Skip to content
AP U.S. History · Period 3: 1754-1800

Press freedom

Press freedom appears in 4 reviewed AP U.S. History questions and sits in Period 3: 1754-1800. Below are worked examples showing exactly how the exam tests it, with the answer marked and every distractor explained.

Freedom of the press is the principle that government cannot punish people for publishing criticism of officials. In this period it was written into the First Amendment in 1791 and immediately tested by the Sedition Act of 1798, which made it a crime to print false, scandalous, or malicious attacks on the federal government.

Why it matters

The Sedition Act proved that a written guarantee does not enforce itself. Federal prosecutors targeted Democratic-Republican editors and politicians — Congressman Matthew Lyon was fined and jailed for four months, then re-elected from his cell. The backlash cost the Federalists the presidency and Congress in 1800. The party held on regionally in New England into 1816, but it never won the presidency again.

How the exam tests it

The press-freedom item on this page is not a Period 3 item. It belongs to Period 8. It describes Edward R. Murrow's March 1954 See It Now broadcast on Senator Joseph McCarthy, and asks what a historian could argue from it. Pick the answer that McCarthy relied on intimidation and shifting accusations rather than evidence, and that a free press can check a demagogue by exposing his methods. For Period 3 itself, carry the Sedition Act prosecutions of Matthew Lyon, Thomas Cooper, and James Callender as background knowledge.

Don’t confuse it with

The Zenger trial of 1735, where a New York jury acquitted a printer of seditious libel because what he published was true. That verdict moved public opinion but set no binding precedent. The Sedition Act of 1798 in fact put Zenger's two principles into statute: Section 3 let a defendant prove truth, and let the jury decide the law as well as the facts. Prosecutions still succeeded, because Federalist judges treated political opinion as if it were an assertion of fact the defendant had to prove true — and opinion cannot be proven, so the truth defense was unavailable in practice.

Press freedom in real questions

Example 1Medium
In a March 1954 episode of his CBS television program See It Now, the broadcast journalist Edward R. Murrow criticized Senator Joseph McCarthy, pointing out that the number of alleged communists McCarthy claimed to have identified in the State Department kept changing from speech to speech and arguing that McCarthy treated any disagreement as evidence of communist sympathy. A historian could best use this source to support which of the following arguments?
  1. AMurrow's broadcast reflected the consensus of an American media establishment that had vigorously and consistently opposed McCarthy from the very start of his anticommunist campaign in 1950
  2. BThe broadcast immediately ended McCarthy's influence, prompting the Senate to vote his censure the following week amid an overwhelming wave of public outcry against him
  3. CMcCarthy was ultimately vindicated when his claim that the State Department harbored 205 communist agents was substantiated, confirming the soundness of his investigative methods
  4. DMcCarthy's anticommunism relied more on intimidation and shifting accusations than on evidence, and a free press could check such political demagoguery by exposing its methodsCorrect

Why D is right

Murrow's March 1954 See It Now broadcast on McCarthy — noting the inconsistency of the charges and characterizing McCarthyism as a threat to civil liberties — is one of the most celebrated examples of investigative broadcast journalism. It demonstrated that the press could effectively challenge political demagoguery by exposing its methods. The broadcast contributed to McCarthy's eventual decline, along with the Army-McCarthy hearings and Joseph Welch's famous 'Have you no sense of decency?' rebuke. Murrow's willingness to take a clear position — unusual for the cautious broadcast industry — illustrates both the potential and the difficulty of journalistic accountability.
Why the other 3 choices miss
A
Incorrect because most American media had been too cautious to challenge McCarthy before Murrow; many newspapers and broadcasters had treated his accusations with deference rather than skepticism, and Murrow's broadcast was exceptional precisely because so few had taken such a critical stance.
B
Incorrect because McCarthy's censure did not come immediately after Murrow's broadcast; the censure vote came in December 1954, nine months later, and was triggered more by the Army-McCarthy hearings and his attacks on the military than by the broadcast alone.
C
Incorrect because McCarthy's State Department charges were never proven; no list of 205 communist agents was ever substantiated, and the changing numbers Murrow highlights reflect the fabricated nature of the accusations.

Studied alongside

Other concepts from Period 3: 1754-1800.