Historians have documented that in his writings and speeches on segregation and disfranchisement during the late 1880s and early 1890s, Frederick Douglass argued that the white South did not primarily fear Black poverty or ignorance. Rather, he contended that Black economic and political advancement provoked the fiercest white resistance, and that disfranchisement laws and Jim Crow statutes were designed to deny full equality to successful, propertied, educated Black Americans — not merely to control the "ignorant and degraded."
Which of the following most directly challenged this viewpoint?
- ABooker T. Washington's view that economic success through industrial education would gradually overcome discrimination and earn white Southern acceptance of Black advancementCorrect
- BW.E.B. Du Bois's argument that only rigorous academic education for a Talented Tenth, rather than industrial training, could overcome white resistance to full Black equality
- CSouthern newspaper editors who insisted that disfranchisement laws were designed merely to prevent electoral fraud and corruption, not to suppress Black political and economic advancement
- DThe Supreme Court's ruling in Plessy v. Ferguson that separate-but-equal facilities were constitutionally permissible for the races under the Fourteenth Amendment
Why A is right
Douglass's documented critique — that it is Black success and equality, not Black degradation, that the white South truly fears — directly challenges Washington's optimistic accommodationism. Washington believed that economic achievement through industrial education would gradually win white Southern acceptance and break down discrimination. Douglass's writings on disfranchisement and Jim Crow in this era already articulated why this theory was flawed: white resistance intensified precisely when Black Americans succeeded economically or politically, because the goal was maintaining racial hierarchy, not managing ignorance or poverty.
Why the other 3 choices miss
- B
- Incorrect because Du Bois's argument about the Talented Tenth largely supported Douglass's diagnosis — that Black intellectual and economic achievement was essential and deserving of full equality — rather than challenging it; Du Bois agreed with Douglass that discrimination targeted Black success.
- C
- Incorrect because Southern newspaper editors who defended disfranchisement are challenging Douglass's interpretation but from a pro-segregationist position that Douglass would see as confirmation of his argument; this is not the most significant intellectual challenge to his viewpoint in the reform debate.
- D
- Incorrect because Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) was a Supreme Court ruling that confirmed the constitutionality of segregation; it did not 'challenge' Douglass's viewpoint in the sense of offering an alternative path to equality — it was a legal endorsement of the system Douglass was critiquing.