloch v. Maryland affirming federal supremacy over state laws
- CThe Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions' claim that states could judge the constitutionality of federal lawsCorrect
- DThe Northwest Ordinance's provisions establishing the process for organizing territories and admitting new states to the Union
Why C is right
South Carolina's Ordinance of Nullification drew on the same compact theory articulated in the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions (1798-1799), authored by Madison and Jefferson. Both held that states could judge whether the federal government had exceeded its powers.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because Hamilton's broad construction of federal power is the opposite of nullification, which rests on a narrow, states'-rights reading of the Constitution.
- B
- Incorrect because Marshall's ruling affirmed federal supremacy, directly contradicting the compact theory that underlies nullification.
- D
- Incorrect because the Northwest Ordinance addressed organizing territories and admitting states, not a state's authority to nullify federal laws.