Historians commonly describe the Palmer Raids of 1919-1920 this way: after a series of mail bombings and alarm over the Bolshevik Revolution in Russia, Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer ordered raids on the offices of socialist, communist, and labor organizations across the country. Roughly 10,000 people were arrested, many without warrants, and thousands faced deportation without due process. J. Edgar Hoover, then head of the Justice Department's new General Intelligence Division, directed the operations.
The Palmer Raids most directly reflected which political phenomenon of the immediate post-World War I period?
- AThe labor movement's own self-regulation, since the AFL cooperated with Palmer's raids to eliminate communist influence in trade unions competing with AFL affiliates for members
- BThe American government's legitimate concern about Soviet espionage, since many of the organizations raided were later proven to have been directed by Soviet intelligence agents
- CThe First Red Scare, in which fear of Bolshevism and radical labor organizing combined with wartime xenophobia to produce a repressive crackdown on civil liberties and political dissentCorrect
- DA bipartisan response to actual revolutionary threats, since both Democrats and Republicans supported the raids as necessary security measures against proven conspiracies against the government
Why C is right
The Palmer Raids exemplify the First Red Scare — the period of intense anti-radical repression (1919-1920) driven by fear of Bolshevism following the Russian Revolution, anxieties about radical labor organizing amid a major strike wave, and the xenophobic associations of radicalism with foreign-born immigrant workers. The raids violated Fourth Amendment protections against warrantless searches and Fifth Amendment due process protections, and many of those arrested had committed no crimes. The raids ultimately discredited Palmer when his predictions of revolutionary uprising on May Day 1920 proved false, but they established precedents for government surveillance of political dissent that J. Edgar Hoover would maintain for decades.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because while the AFL did oppose communist influence in labor, the AFL did not 'cooperate with' or support Palmer's illegal mass raids; the AFL had its own approaches to dealing with radical competition that were distinct from government repression.
- B
- Incorrect because characterizing the raids as 'legitimate' based on later Soviet espionage revelations applies hindsight inappropriately; the organizations raided were primarily labor and political organizations rather than proven spy rings, and the raids' methods (mass arrests without warrants, deportations without due process) were illegal regardless of the organizations' actual connections.
- D
- Incorrect because the raids were not bipartisan; many Republicans criticized Palmer's violations of civil liberties, and civil libertarians across party lines condemned the raids; characterizing them as a bipartisan consensus response misrepresents the political reality.
Read the following description and answer the question.
Historians note that leaders of the newly founded American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) argued in 1920 that the government could not claim to be protecting national security while using the Espionage Act and Sedition Act to silence domestic political critics. They pointed to the imprisonment of Eugene Debs for delivering an antiwar speech and the U.S. Post Office's banning of The Masses magazine from the mail as evidence that the government was suppressing dissent rather than defending the country from foreign enemies.
The organization described most directly emerged in response to which of the following developments?
- AThe failure of Progressive Era reform to produce sufficient legal protections for workers' right to organize and strike without criminal prosecution
- BThe Palmer Raids of 1919-1920 that targeted immigrant radical organizations, which ACLU founders believed required a permanent organization to defend civil liberties in future emergencies
- CThe systematic suppression of political dissent during and after World War I through the Espionage Act, Sedition Act, and the Red Scare's deportation of radical immigrantsCorrect
- DThe Supreme Court's ruling in Schenck v. United States that upheld the constitutionality of the Espionage Act, which ACLU founders sought to reverse through test litigation
Why C is right
The ACLU was founded in 1920 specifically in response to WWI-era civil liberties violations: the Espionage Act (1917), Sedition Act (1918), imprisonment of Debs and other dissenters, post-war Red Scare deportations, and suppression of radical publications like The Masses.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- While labor rights were among the ACLU's concerns, the organization's founding was specifically motivated by the WWI-era political suppression of speech and press, not primarily by labor-specific criminal prosecutions.
- B
- The Palmer Raids were part of the pattern that motivated the ACLU's founding, but the description also references Debs's imprisonment and magazine censorship — the WWI-era suppression generally, not Palmer Raids specifically.
- D
- While Schenck was important, the ACLU's founding responded to the broader pattern of suppression, not specifically to one Supreme Court case; and the ACLU pursued litigation to protect civil liberties, not specifically to reverse Schenck (which remained precedent for decades).
In a March 1954 episode of his CBS television program See It Now, the broadcast journalist Edward R. Murrow criticized Senator Joseph McCarthy, pointing out that the number of alleged communists McCarthy claimed to have identified in the State Department kept changing from speech to speech and arguing that McCarthy treated any disagreement as evidence of communist sympathy.
A historian could best use this source to support which of the following arguments?
- AMurrow's broadcast reflected the consensus of an American media establishment that had vigorously and consistently opposed McCarthy from the very start of his anticommunist campaign in 1950
- BThe broadcast immediately ended McCarthy's influence, prompting the Senate to vote his censure the following week amid an overwhelming wave of public outcry against him
- CMcCarthy was ultimately vindicated when his claim that the State Department harbored 205 communist agents was substantiated, confirming the soundness of his investigative methods
- DMcCarthy's anticommunism relied more on intimidation and shifting accusations than on evidence, and a free press could check such political demagoguery by exposing its methodsCorrect
Why D is right
Murrow's March 1954 See It Now broadcast on McCarthy — noting the inconsistency of the charges and characterizing McCarthyism as a threat to civil liberties — is one of the most celebrated examples of investigative broadcast journalism. It demonstrated that the press could effectively challenge political demagoguery by exposing its methods. The broadcast contributed to McCarthy's eventual decline, along with the Army-McCarthy hearings and Joseph Welch's famous 'Have you no sense of decency?' rebuke. Murrow's willingness to take a clear position — unusual for the cautious broadcast industry — illustrates both the potential and the difficulty of journalistic accountability.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- A
- Incorrect because most American media had been too cautious to challenge McCarthy before Murrow; many newspapers and broadcasters had treated his accusations with deference rather than skepticism, and Murrow's broadcast was exceptional precisely because so few had taken such a critical stance.
- B
- Incorrect because McCarthy's censure did not come immediately after Murrow's broadcast; the censure vote came in December 1954, nine months later, and was triggered more by the Army-McCarthy hearings and his attacks on the military than by the broadcast alone.
- C
- Incorrect because McCarthy's State Department charges were never proven; no list of 205 communist agents was ever substantiated, and the changing numbers Murrow highlights reflect the fabricated nature of the accusations.